Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
what am I missing out on? Different color bubbles? Big whoop!

Well, to each their own. I’ve tried most of the messaging apps and WhatsApp is still my favourite (also the most used one globally), simply because I prefer its UI (user interface). Personally, I can’t stand the interface and all the, imo, useless gimmicks in Messages (iMessage).
 
Surprising that nobody has really mentioned Snapchat and Facebook messenger, those (along with WhatsApp) are the go to messaging apps. Nobody has really used texts since about 2012, which most of people see iMessage as an extension of. The only time you would use texts/iMessage (yes I know technically they are different but most lump them in together and they use the same app) are for parents/elderly relatives, dealers, or formal situations such as work (and even in the latter situation this is ever increasingly likely to be WhatsApp) This is in the UK and I believe the situation is similar in continental Europe. iMessage may well be bigger in the US though
 
Surprising that nobody has really mentioned Snapchat and Facebook messenger, those (along with WhatsApp) are the go to messaging apps. Nobody has really used texts since about 2012, which most of people see iMessage as an extension of. The only time you would use texts/iMessage (yes I know technically they are different but most lump them in together and they use the same app) are for parents/elderly relatives, dealers, or formal situations such as work (and even in the latter situation this is ever increasingly likely to be WhatsApp) This is in the UK and I believe the situation is similar in continental Europe. iMessage may well be bigger in the US though
I guess t 33 I’m considered elderly. Never used Facebook messenger once it became stand alone and don’t really understand the appeal of snap
 
I guess t 33 I’m considered elderly. Never used Facebook messenger once it became stand alone and don’t really understand the appeal of snap

Well, I’m 10 years older, but I use Facebook Messenger quite often - not by choice, but because I have a family group-chat there, also some people tend to message me there. I didn’t mention those options because it seemed to me that the OP was asking about messaging apps that require your phone number - which Facebook don’t (even though they keep nagging about it - fu@k ’em), but iMessage, WhatsApp, Telegram and the others do. Fortunately, they all offer end-to-end encryption. However, I honestly don’t see that advantage of Telegram over WhatsApp (haven’t tried Signal yet, as none of my contacts use it), because in WhatsApp end-to-end encryption is on by default, while in Telegram you have to manually activate it for each conversation, which I find annoying.

(Never used Snap, btw.)
 
SMS messages are fine until you send multimedia. Pictures and videos. Granted in this day with more people staying home due to the pandemic, it’s harder to see the benefits. At least it is for me. But it will be priceless when my wife wants to send me a short video of my daughter at dance class or I want to send her something that my son is doing. Can that stuff wait until we both get home? Of course. But sometimes she’ll forget to show the video because of the busyness. And it’s nice to have a copy of it on my phone to go back and reminisce. There are work arounds on Android such as sharing it through Google Photos, which I’ve done in the past with success. But it’s not as instant as iMessage. You have to wait for the photo or video to upload to Google Photos then you can share it. I love the features of iMessage but I also hate that it’s only available to iOS users. We may never see a true competitor to it on Android. That generally is not good for business. Because what if Android had something comparable or slightly better? That competition would drive Apple to further innovate to make it better. So we may never see a true competitor nor see any noticeable improvements with iMessage.
 
Ecosystem integration and more importantly...it's kind of a "legacy app" in its own right at this point. It was one of the first apps out there that allowed for texting with a phone number via WiFi. Tons of apps have done it since, but Apple was there first or close to it. Eventually we all kind of just keep using what we're used to using.
 
In the US people are fine with SMS and it’s free so it’s seamless with iMessage. You don’t have to think about it. Blue is iPhone and green is non iPhone.

From what I understand Europe still charges for SMS so it makes sense why WhatsApp and others are popular.
 
From what I understand Europe still charges for SMS so it makes sense why WhatsApp and others are popular.

Nah, they don’t. Not even Mexico charges for sms, yet WhatsApp is by far the preferred messaging app by individuals and businesses. I believe it’s because WhatsApp has a superior user interface (just imo), and of course because it works across platforms (more people here, and in Europe, use Android phones compared to the US, I believe.).
 
  • Like
Reactions: secretk
Nah, they don’t. Not even Mexico charges for sms, yet WhatsApp is by far the preferred messaging app by individuals and businesses. I believe it’s because WhatsApp has a superior user interface (just imo), and of course because it works across platforms (more people here, and in Europe, use Android phones compared to the US, I believe.).

