Travis Dude, you need to CHILL OUT.
Re-read all your posts on this thread. First you express doubt regarding the deal but you leap on it and shrug, hopping for the best. Then you get worried that you were screwed over and leave negative feedback. They you get worried that were too impulsive and want to retract your negative feedback. They PayPal fixed everything for you. You're all over the map. You feel one way but act another and it changes the next day.
You sound like a decent guy. When in doubt, DO NOTHING. Take a deep breath, give yourself some to figure things out and don't throw gasoline on the fire. Man, the few hundred bucks you're trying to save is not worth the weeks that this stress took off your life.
Best,
Mike