ya know here is always a 3rd option unless that includes the soup or salad.
i enjoyed this thread, thanks of posting!
[doublepost=1533299647][/doublepost]
which I strongly feel is regression and bulling.
We hereby state that "here is our computer- you must not amend or alter our computer, doing so will be punishable by voiding warranty and condemn such behavior with regulations"
There are still big hulking "laptops" out there. I have one for my CAD operator who works from home. She does not carry it anywhere, it just sits on her desk. The only reason for a "laptop" is to facilitate her being able to grab it and bring it into the office for whatever reason (which she hasn't done in several years). Hers is one of the big 10+ lb Acer gaming machines.
For those of us that carry our machines all day and need to use them in the field, size, weight, and battery life is everything. I used to be an upgrade maniac. I built all the machines for my office, desktops and servers. Hell, 2006 Mac Pro had eSata cards, Video card upgrades, every drive sled full, and about every other upgrade possible. Even my base model Trash Can now has a 12 core and 64GB ram. My last iMac had a BD drive and SSD. All my older pre unibody MBP's got SSD swaps, and even the Lenovo Tiny PC's I use in the office get upgraded to SSD as soon as I buy them (you need a 500GB 2.5" spinner - I have dozens of them that are brand new and yet in the discard pile).
But the fact is that upgrades are no longer terribly compelling. Moore's "Law" died some time ago and updates have been less than compelling. The only reason I am not using my 2013 unibody MBP is the fact that they have gotten smaller, lighter and have much better battery life. Performance wise, they are faster, but not enough to justify replacement. I've bought Dell XPS's, HP Spectre's, Microsoft Surface's, and Lenovo X1Carbons, all chasing the best user experience, size, weight, and footprint. Yet here I am right back in a new 13" MBP.
Oh, one more thing, I am not sure if you have ever upgraded/replaced and NVMe drive....it's not a lot of fun, and depending on the machine can be a real PITA as it's not as simple as attaching a USB enclosure and cloning. Not impossible, but certainly nothing that an average user is going to take on. Hell, even adding an NVMe to an HP Envy is a pain, and the basic ones at Best Buy have the vacant slot just sitting there unpopulated. The guys at the local BB always question me as I have on more than one occasion left with a new Ryzen Envy and a Samsung 960. My outside sales guys are carrying Envys with a blazing 256SSD and 1TB of bulk storage, along with a blazing fast CPU out the door and I'm out less than $850 and a little time for the upgrade. If you want the best deal in a laptop I can't recommend this path highly enough!