Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I prefer 3GS because it just feels more comfortable in my hands. The iPhone 4's edges "cut" into my hand when I grip it. And since I have small hands, no matter how I tried, my pinkie always end up covering the antenna gate and the signal always dropped. I just wish the 3GS has Retina Display.
 
Battery in the 4 is pretty rubbish too imo.

Glass back and battery is making me go off the iPhone, especially now that everyone has one. 2-3 years ago I was the only one in my office with one, now 1 in 4 people have one.

I don't know how much more improved the battery is over the 3G but it's definitely improved.

As for everyone having one, in tech that is good. That means more appeal for developers to make programs for the thing and well, with computers, the more programs, the more functionality they can do. And that's really the most important part.

I don't get people who bitch their computers/phones are too popular. Use it cause it does what you want and is very useful. If you really care about how cool you look or different, get a unique car! Wear some nifty clothes. Those don't matter if they are unique, they're still useful for what they're for.

I prefer 3GS because it just feels more comfortable in my hands. The iPhone 4's edges "cut" into my hand when I grip it. And since I have small hands, no matter how I tried, my pinkie always end up covering the antenna gate and the signal always dropped. I just wish the 3GS has Retina Display.

I have small hands and have no issue with the 4. I admit I did eventually put a case around it but that's more cause I'm paranoid of dropping it with its glass front and back (I know I will, I already have a few times).

Plus honestly, the case makes it easier to grip without it falling out of my hands so it's an extra benefit there too.
 
I don't know how much more improved the battery is over the 3G but it's definitely improved.

As for everyone having one, in tech that is good. That means more appeal for developers to make programs for the thing and well, with computers, the more programs, the more functionality they can do. And that's really the most important part.

I don't get people who bitch their computers/phones are too popular. Use it cause it does what you want and is very useful. If you really care about how cool you look or different, get a unique car! Wear some nifty clothes. Those don't matter if they are unique, they're still useful for what they're for.

My 3G would last over 48 hours with aprox 30 mins calls, checking emails, light browsing and ocassional app use. My 2 month old iP4 barely lasts 36 hours.

With regard to the 'popular' comment, I always prefer gadgets when not many other people have them. In addition, as far as the iPhone is concerned, Apple as a company have changed (for the worse) with both being cocky over the death-grip issue, and this integrated sim-card proposal, which will suck for the customer. Just my opinion
 
My 3G would last over 48 hours with aprox 30 mins calls, checking emails, light browsing and ocassional app use. My 2 month old iP4 barely lasts 36 hours.

I just know i use up less battery with my usual daily use on my 4 than my 3G. Most of my use though is browsing the web (vs. phone calls, I very rarely use the actual phone part).

With regard to the 'popular' comment, I always prefer gadgets when not many other people have them.

That's fine and dandy when they are a gadget that is not designed to install and run programs (and just has one use that it was made for). Not so fine and dandy when they are more like a mini computer where the actual functionality is the stuff you install on it. What good is a mac for example if there are no programs you can run on it?

In addition, as far as the iPhone is concerned, Apple as a company have changed (for the worse) with both being cocky over the death-grip issue, and this integrated sim-card proposal, which will suck for the customer. Just my opinion

I think their hardware quality has gone downhill (Though my basis of comparison is my two laptops I have had from them in the past three years vs. desktops so maybe I'm being a bit unfair. I'm getting the impression laptops in general don't tend to fair as well as desktops).

But honestly, I remember back when I had my performa, I never really saw them as having good customer service (quite the opposite but I barely had to use it, I usually just fuxored with my own computer and fixed it myself. But I was unimpressed the one time I did try to use it). That seemed to be a reputation they gained around 2000?

I have always liked the Macintosh computer but I can say I can't honestly say I've always liked Apple (fact for a while in the 90's I was ticked at htem for not marketing better and killing my favorite computer. I mean there was very little made for it and who is going to buy a computer that doesn't do much no matter how nice it is). Shoot, I have an iphone and love it now, but when it first came out I was making fun of it and thinking Apple should stick to computers. In fact I'd still be very pissed if Apple did abandon the Mac cause that's still the product I am dedicated to but I'll give hte ipod/iphone props cause it has seemed to bring more people into trying out Macs (and it seems you can find a lot more stuff for hte mac these days). So even if I didn't have an iphone or ipod, at this point I'm appreciative that they did go into different markets cause it seems to have brought more people to Macs. And more people = more software = computer is more flexible and powerful cause it can do more.

As for the antenna thing, honestly, I do think they handled it wrong from a marketing standpoint. What they really shoudl have done is just put it in the instruction manual to not hold it there (one of my Nokia phones actually had that in its instruction manual not to hold the phone at a certain place so it really is not unheard of for a cellphone to have certain spots that should not be held). Make it that is how it is supposed to be operated. Rather than pretend it didn't exist and make it look like a bug. It honestly really isn't that big of an issue. People are making it far more of a problem than it really is. But I honestly think it's cause of how Apple decided to handle it.
 