Yep the popularity of WhatsApp is literally because of cross platform peer pressure mostly. Don’t think interface plays as much role as being able to send pictures / videos for free over the internet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: secretk
Surprising that nobody has really mentioned Snapchat and Facebook messenger, those (along with WhatsApp) are the go to messaging apps. Nobody has really used texts since about 2012, which most of people see iMessage as an extension of. The only time you would use texts/iMessage (yes I know technically they are different but most lump them in together and they use the same app) are for parents/elderly relatives, dealers, or formal situations such as work (and even in the latter situation this is ever increasingly likely to be WhatsApp) This is in the UK and I believe the situation is similar in continental Europe. iMessage may well be bigger in the US though
Some very big assumptions there .... although in fairness I note that you say you are talking about the UK ....... but to say "Nobody has really used texts since about 2012" is quite sweeping ....... there is a big wide world outside of the UK and US ....... many millions of users in developing countries rely on SMS and many developed countries use SMS in various scenarios beyond chatting with friends .... and not every part of the world uses snap and FB ....... lots of popular messaging platforms out there in various corners of the world !
 
  • Like
Reactions: remington79
Some very big assumptions there .... although in fairness I note that you say you are talking about the UK ....... but to say "Nobody has really used texts since about 2012" is quite sweeping ....... there is a big wide world outside of the UK and US ....... many millions of users in developing countries rely on SMS and many developed countries use SMS in various scenarios beyond chatting with friends .... and not every part of the world uses snap and FB ....... lots of popular messaging platforms out there in various corners of the world !
In my country we rarely use SMS to chat with friends. I receive SMS but it is related to services - like delivery statuses, card payments, stuff like that.

In my country people use different apps for sharing media and it is a choice between Messenger, Viber and WhatsApp. They are all cross platform, but the annoying thing is that you would have different groups of friends and they would use different services and you might need to install multiple apps for the same thing. iMessage on the other hand works only for iPhones and those are not that often used in my country as well.

So while iMessage exists to address meaningful needs until it is cross platform it cannot be used properly in our country.
 
Here in the US iMessage and SMS switches automatically. Most people just text and if you have an iPhone it picks iMessage. I have a group text where there is that one friend that has an Android so it’s all in regular SMS.

Most phone plans are unlimited text and data so sending pictures and videos over SMS to the few people hasn’t been a problem. Just hit the text app and their name and type. No trying to remember if they’re on Telegram or Signal and opening up the appropriate app. No one uses WhatsApp because there’s no need and because it’s owned by Facebook. And out of our group of friends only one has a Facebook page. The rest of us haven’t had one and don’t want one.
 
Here in the US iMessage and SMS switches automatically. Most people just text and if you have an iPhone it picks iMessage. I have a group text where there is that one friend that has an Android so it’s all in regular SMS.
Btw maybe I am doing something wrong but I cannot send SMS with iMessage without mobile data. I can with regular SMS service on my Android phone so I am not sure what I am doing wrong with iMessage.
Most phone plans are unlimited text and data so sending pictures and videos over SMS to the few people hasn’t been a problem. Just hit the text app and their name and type. No trying to remember if they’re on Telegram or Signal and opening up the appropriate app. No one uses WhatsApp because there’s no need and because it’s owned by Facebook. And out of our group of friends only one has a Facebook page. The rest of us haven’t had one and don’t want one.
Yes I do get annoyed that we do not have one app that we all use but you have to remember who uses which client etc. Honestly for me it is annoying. People here actually use those apps not just for the texting but for the calls. We have unlimited data and texts too but not unlimited minutes. People use those apps both for testing and free video/audio calls as long as they are connected to WIFI or mobile data. Basically they are iMessage plus Facetime and as most of the people here do not own an iPhone, this is why for our country those apps are popular.
 
In my country we rarely use SMS to chat with friends. I receive SMS but it is related to services - like delivery statuses, card payments, stuff like that.

In my country people use different apps for sharing media and it is a choice between Messenger, Viber and WhatsApp. They are all cross platform, but the annoying thing is that you would have different groups of friends and they would use different services and you might need to install multiple apps for the same thing. iMessage on the other hand works only for iPhones and those are not that often used in my country as well.

So while iMessage exists to address meaningful needs until it is cross platform it cannot be used properly in our country.

Curious, is this in the Philippines? I think that's one of the handful of countries that use Viber. I know in Thailand, LINE is the most used.

Majority of my friends and family in PH, I just contact via Facebook Messenger. I've noticed they change phone numbers quite often so it's hard to keep track of their current number with the phone-based messaging apps.

