Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I think I'll go on record in saying that this list is in pretty much good taste, because out of the 30 books listed here, half of them are on the banned list. ;)

BL.

Which banned list?

I do get a bit uneasy about societies which take it upon themselves to ban classics and seek to deprive kids (and adults) from the joy of exploring and finding out for themeless what a wonderful world awaits them, once they open the pages of some of these books.
 
Which banned list?

I do get a bit uneasy about societies which take it upon themselves to ban classics and seek to deprive kids (and adults) from the joy of exploring and finding out for themeless what a wonderful world awaits them, once they open the pages of some of these books.

Here you go..

http://www.ala.org/bbooks/frequentlychallengedbooks/classics
http://www.ala.org/bbooks/bannedbooksweek/ideasandresources/freedownloads#lists

Note that even a couple of Seuss books and the entire Harry Potter and Twilight series are on that lists of banned or frequently challenged books.

I say that the list is in good taste, because the poster is leaving it up to himself to form his own opinion of them, taking the works on the whole instead of some reason as to why they are banned or challenged.

BL.
 
Here you go..

http://www.ala.org/bbooks/frequentlychallengedbooks/classics
http://www.ala.org/bbooks/bannedbooksweek/ideasandresources/freedownloads#lists

Note that even a couple of Seuss books and the entire Harry Potter and Twilight series are on that lists of banned or frequently challenged books.

I say that the list is in good taste, because the poster is leaving it up to himself to form his own opinion of them, taking the works on the whole instead of some reason as to why they are banned or challenged.

BL.

Thank you for posting this; a salutary lesson, and one worth bearing in mind, if only to keep reminding ourselves of the need to safeguard the right to be able to read the classics without being forbidden to do so.

Sigh. I keep forgetting the controlling Puritanical political and cultural ancestry of parts of the US.

Anyway, an appalling list; just spotted 'Farewell to Arms' on @Huntn's list; an excellent and wonderfully bitter sweet work. Anyone who would seek to ban Harry Potter, or Dr Suess does need their head examined.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jmona and Huntn
Lol, whose banned list?

The banned list from the American Library Association. See post #27. Numerous challenges (with some of them succeeding) in having some of the books on your list removed from classrooms and school and public library shelves. I know for fact that 4 of them on your list (Lord of the Rings, Catcher in the Rye, Slaughterhouse Five, To Kill a Mockingbird) were reading material for me in high school (1988 - 1992); they have been subsequently banned from various school districts. Whether they have been added back is a good question, but I know that they are still banned from my hometown's school district.

BL.
 
Last edited:
The banned list from the American Library Association. See post #27. Numerous challenges (with some of them succeeding) in having some of the books on your list removed from classrooms and school and public library shelves. I know for fact that 4 of them on your list (Lord of the Rings, Catcher in the Rye, Slaughterhouse Five, To Kill a Mockingbird) were reading material for me in high school (1988 - 1992); they have been subsequently banned from various school districts. Whether they have been added back is a good question, but I know that they are still banned from my hometown's school district.

BL.

Sigh.

How insane - and ludicrously stupidly judgemental - is that?

These are classics, and the mental and moral landscape of every kid would be immeasurably enhanced by the study of such works of literature. None of those works - on the earlier list which you referenced (and I have read almost all of them) - are gratuitously offensive; they are all thoughtful, intelligent and well written works of artistic merit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jmona
Ordinary People by Judith Guest
The Knife Man by Wendy Moore
Advanced Game Design with HTML5 and JavaScript by Rex der Spuy
 
While some have mentioned 'One Hundred Years Of Solitude' (a terrific book) by Gabriel Marcía Márquez, I'd also mention 'The House Of The Spirits' by Isabel Allende which is outstanding.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jmona
The banned list from the American Library Association. See post #27. Numerous challenges (with some of them succeeding) in having some of the books on your list removed from classrooms and school and public library shelves. I know for fact that 4 of them on your list (Lord of the Rings, Catcher in the Rye, Slaughterhouse Five, To Kill a Mockingbird) were reading material for me in high school (1988 - 1992); they have been subsequently banned from various school districts. Whether they have been added back is a good question, but I know that they are still banned from my hometown's school district.

BL.

http://www.ala.org/bbooks/frequentlychallengedbooks/classics

I'm shocked by this list, an utter failure by so called "freedom loving" people who seem resistant to freedom of thought. I'd like to know on what grounds Lord of the Rings or To Kill A Mocking Bird could be banned? I remember the Catholic Church objecting to Harry Potter before they finally threw in the towel, lol.

Here is why Catcher in thr Rye is objectionable to some:

Parents need to know that this book remains one of the best books about adolescence ever written. Any language used -- and it is chock full of mild to moderate swearing, and "****" is used several times -- is in the service of being true to the nature of a rebellious teen. There are also lots of sexual references, and everyone smokes and drinks -- including the underage protagonist. Holden refers to homosexuals as "flits." People have used these instances in an effort to have the book banned. But those who would do so miss the point of the book, which is a compassionate tale of a child adrift in the world. It's an American classic that everyone should read.
 
Last edited:
Judging “favorite” as meaning the most falling-apart books in the house, I’d clearly have to go with the two listed below, although in future I’ll have to figure different rules since some digital format books have moved up in my usage:

Eleanor Perenyi’s Green Thoughts: A Writer in the Garden

Wallace Stevens: poetry collection The Palm at the End of the Mind

Past those, probably mostly some quilting books and cook books that taught me enough so they gather dust now and should hit the handoff or recycle road.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
'Favourite' can mean so many different things; for some, a 'favourite' book could be akin to a comfort blanket, something you return to, again and again, secure in the knowledge of what it can offer you by way of reassuring predictability and sturdy unquestioning comfort.

