I hate numpads on laptops, the force you to sit slightly off center from the screen and i never use them.
thats why i proposed the screen touchpad ;-)
I think it should be like a $49 build to order option on the 17". Some people, me included, do not want it as standard, as it off centres the keyboard. Plus, I used to have an HP Pavilion Dv9600, and it had a 17" screen and the number pad. I don't recall using it more than 3 or 4 times in the two years I owned it. Plus, with a BTO option, the people who want it could get it, and everyone would be happy.
ill tell you a little story and then explain why i said it (if you still dont get it xD).
Some ash from my cigarette fell on my "o" in my
unibody macbook (while still hot) and burned it. It still works but u have to press a little harder.
I called apple to see how much this is gonna cost to repair, they said around 150euros. Obviously i was surprised, its just a damn button! When i told them that, they said "we can't replace 1 button, you need to change the whole keyboard". (and maybe the whole bottom case,i don't remember).
My point is, a BTO option for a numpad will cost a lot a lot more because they have to make a whole new bottom case, new keyboards for this to work.
To be honest, 50 euros seems reasonable for a numpad that way (reasonable in apple prices, not normal

), but since they're apple, i don't see that happening. Maybe at 100.
But as some people here said, the keyboard on the 17 inch does look small compared to the size of the laptop, so why not put a numpad on it?