Toggle sidebar Toggle sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

[WW] Simple Werewolville Mach 2 - Game Over, wolves win.

Does this mean that some one is infected?

We mustn't forget about the fact that our more influential people can be werewolves as well as those that post little. Therefore we should take -aggie- and iBlue into consideration.

I here by change my vote to Mexbearpig.
 
Intell said:
Does this mean that some one is infected?

We mustn't forget about the fact that our more influential people can be werewolves as well as those that post little. Therefore we should take -aggie- and iBlue into consideration.

I here by vote for -aggie-.
Click to expand...

We have two people talking alot about techfreak85 being a WW, and then someone gets saved by the hunter (giving the hunter a 1 out of 2 chance of picking the right one, if the WW's picked one of those two), and you think I'm the WW? Makes little sense, unless you want to swing the other way and now vote for people with the most posts, which makes as much sense as voting for people with the least posts, but we had nothing else to go on at the time.

Edit: BTW, what makes you think someone is infected? The scene above suggests a hunter saved someone, unless I'm missing something (that could well be).
 
I'm just guessing. No idea really. If the hunter did get a WW then wouldn't the threads title be "XXXXXX killed by hunter" or something like that.
 
Intell said:
I'm just guessing. No idea really. If the hunter did get a WW then wouldn't the threads title be "XXXXXX killed by hunter" or something like that.
Click to expand...

You're getting confused with the more complicated game. In this game the hunter just protects someone, AFAIK. I could be wrong, but that was my understanding from reading the OP.

The hunter protects a villager and that's all.

Hunter: The hunter can pick one player to protect per night. S/he cannot protect the same player twice in a row.
Click to expand...
 
Good job hunter!

I'm still thinking NathanMuir, although, like I said I think we should all post the reasoning behind who we are suspicious of. I'll vote after I hear some more thoughts so it's not just a blind vote like the last few times.
 
WELL DONE HUNTER!!! 🙂 I really wish I knew who you protected - that info could help because we'd know who not to lynch. If we're ever about to lynch you please speak up with that info, even if it doesn't save you (can't convince everyone) it may help the village and your innocent death would likely prove what you say was true. (if you follow me here.)


chrmjenkins said:
ShaunPriest was used because he was the only dissenter with the vote. Your words reflected that the village as a whole is dissatisfied with their performance, and you're the next one to go down for nothing. In my narrations, I will take people's actions and thoughts into account, but I will never allude to identities or give hints within. It is all for narrative effect.
Click to expand...

I didn't vote for fireshot91 either. Didn't matter in the end but just for the record and stuff.

I'm still thinking techfreak85. Not a lot of interest shown in speculating who the wolves are. That's why I don't particularly suspect -aggie-, he's trying to figure/reason things out. I could be wrong here but that's just my feeling.

NathanMuir has had some odd comments but he did in the other game as well. He seems a bit ready to sacrifice people just for not participating. Now I do vote that way too really but that's not because I'm okay with sacrifice, it's because I find lack of participation to be suspicious - like there's no interest in working out who the wolves are because they already know. Not sure on NathanMuir... or anyone but myself. 😛
 
iBlue said:
WELL DONE HUNTER!!! 🙂 I really wish I knew who you protected - that info could help because we'd know who not to lynch. If we're ever about to lynch you please speak up with that info, even if it doesn't save you (can't convince everyone) it may help the village and your innocent death would likely prove what you say was true. (if you follow me here.)




I didn't vote for fireshot91 either. Didn't matter in the end but just for the record and stuff.

I'm still thinking techfreak85. Not a lot of interest shown in speculating who the wolves are. That's why I don't particularly suspect -aggie-, he's trying to figure/reason things out. I could be wrong here but that's just my feeling.

NathanMuir has had some odd comments but he did in the other game as well. He seems a bit ready to sacrifice people just for not participating. Now I do vote that way too really but that's not because I'm okay with sacrifice, it's because I find lack of participation to be suspicious - like there's no interest in working out who the wolves are because they already know. Not sure on NathanMuir... or anyone but myself. 😛
Click to expand...

If you're not the one saved, then you can rule out shaunpriest as a WW, based on my theory above (could be total crap, based on my other theories 🙂).
 
