Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
It looks like you haven't read any of the relevant post, if any post at all.
So maybe before trounching judgement, you should just try to gather a minimum of information.
Plutonius wasn't even voted off. He was done in by the executioner in a self- defense move.
I personally had not voted for pluto, but infact I had conspired with QoS, moyank and southern dad to save his skin at the last minute. We succeed in that, at the expense of tomorrow, but turned out that tomorrow (understandably) disagreed, and used his executioner privilege to overturn the lynching and put pluto back on the spot.

An even cursory look at the thread would have shown that much,

My "cursory" look at the thread showed he was leading votes, and then got lynched.

It's 2:30 in the morning, so excuse me if I missed something.
 
My "cursory" look at the thread showed he was leading votes, and then got lynched.

It's 2:30 in the morning, so excuse me if I missed something.

No, i don't, because you come here full of it while you know jack.

If you don't have time to look at even a single post, then you can also avoid to bs around and wait until you actually know something
Plus, when you get called on it, instead of owning up, you keep with the misplaced attitude
 
Why does your operation 'Let's stir the pot and save Pluto' make you, Moyank and QoS any less suspicious, DP? Tomorrow wasn't a baddie either. This could have been for show as well, not necessarily all three of you of course.


For voting Pluto off: he was the last of the three 'suspects' (SD, Pluto, tee) uncleared to me and in my perception posting/playing slightly different than usual. This can have many reasons (work, annoyed to get votes, etc) but hey, there was little to go on for everybody else too.
 
No, i don't, because you come here full of it while you know jack.

If you don't have time to look at even a single post, then you can also avoid to bs around and wait until you actually know something
Plus, when you get called on it, instead of owning up, you keep with the misplaced attitude

Look in the mirror, with the attitude.
 
Why does your operation 'Let's stir the pot and save Pluto' make you, Moyank and QoS any less suspicious, DP? Tomorrow wasn't a baddie either. This could have been for show as well, not necessarily all three of you of course.


For voting Pluto off: he was the last of the three 'suspects' (SD, Pluto, tee) uncleared to me and in my perception posting/playing slightly different than usual. This can have many reasons (work, annoyed to get votes, etc) but hey, there was little to go on for everybody else too.

I see your point.
I can only say that it does in my eyes.
The ww obviously knew he was a good guy, and he can be very helpful to the village in that position. So it would be in their interest if he was lynched, i think.
So if QoS or moyank (or me) were ww, by doing nothing they could have achieved that.
Could it be just a show by any of us to build some sort of alibi? Yes, it could.
But i know it wasn't on my part and at this point i don't think it was on theirs either. That said, i have been fooled plenty before.

Right now the only people cleared are tomorrow and SD (barring infection), the rest are all suspects. The 'list' just reflects my current impression of who i deem more or less likely to be a villain given what as transpired so far. I could most certainly be off (and obviously, there are only 3-4 villains, so clearly a good chunk are heroes)
 
First off, while I don't really mind being placed by DP in 'the possibly most suspicious' category, I will point out that during two rounds of voting, I remained adamant that Plutonius was not a baddie.

At this stage, I really wish to know - for certain - which side DP is on, as I confess to increasing suspicions. This does not necessarily mean that I would vote for him on the morrow, but a nice scanning would put my mind at rest.

Likewise, I am rather curious as to Moyank's loyalties. And, while -aggie- may come across as somewhat irascible at times, that does not invalidate the valid - to my mind - questions or matters that he has raised.
 
These guys were idiots for voting you off. I've been on a 12+ hour date, so I was really irritated to see they voted you off. Makes no sense to me.

You seriously messed up, and you're messing up even more thinking I'm on your list.

Calling us idiots when you haven't even read the thread is hilarious. Here's a cliffs notes version: we tried to save his skin. Come on, if you haven't read it, wait until you do before you start insulting people. :rolleyes:

Also, you're insulting Moyank too - she voted along with us. Pretty sure you won't be calling her an idiot directly, right?

First off, while I don't really mind being placed by DP in 'the possibly most suspicious' category, I will point out that during two rounds of voting, I remained adamant that Plutonius was not a baddie.

