I'm surprised I'm only the 2nd person to say BEST BUY.
They are the ONLY retailer who offers accidental damage coverage. And their policy? If they can't fix it, they replace it. If you have patience, you could potentially end up with a brand new one in a couple of years for the price of a service plan. Not to mention peace of mind (for myself at least). Not to mention matching the educational discount (got my 13" MBP for $1099+tax), Reward Zone points, and special financing. WIN FOR ME!
(Please don't anyone try to dispute me, let's stay on topic 🙄... seems to be a lot of Best Buy haters around the MR boards, so let's just focus our attention on the question at hand😀)