Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

[WW] Friend... or foe? : GAME OVER WOLVES WIN

twietee said:
Because we might have an inexperienced hunter who is not used to read that much between the lines? Worst thing that can happen is that the Seer dies without sharing any info! We have no infection and only two ww.

I don't know what you two chatted about and how that'd proof anything. I'd rather have the option to vote for those mostly absent to this game but that's another story and not much to do about now. I initially voted for neither of them.

My vote for him is not set in stone anyway, I can't now due too much work but will revisit the thread later a bit more closely. A deadline would be help though.

----------



Well, not to be misunderstood: I just picked rick's "I have reason" comment up. If he's not the Seer, fine. But if he knew anj was a baddie I think it'd be a different thing - and most probably not a 4 day game. Imagine anj (well, doesn't make sense in this case) or Meister would be the Hunter, do they read between the lines as we do? They can't ask their 'partners' for help. But the wolves may have picked it up and rick could have been gone without any protection. Just sayin'.
Never said the hunter should out him -or herself?? Nor the Seer in general.
Click to expand...

But yes, if the seer see a wolf, he should tell. And yes, the PM's between two is no proof in anyway of "cleaniness", and that's were this game is complex.
 
Meister.

In my experience Anjinha plays a sly wolf but I have to cut her a break at some point. - You were a wolf, what, four times in a row there way back then? Couldn't get a break.

I may be eating my words sooner or later but now...
 
ok, i finally had time to get back on and read the thread.
i need to go back to re-read a few posts before i can make up my mind

meanwhile this is the updated situation:

anjinha: 3 (sythas, scepticalscribe, rick)
meister: 3 (twietee, melrose, moyank)

still to vote: dontpanic, queenofspades.

looks like i will or (qos , if she votes first) be in a deciding situations, with two similarly unlikely choices (especially now that i have read the thread).

btw i updated the google spreadsheet for those interested, you have to click on the frind/foe tab on the bottom left.

for meister and anjinha, that is a record of all votes for quick reference, it is open to anyone to edit and update. the sole requirement is that you only change infos if they are incorrect and only add factual data (no speculations).
it is linked in my sig.
 
This is thrilling, but I also have a hunch that both I and Anj are innocent. :confused:

That would make this quite the sad and pointless hanging :(
 
Meister said:
This is thrilling, but I also have a hunch that both I and Anj are innocent. :confused:

That would make this quite the sad and pointless hanging :(
Click to expand...

considering we have 2WW and 8 villager left, that is unfortunately more likely than not (although it is usually true for most lynching, especially in simple games where there is really very little to go on)

part of the reasons i can't make up my mind.
 
Don't panic said:
considering we have 2WW and 8 villager left, that is unfortunately more likely than not (although it is usually true for most lynching, especially in simple games where there is really very little to go on)

part of the reasons i can't make up my mind.
Click to expand...

Me either, but I'll take the plunge since I abstained from voting for one of them in the first round.
 
One last word:

I am nothing. Not hunter, not seer, not ww. Just a boring villager.

If you hang me, at least you know that you are not killing a hunter or seer by accident. So I would be taking one for the team - provided Anj is not a ww, of course.
 
Give me a break, DP, QoS and Moynak post within 10 minutes?! No infection, huh? :D
 
Ok, here we go.
I am sure this will come back and bite me in the posteriors tomorrow (if them furry ones do not chew me up tonight first), but I decided to stick to my previous vote.
Not a solid vote, as I am not convinced either way, and –meister- you are probably right that both of you are villagers, but it is a tie-break and one has to go.
hopefully -to steal a favourite expression of ScepticalScribe- you will turn out to be of the lupine persuasion, and anjinha will not

----------

ninja attack by the queen! :D
oh well, hopefully you are right.

although i suppose things are still in play and anyone could change their votes until ravenvii call it
 
Don't panic said:
Ok, here we go.
I am sure this will come back and bite me in the posteriors tomorrow (if them furry ones do not chew me up tonight first), but I decided to stick to my previous vote.
Not a solid vote, as I am not convinced either way, and –meister- you are probably right that both of you are villagers, but it is a tie-break and one has to go.
hopefully -to steal a favourite expression of ScepticalScribe- you will turn out to be of the lupine persuasion, and anjinha will not

----------

ninja attack by the queen! :D
oh well, hopefully you are right.

although i suppose things are still in play and anyone could change their votes until ravenvii call it
Click to expand...

Why Meister over ajinha? Because he's sworn to be a villager? I'm open to swapping, but I think we're probably wrong on this round.
 
Meister said:
Another tie?
Click to expand...

yep! :D
anyone changing their vote will cause majority.
but anjinha got there first, so if there are no changes you should be safe.

----------
Queen of Spades said:
Why Meister over ajinha? Because he's sworn to be a villager? I'm open to swapping, but I think we're probably wrong on this round.
Click to expand...

nah, that is meaningless, and i think anjinha did too.
i don't have a good reason in truth, just bits here and there.
things are complicated by the fact that i never played with Meister and i think i might have played with anjinha a long time a go, so it is hard to read them

----------
Queen of Spades said:
Why Meister over ajinha? Because he's sworn to be a villager? I'm open to swapping, but I think we're probably wrong on this round.
Click to expand...

btw, you should have posted at 2:00! it would have been so cool if they appeared simultaneously! :)
 
Don't panic said:
yep! :D
anyone changing their vote will cause majority.
but anjinha got there first, so if there are no changes you should be safe.

----------



nah, that is meaningless, and i think anjinha did too.
i don't have a good reason in truth, just bits here and there.
things are complicated by the fact that i never played with Meister and i think i might have played with anjinha a long time a go, so it is hard to read them

----------



btw, you should have posted at 2:00! it would have been so cool if they appeared simultaneously! :)
Click to expand...

Heh, I was afraid you'd snipe me and it'd be over without my even making a vote. Next time we'll synchronize swatches. ;)
 
Curiouser and curiouser.

Another tie - this one possibly influenced by private communications with partners every bit as much as by knowledge, or vague suspicions, or lack thereof.
 
Queen of Spades said:
Heh, I was afraid you'd snipe me and it'd be over without my even making a vote. Next time we'll synchronize swatches. ;)
Click to expand...

NP. but if Meister is all hairy under those big glasses, it is all on you!

----------
Scepticalscribe said:
Curiouser and curiouser.

Another tie - this one possibly influenced by private communications with partners every bit as much as by knowledge, or vague suspicions, or lack thereof.
Click to expand...

well, it could be a good source of data, especially if anjinha turns out to be a WW
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back