At this stage, I really wish to know - for certain - which side DP is on, as I confess to increasing suspicions. This does not necessarily mean that I would vote for him on the morrow, but a nice scanning would put my mind at rest.

Likewise, I am rather curious as to Moyank's loyalties. And, while -aggie- may come across as somewhat irascible at times, that does not invalidate the valid - to my mind - questions or matters that he has raised.

I agree that DP, Moyank and I are not cleared by any means. We would have happily lynched Tomorrow (sorry buddy) and that would have been wrong as well. But personally, I wouldn't have put myself out there for a last minute bandwagon if I were a baddie. I would have just sailed on and let Plutonius get killed. Not only is he an excellent analyst, but it would have raised no further suspicion. That's my explanation, anyway.

As for -aggie-, I'm not inclined to take his questions seriously when he hasn't even read the thread. It's one thing to miss some time for personal reasons, we've all had that happen. But the correct response is not to come into the thread guns blazing, talking nonsense and being cranky and insulting.

I plan to do another re-read before Sunday, but the extended weekend deadline for night gives us some time for thoughtful analysis before we have to make another vote.
 
Last edited:
First off, while I don't really mind being placed by DP in 'the possibly most suspicious' category, I will point out that during two rounds of voting, I remained adamant that Plutonius was not a baddie.

At this stage, I really wish to know - for certain - which side DP is on, as I confess to increasing suspicions. This does not necessarily mean that I would vote for him on the morrow, but a nice scanning would put my mind at rest.

Likewise, I am rather curious as to Moyank's loyalties. And, while -aggie- may come across as somewhat irascible at times, that does not invalidate the valid - to my mind - questions or matters that he has raised.

I am fine with everything you said (although i would say in my defense that i already tangibly helped the village, in addition to the fail attempt at saving pluto), and i accept rick' as a valid argument, i can just reiterate that i am just expressing an opinion,
but honestly, what "valid" matter did aggie raise with his "matters"? He barges in, does not read anything, singles out a post of mine completely out of context, and starts, insulting people for doing stuff we didn't even do in the first place. And then behave like he was somehow wronged.
I was going to drop the whole thing, but, seriously?
 
It hurt my eyes the way DP uses colors to code his list. ;) i don't fully concur with it's content either (not with my placing up top, that makes perfectly sense) albeit I understand the logic behind it. Still, I'm nothing but an innocent bystander searching for the purse he seemed to have lost along the way.

Btw, I can very well imagine, sythas pointed to it before as well, that ravenvii died because of my joking comment about him and sythas (the two players that participated the least at that point). Some sort of gruesome set up. Plus he talked a lot of crap.

Odds really don't look good for us now. Hope the seer is alive and catches one for us!
 
Obviously I'm not going to agree with DP and me being in the suspect list but since there is no substantial proof of me being innocent, it makes sense.
 
Is it a DnD-type game? I haven't played any rpg in ages
I certainly hope there will be a game 5, although for different reasons than yours ;)

It is. It's a spin-off from 3.5 which has become one of the most popular in the world. It's the only system I've played. I absolutely love it!
 
These guys were idiots for voting you off.

WE'RE idiots? Pot, meet kettle.

I've been on a 12+ hour date, so I was really irritated

That's a shame. After 12 hours on a date and you end up this grumpy - that's a lot of "frustration."

I'm as sorry as anyone that you couldn't put the ball in the hole (which is to say, I'm not sorry at all), but that's no reason for you to show up here and start being a dick to everyone without even being arsed to read the thread first.

You seriously messed up

Look in the mirror.


No. Either read it for yourself or piss off.

It's 2:30 in the morning so excuse me if I missed something.

Your 2:30 in the morning excuse is good enough to absolve you from informing yourself but it doesn't slow you down when it comes to verbally ******** on people?
 
get_along_people_spray_ver.png
 
Deadline is Sunday at 12pm PST. He probably extended it a bit because it's the weekend.

Thank you. I'll confess that the games where tempers start to fray leave me a little cold, and a lot less enthusiastic.

In any case, if I read the times some of you offered earlier correctly, am I to take it that PST is around 8 hours behind GMT?
 
Thank you. I'll confess that the games where tempers start to fray leave me a little cold, and a lot less enthusiastic.