^ Maybe. We could deduct more from voting patterns if we could get one wolf and see how they voted and whose votes didn't go towards them, etc. That's another reason I suspect non-participants - if they're trying to be ambiguous in the shadows, not voting.

Has anyone kept a voting record of how everyone has voted? We should do this. (Might do so myself later, if I survive. It's just a bit late and I'm a little, uh, cookied™ out right now.)
 
iBlue said:
^ Maybe. We could deduct more from voting patterns if we could get one wolf and see how they voted and whose votes didn't go towards them, etc. That's another reason I suspect non-participants - if they're trying to be ambiguous in the shadows, not voting.

Has anyone kept a voting record of how everyone has voted? We should do this. (Might do so myself later, if I survive. It's just a bit late and I'm a little, uh, cookied™ out right now.)
Click to expand...

I have.
 
iBlue said:
Has anyone kept a voting record of how everyone has voted? We should do this. (Might do so myself later, if I survive. It's just a bit late and I'm a little, uh, cookied™ out right now.)
Click to expand...

I didn't realize it was that well used. I'll keep better track of the spreadsheet if there's a next game. 🙂
 
^ Oh yeah, I always try to figure a little something from it but I'm not always great at keeping records myself. 😱

-aggie- said:
I have.
Click to expand...

Oh excellent. Please post it. Pretty soon it's going to be very vital that our votes don't kill more villagers since we could have three wolves running around.
 
Seer: The seer can scan any player during the night, and the player's role will be revealed to the seer.
Click to expand...

Is the Seer allowed to say they are a Seer?

Why hasn't the Seer told us who is/isn't a werewolf?
 
^ They put themselves at risk to wolf attack to reveal that. We may have accidentally lynched them too. It seems to be an unlucky pattern for the hunter and seer to be lynched early. At least we know the hunter is still around though.
 
This is messy and I used abbreviations, but you should be able to understand it (I took it from my writing on paper; didn't bother to make a spreadsheet):

TF 1(SP)
WB 2(iB, ag)
jav 9(Mel, ren, MBP, TF, NM, FH, Anj, Int, abi*) *later abbie changed vote
Mel 1 (jav)
FH 1 (abi*, iBook) *later abbie changed vote

Mel 1 (TF)
abi 2 (iB, ren)
KMM 8 (NM, Int, MBP, Mel, ag, FH, SP, abi)

Int 0 (FH*) *changed vote
FH 0 (iBook*) *changed vote
WB 8 (iB, Mel, ag, NM, TF, MBP, FH*, iBook*) *changed vote
 
Well another villager. This is no good. Well I forgot who said it but someone said who we suspect. Well for me it's techfreak. He has been posting quite a lot. I think he's trying to watch his back for people voting for him. So I hereby vote for techfreak.
ShaunPriest said:
Is the Seer allowed to say they are a Seer?

Why hasn't the Seer told us who is/isn't a werewolf?
Click to expand...

Yeah but someone could easily impersonate the seer and could actually be a Baddie. So it would be pointless.
 
Aggie that fact that you have this information to hand illustrates to me that you're definitely not a werewolf.

A werewolf wouldn't bother having this info.
 
Finally, a bit of good luck!

The only problem is I have no idea who to look at now. I think that we need a list of all the remaining players. I think that these are all the players who are left:

1) -aggie-
2) Mexbearpig
3) NathanMuir
4) renewed
5) techfreak85
6) Intell
7) iBlue
8) iBookG4User
9) ShaunPriest

From that list, I don't think that ShaunPriest is a wolf. I have a feeling that iBookG4User isn't either. For record, I know that I am not a wolf, but of course I can't prove it. So if we remove the other two names we are left with:

1) -aggie-
2) Mexbearpig
3) NathanMuir
4) renewed
5) Intell
6) iBlue
7) Techfreak85

Does anyone else agree that ShaunPriest and iBookG4User aren't the wolves?

If so, who do you think left on the list above are likely wolves. I got the sickening feeling in my stomach that one, if not both (or perhaps three), wolves has to be a user who has played before and they are quite skilled.