If the 3GS would have shipped with that matte case that leaked I would say the 3GS. I do like my iPhone 4 but I always worry about dropping the damn thing.
 
A picture is worth a thousand words

iphone-3gs-vs-iphone-4-apple.jpg


I have the iPhone 4. My friend the 3Gs. They are not even in the same league.

iphone-3g-ios4-rm-eng.jpg


iPhone4Jailbreak.jpg


and the winner is

iphone-4-death-grip.jpg
 
The 4 is beautiful, to look at. Even the specs like the glass on the front/back are better than plastic or whatever they had on the 3GS, however, I feel like the 3GS feels a little better in my hand than the 4.
 
I prefer the 3GS but thats probably cos it's what I have. I'm sure if I owned an iPhone 4 my opinion would be different. To be honest though, the 2G is where its at. It has the flat back of the iPhone 4 as well as the rounded edges of the 3GS. I hope Apple bring back the rounded edges for the next iPhone
 
I prefer the 3GS but thats probably cos it's what I have. I'm sure if I owned an iPhone 4 my opinion would be different. To be honest though, the 2G is where its at. It has the flat back of the iPhone 4 as well as the rounded edges of the 3GS. I hope Apple bring back the rounded edges for the next iPhone

Not a chance I'm afraid.

They want the entire line to look the same. At the moment it's like a mini Macbook Pro

product-hero-iphone4.jpg


overview-hero.jpg



iPhone 4 design is not going anywhere. Next year they will bring it all together even further with the new iOS and OSX for Mac. It will be seamless from the iPhone to the iPad, to the Macbook Pro.

a round iPhone like the 3Gs would stick out like a sore thumb in that lineup.
 
Iphonee 4 with the silver band around the case.

I find my Iphonee3 used to to run quite warm holding it for web surfing more than 20 - 30 minutes, it was fine just for a quick check of mail.


Have not experienced any overheating issues with the Iphone4


Would be nice to see Apple come out with a white iphone4
 
iPhone 4 design is not going anywhere. Next year they will bring it all together even further with the new iOS and OSX for Mac. It will be seamless from the iPhone to the iPad, to the Macbook Pro.

a round iPhone like the 3Gs would stick out like a sore thumb in that lineup.

Yeah I think you're completely right. I can still dream though. I think if I had the iPhone 4 for a while rather than just playing with demo ones in the store that I'd get to like the feel. Oh well, I'll see what next year brings.
 
Yeah I think you're completely right. I can still dream though. I think if I had the iPhone 4 for a while rather than just playing with demo ones in the store that I'd get to like the feel. Oh well, I'll see what next year brings.

One thing I can say about the iPhone 4. I've had it for a little over 1 week now and when I pick up my Blackberry Bold 9000 (big phone) that my wife is using now it feels light as a feather. and I thought that phone was heavy :D

It is one heavy phone, but it adds to the premium feel. Other phones feel cheap to me now.
 
I think they both have an amazing design.
Love the curves of the 3GS but dislike the chrome bezel.
Love the stainless steel band of the 4.
whitephones.jpg
 
One of the things I love about iPhone 4 is how easy it is to take the back off. Much easier to manually replace the battery unlike the 2G.
 
yeah, the major problem with 3GS design is the chrome bezel. it just looks odd and it makes the screen look smaller :/
an iPhone with curved back (which I love) and no bezel would look gorgeous, especially if they would made it thinner.
something like this on this (I know that both of them doesn't look too Apple-ish, just take that for reference)
Anyway I'm not saying that I dislike the ip4 design: I love it, and it's way better than my old 3G. I'm only saying that's room to improve that.

BTW, interesting discussion!
 
iPhone 4 by a lot. It feels very solid in the hand, and the brushed stainless bezel is sexy.

I also like how the iPhone 4 rests on flat surfaces. This makes it easy to use the phone while resting on a table, for example, because it doesn't wobble around.
 
It was the design of the 4 that really made me pull the trigger (although I despise a little the home button build).

Personally the 3 was not interesting design-wise.
 
I very much prefer the 4 to the 3G/3GS. In fact, I have had each model, and I was somewhat disappointed in the 3G when it came out. I thought the rounded plastic back seemed a little cheap compared to the 1st generation and it's metal case. I know several people who were reluctant to upgrade because it felt like a downgrade. The 1st gen just felt so good and now the 4 brings that back even stronger. I think the round back was a design trick to make the device appear thinner than it really is. They used the same effect on the iPad, and it is irritating that you have to put it in a case so it will lay flat on a table. I am pleased with my 4 and how it feels every time I pick it up. As far as the thought that the glass back makes the phone less durable -- I have had mine since release day and I keep it in the apple bumper with the back exposed. I have dropped it hard several times without a crack or even a scratch. Not on concrete yet, but at least once on wood and once on tile and I think people are making a little too much out of the glass construction. It really is tougher than you think. Not that I want to walk through the parking garage playing football with it. I just don't think it is fair to say that it is twice as likely to break.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.