In any case, if I read the times some of you offered earlier correctly, am I to take it that PST is around 8 hours behind GMT?

We're 7 hours behind now. 9:48am here.

I understand about the tempers, but in this case one person started the antagonism. It's fair to have a response to being called an idiot, in my opinion. Either way, hopefully some sleep did him well.
 
DAY 3

Moyank24 rubbed the sleep from her eyes as she heard the doorbell to the hero headquarters start (it was actually quite a beautiful a capella rendition of hijo de la luna by Swedish goats). She briskly walked to the door and opened it. No one was there, but she happened to look down and notice a package had been left.

"TO TEH HEROZE, HAHA. NO DONT WRIGHT THAT PART STOOPID"

Moyank24 called out for the other heroes to join her and they all silently gathered around the box.

"So, I guess we should open it" Scepticalscribe solemnly offered.

"Alright," Sythas stepped forward, "I'll do it." He knelt down slowly and opened the hastily closed box. He gave a small gasp. "It's Don't Panic, he's dead!" He slowly closed the box.

"Let me see!" Southern Dad pushed forward, banjo clapping against his back. "No, he's not dead you idiot." Don't Panic smiled and waved.

"No, he's clearly dead," Techgod. "Heads don't do that on not dead people."

Queen of Spades peeked over the rim of the box. "I think... I think he just winked at me!"

Koodauw snatched the box up and dumped out the contents before the heroes, which hit the ground with a wet slorping sound. "Maybe he was both alive and dead in the box. But now he's all the way dead."

Everyone agreed.

"Hey," WoodNUFC looked at abijnk. "How come you never talk?"

"That's part of my power," she said deeply.

"Wow, your voice is so deep!" Twietee was staring wide in amazement.

"That's actually my high voice. People think Barry White died in 2003, but it was actually way before that. I recorded his last three albums." abijnk said proudly.

"HEY GUYS WHAT DID I MISS!" rick snagwell clapped abijnk on the back as he approached.

abijnk let out a startled yell and everyone felt their intestines dance as they violently filled their pants. "Sorry," she said in her 'high' voice.

"Pouring one out for our dead homie, ravenvii?" moyank24 meekly offered, sending everyone into a raucous laughing fit until she got bored and left the room.


Don't Panic has been truly killed in the night, for real. 100% dead. No uncertainty.

It is now DAY 3. Deadline is noon PST 6/9 (Monday). Majority is 7.
 
That answers that question……..well, it answers two questions……..

Gosh. Oooooooof. Okay, I'll admit that I strongly suspected him. He was not taking as strong a lead as he usually did when on the side of good, which bothered me somewhat; moreover, the fact that he had survived………until now, was also something I found…….to be unexpected.

Wrong, then, this time. Completely wrong, in my conclusions and suspicions.

And this one, fellow heroes and heroines, is a very bad loss to us, make no mistake as to that.
 
The heroes had barely had time to turn around when they found Tomorrow pinned up along the hall wall, limbs grotesquely pierced with a menagerie of his expensive toys.

"Well, there's one thing money can't buy you," Queen of Spades said with a solemn stare.

"What's that?" the group almost collectively replied.

"Fashion sense. Those pants with that shirt?" she ticked and quickly turned and walked away to the sound of soft mechanical baby farts in the background.


Tomorrow, a villain has been slain in the day. Voting majority is still 7.
 
The heroes had barely had time to turn around when they found Tomorrow pinned up along the hall wall, limbs grotesquely pierced with a menagerie of his expensive toys.

"Well, there's one thing money can't buy you," Queen of Spades said with a solemn stare.

"What's that?" the group almost collectively replied.

"Fashion sense. Those pants with that shirt?" she ticked and quickly turned and walked away to the sound of soft mechanical baby farts in the background.


Tomorrow, a villain has been slain in the day. Voting majority is still 7.

Nice narrative!

And :)
 
Ah, bravo. Excellent! Got one! Fantastic! Very, very, very well done. Take a bow.

(If there was an icon to depict rubbing hands together with pleased satisfaction, I'd post it, now; indeed, if there was an icon to depict appal use, loud, prolonged and sustained, I'd happily post that, too…..)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.