People who got the XS Max, do you still like it? Is it too big?
I've had the Plus sized phones since the 6 Plus. I was concerned at the time that it might be too big, but I also knew the only way I would know for sure would be to take advantage of Apple's 2 week return policy: get the Plus, give it a fair shake for a couple of weeks, and if it was too big, I could return it and get the non-Plus size, no harm no foul.
Turns out, I loved the Plus size. Yeah, it took me about three days to get used to it, but once I did, there was no turning back. The extra screen real estate was amazing for watching videos, reading emails, text conversations, web pages, documents, etc.
When the X came out, I loved it, but missed the extra real-estate of a true Plus sized phone. I said multiple times throughout that year, "I really hope Apple comes out with a 'Plus' sized X in 2018." Of course that was the XS Max, I got it on day one (as per my usual), and have loved it ever since.
Whatever Plus sized model comes out this September I'll be happily getting as well.