SMS/MMS is still universal. I wish there was a successor to it that will simply work on all devices (at least ones manufactured after a certain date). RCS isn't exactly serving its purpose.
 
Last edited:
Curious, is this in the Philippines? I think that's one of the handful of countries that use Viber. I know in Thailand, LINE is the most used.

Majority of my friends and family in PH, I just contact via Facebook Messenger. I've noticed they change phone numbers quite often so it's hard to keep track of their current number with the phone-based messaging apps.
Bulgaria. I hate Viber but man is it widely used here :D . One another thing I forgot to mention - here people also do not own Macbooks. So being able to install Viber or Whatsapp on their Windows computer works wonders.

In other words iMessage makes sense in places where people own iPhones and Macbooks. In places where that's not the case, people turn to other platforms and thus make iMessage obsolete even for the few people that have an iPhone.

Interesting that they change phone numbers frequently. Here we change providers but we can keep our phone numbers when moving to another provider. So that's handy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rui no onna
Bulgaria. I hate Viber but man is it widely used here :D . One another thing I forgot to mention - here people also do not own Macbooks. So being able to install Viber or Whatsapp on their Windows computer works wonders.

In other words iMessage makes sense in places where people own iPhones and Macbooks. In places where that's not the case, people turn to other platforms and thus make iMessage obsolete even for the few people that have an iPhone.

Interesting that they change phone numbers frequently. Here we change providers but we can keep our phone numbers when moving to another provider. So that's handy.

Alas, there's no number portability in PH, I think. The area code is tied to the carrier.

Yep, having Viber access on multiple devices is useful. I have it set up on 1x iPhone and 3x iPads. I just wish you can use it on more than one phone. One of my gripes with WhatsApp, I can't use it on a tablet on the same account as the smartphone. I rarely use the home PC and I don't want my personal messages on my work PC so WhatsApp effectively works on just one device for me.

One of the things I like best about iMessage/iOS Messages app is the fact that I get all my messages including SMS synced across multiple devices. Obviously not for Windows but I can send and receive messages to my primary number on all my iPhones and iPads. Something I find incredibly useful.

Same for FB Messenger. Simultaneous multi-device support is very important to me.
 
Alas, there's no number portability in PH, I think. The area code is tied to the carrier.
I see. Then I understand why people change phone numbers regularly :).
Yep, having Viber access on multiple devices is useful. I have it set up on 1x iPhone and 3x iPads. I just wish you can use it on more than one phone. One of my gripes with WhatsApp, I can't use it on a tablet on the same account as the smartphone. I rarely use the home PC and I don't want my personal messages on my work PC so WhatsApp effectively works on just one device for me.
I see. Interesting. I do not use those apps as I am like an old woman. If it is a phone I use it for phone calls. If it would be media sending, I do it on my laptop or iPad but rarely the phone. I just hate using the phone for things like that - the screen is not big enough for me, texting is slow. I am weird :D.
One of the things I like best about iMessage/iOS Messages app is the fact that I get all my messages including SMS synced across multiple devices. Obviously not for Windows but I can send and receive messages to my primary number on all my iPhones and iPads. Something I find incredibly useful.
The idea sounds awesome but the syncing is rather buggy. My iPad receives the messages like few hours late. So I like the idea but I am not sure that I can use it properly with those delays and bugs.
Same for FB Messenger. Simultaneous multi-device support is very important to me.
Wait I have had FB messenger on multiple phones - personal and work one and on the iPad and on the Windows laptop. I have not had issues with that. What problems you have with the Messenger?
 
Nah, they don’t. Not even Mexico charges for sms, yet WhatsApp is by far the preferred messaging app by individuals and businesses. I believe it’s because WhatsApp has a superior user interface (just imo), and of course because it works across platforms (more people here, and in Europe, use Android phones compared to the US, I believe.).
What about if let’s say I’m in the UK I text someone in Spain, do I get charged for SMS?
 
I believe so unless your sending an iMessage to another iPhone user. Otherwise you’d have to use a third party app like what’s app
Do people still get charged for sending sms and mms in this day and age? Surly not.

Sms and mms has been free for a while here in Australia. 🦘🇦🇺
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robbosan
Do people still get charged for sending sms and mms in this day and age? Surly not.

Sms and mms has been free for a while here in Australia. 🦘🇦🇺
SMS is free if it’s sent in the UK but MMS messages are charged at 55 p a message which is ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.