From reading past games, I feel that Mexbearpig has changed his style somewhat. I can't place my finger on it but, I don't know, just feels different.

But I'm not ready to vote yet. Every time I've made my case, I've been dead wrong. So let's get some feed back and try narrow this list down and kill the wolves.

EDIT:
I have made changes in italics to my theory. As you may have seen by now, I got things out of order and made a major mistake. Again, sorry for the confusion and the drama.
 
^ Perhaps techfreak85 and iBookG4User are your fellow wolf chums?

There are 9 remaining players according to the above post (including me). With the possibility of 3 werewolf's. We have a 33% chance of catching one tonight.

Let's make it happen people. I voted for techfreak85, but I'll be honest - it is just a hunch. I am also suspicious of Mexbearpig.

Does anyone have substantial evidence to implicate one of the nine on the list?
 
-aggie- said:
We have two people talking alot about techfreak85 being a WW, and then someone gets saved by the hunter (giving the hunter a 1 out of 2 chance of picking the right one, if the WW's picked one of those two), and you think I'm the WW? Makes little sense, unless you want to swing the other way and now vote for people with the most posts, which makes as much sense as voting for people with the least posts, but we had nothing else to go on at the time.

Edit: BTW, what makes you think someone is infected? The scene above suggests a hunter saved someone, unless I'm missing something (that could well be).
Click to expand...

iBlue said:
WELL DONE HUNTER!!! 🙂 I really wish I knew who you protected - that info could help because we'd know who not to lynch. If we're ever about to lynch you please speak up with that info, even if it doesn't save you (can't convince everyone) it may help the village and your innocent death would likely prove what you say was true. (if you follow me here.)




I didn't vote for fireshot91 either. Didn't matter in the end but just for the record and stuff.

I'm still thinking techfreak85. Not a lot of interest shown in speculating who the wolves are. That's why I don't particularly suspect -aggie-, he's trying to figure/reason things out. I could be wrong here but that's just my feeling.

NathanMuir has had some odd comments but he did in the other game as well. He seems a bit ready to sacrifice people just for not participating. Now I do vote that way too really but that's not because I'm okay with sacrifice, it's because I find lack of participation to be suspicious - like there's no interest in working out who the wolves are because they already know. Not sure on NathanMuir... or anyone but myself. 😛
Click to expand...

ShaunPriest said:
techfreak85

No reason in particular, but I would like to be consistent in my voting.
Click to expand...

Mexbearpig said:
Well another villager. This is no good. Well I forgot who said it but someone said who we suspect. Well for me it's techfreak. He has been posting quite a lot. I think he's trying to watch his back for people voting for him. So I hereby vote for techfreak.

Yeah but someone could easily impersonate the seer and could actually be a Baddie. So it would be pointless.
Click to expand...

Please see Edit 2.

Guys, if this is the last chance I get before any events go down tonight, I urge you not to vote for Techfreak. Please, reconsider your votes.

EDIT:

As for my vote, I'm not going to bother with reasoning as I've been wrong twice now.

EDIT 2:

Please disregard the above, I got very confused. I f-ed up big time and realized my mistake when I went back and checked certain things.

I know that this seems very suspious, but in the end you'll see it was an honest mistake.

I will be voting for TechFreak. Again, my apologies.
 
ShaunPriest said:
^ Perhaps techfreak85 and iBookG4User are your fellow wolf chums?

There are 9 remaining players according to the above post (including me). With the possibility of 3 werewolf's. We have a 33% chance of catching one tonight.

Let's make it happen people. I voted for techfreak85, but I'll be honest - it is just a hunch. I am also suspicious of Mexbearpig.

Does anyone have substantial evidence to implicated one of the nine on the list?
Click to expand...

Love the first line. 🙂
 
NathanMuir said:
Guys, if this is the last chance I get before any events go down tonight, I urge you not to vote for Techfreak. Please, reconsider your votes.

EDIT:

As for my vote, I'm not going to bother with reasoning as I've been wrong twice now. I'm going with my gut and voting for Mexbearpig.
Click to expand...

Being honest here, this is just too suspicious for me so I'm going to vote for NathanMuir.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back