For others, a book that is placed in the category of 'favourites' is something that stunned you with a visceral electric shock when you read it, a book which had you breathless with stupefied awe, a book you couldn't put down until you had finished it, and a book - which, while you may not choose to re-read it very often - is one you can never forget.

For me, 'Wuthering Heights' by Emily Bronte falls into this latter category. I came across it on the bookshelves of a very well stocked library in five languages in the flat of an academic from whom I was renting the flat in the Old Town of Vilnius, a little over twenty years ago, not long after The Wall Came Down.

Strangely enough, I hadn't read it prior to that. This was a book which came with loads of baggage and an awful lot of hype, so much hype, in fact, that I doubted very much whether the book could live up to its reputation, and I feared an anti-climax when I finally decided to read it.

Anyway, one night, out of idle curiosity, I picked it up, and decided to check it out, mainly to see whether or not it justified its reputation, whether it really was as good as it was supposed to be.

Thus, I began to read it, and - but, of course, inevitably - fell into the story, for this is an electrifying story that grabs you by the throat - and I carried on reading it through the night, - stopping once to draw breath, and make a cup of coffee - but unable to put it down, and finally came to the end, sprawled on my bed, still fully dressed as I had been over eight hours earlier when I had first opened it, silent with stunned wonder at the awesome power of this tale.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: itsOver9000
'Favourite' can mean so many different things; for some, a 'favourite' book could be akin to a comfort blanket, something you return to, again and again, secure in the knowledge of what it can offer you by way of reassuring predictability and sturdy unquestioning comfort.

For others, a book that is placed in the category of 'favourites' is something that stunned you with a visceral electric shock when you read it, a book which had you breathless with stupefied awe, a book you couldn't put down until you had finished it, and a book - which, while you may not choose to re-read it very often - is one you can never forget.

With that, especially the bold, I'd have to also make the nod for just about any of the books in Donald J. Sobol's Encyclopedia Brown series.I say that because after finding them in 3rd grade in my elementary school's library, even with owning most of the series now, I can still open those books, and still be stumped by some of the cases in those books. I can read those over and over and over again, still not solve the case, and turn to the back of the book to find the solution.

As far as a book that you can't put down until you finish it, I'd have to go with a book that you can't finish, so you couldn't put it down! It's a CYOA (Cover Your Own Arse Choose Your Own Adventure) book: The Race Forever. The book involves two different races: a speed race, and an off-road race. While you could meet your end in each race, should you successfully complete a race, on completion, the book tells you to turn to a given page to start the other race. So after finishing the speed race, the book tells you to start the off-road race. And (you guessed it), after finishing the off-road race, the book tells you to start the speed race. Hence, why it goes on forever. So if you ever start that book, beware: you just started your own Mobius. :p

BL.
 
'Favourite' can mean so many different things; for some, a 'favourite' book could be akin to a comfort blanket, something you return to, again and again, secure in the knowledge of what it can offer you by way of reassuring predictability and sturdy unquestioning comfort.

For me that would be Jurassic Park by Michael Crichton. I've managed to read this book 13 or 14 times, I lost count. I just loved it. I haven't read it for quite a few years though.

For others, a book that is placed in the category of 'favourites' is something that stunned you with a visceral electric shock when you read it, a book which had you breathless with stupefied awe, a book you couldn't put down until you had finished it, and a book - which, while you may not choose to re-read it very often - is one you can never forget.

Phantoms by Dean Koontz. This book creeped me out when I first read it. Too bad the movie wasn't nearly as good. I've read this one 3 or 4 times and still found it enjoyable and entertaining.

Jurassic Park and Phantoms are the only 2 books I can recall reading more than once.
 
While some have mentioned 'One Hundred Years Of Solitude' (a terrific book) by Gabriel Marcía Márquez, I'd also mention 'The House Of The Spirits' by Isabel Allende which is outstanding.
HEAR HEAR! That book was amazing. Read it when I was 14 after I had the chance to meet her.
She actually had a birthday yesterday I believe and one of my good friends whom is also a renown Author in Spain is very good friends with her was there. So it on FB yesterday.
Island beneath the Sea and Daughter of Fortune were two great books of her as well!

'Favourite' can mean so many different things; for some, a 'favourite' book could be akin to a comfort blanket, something you return to, again and again, secure in the knowledge of what it can offer you by way of reassuring predictability and sturdy unquestioning comfort.

For others, a book that is placed in the category of 'favourites' is something that stunned you with a visceral electric shock when you read it, a book which had you breathless with stupefied awe, a book you couldn't put down until you had finished it, and a book - which, while you may not choose to re-read it very often - is one you can never forget.
That would be for me Harry Potter Series and LOTR/Silmarillion/The Hobbit/The adventures of Tom Bombadil and as weird as it sounds the Alien novelization by Alan Dean Foster.



For me that would be Jurassic Park by Michael Crichton. I've managed to read this book 13 or 14 times, I lost count. I just loved it. I haven't read it for quite a few years though.

Jurassic Park and Phantoms are the only 2 books I can recall reading more than once.

Now we are talking! That book was amazing!
I saw so many elements of the book in Jurassic World. Still one of the best books ever written!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.