Fully agree. I ordered Starlight a week ago, after expecting I would go with Midnight since the colors were unveiled in June. The more I looked at photos of both, the more Midnight just looked dark gray, like my work laptop, and the more Starlight looked like white gold or a very warm silver, and I liked it. And I have never wanted a gold laptop or phone before.
I finally saw the machines in person in a store today. In good light, I saw more blue in the Midnight than I had expected, but when the sun went behind a cloud and the otherwise well-lit Apple store got a bit dimmer, it shifted to a dark gray. The issue with fingerprints bothered me less than I expected, but they certainly were visible.
Meanwhile, Starlight looked fantastic regardless of the kind or amount of light it was getting. Like you said, it just seems to exude value in a very classy, understated fashion.
Mine arrives on Monday, if UPS's projections hold. Hope you'd don't have to wait too much longer for yours!