Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I really wanted magsafe to return. I simply don't understand why apple wouldn't bring it back. My 2012 15inch is hanging in there but if it dies I may try to get a 2015 or another 2012.
 
It’s not really a matter of playing the waiting game. Video producers face a real bottle neck with today’s Coffee Lake processors. Ice Lake promises dramatic improvements for video editors. That‘s certainly, for us, worth waiting for.
The 16” uses a dedicated GPU, not the integrated Intel video that the 13” MBP uses.

From what I can tell, 45W 10nm parts are in the 2021 or even 2022 timeframe. The next upgrade for the 16” will be Comet Lake, due next summer.
 
Right, for most tasks. But Ice Lake offers more graphic speed (increasingly important) for crunching 4K video. And it’s optimized for H265 4K — meaning, among other things, faster color correction and rendering. If you’re into 4K video, Ice Lake is definitely worth waiting for. If you’re not into cut-edge video, Ice Lake isn’t so important.

Ice Lake should run cooler with its 10mm architecture. Coupled with the new and better thermals of the 16in MacBook Pro, there should be less throttling, and that sucker should really fly for all processor-intensive tasks.

Wouldn't this would only be a major benefit for MBP 13" (14"!?) laptops with no discrete GPU? Surely today's AMD Radeon Pro 5500M in the MPB 16" will wipe the floor with Intel's forthcoming Ice Lake chips – so even if we had Ice Lake in today's MPB 16" no one would use its video crunching abilities?
 
Long time I don't participate in a post (does't mean I don't like this site, I like it a lot)
Apple never let me down in almost any launch of new product to replace the old one. This one is not exception. Very great new feature.
However,
Well... if I ever have the right to navigate some aspect of the new product development (just in my little dream, of course :cool:), I would try to make the current MacBook Pro lighter and smaller. Reason is I often move my Macbook a lot. (lol I m too selfish, improve just for me :D) The previous generation have an improvement of reducing 10% weight compare to the old one. When this new MacBook Pro come out, I would also expect of another improvement of about 10% again. So it would be about 1.65kg ~ 3.6 lb . But... OUCH ! ! ! Seeing the new weight like a punch in my head, and my heart lol. 2kg. But it is what it is. I can't change. :(

My little boy that I use every days, even every hours is a 15 inch late 2013 (old USB port) and I really love it. Been waiting to make a big jump to skip 1 generation (Touch Bar) to go for this new one 16 inch. But the weight just make me stand back and thing again.

Go buy a MacBook Air or iPadPro.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Already in use
Wouldn't this would only be a major benefit for MBP 13" (14"!?) laptops with no discrete GPU? Surely today's AMD Radeon Pro 5500M in the MPB 16" will wipe the floor with Intel's forthcoming Ice Lake chips – so even if we had Ice Lake in today's MPB 16" no one would use its video crunching abilities?
All good points. Who knows? Right now I’m using my iPad Pro 2018’s ARM chip, and it mops the floor with my Macbook Pro editing 4K video. It’s wild to think that a MacBook Pro is playing catch-up to an iPad for editing video ...
 
I don’t need one but I want to buy one, even just as a way to thank Apple for caring about the MacBook again

Yep, the more users who make their voice heard about the Mac line the more Apple will pay attention to it. That is why i use Apple feedback page to let them know what i like and what i don't like. Apple make so much money on the iPhones that they can take the extra money they make for R&D for Mac systems. Want a Mac Mini Pro, ask them for it. Want to be able to replace SSD storage tell what you think. Why did Apple fix the keyboard and make it better? Why did Apple increase the memory to 64gb?, why did Apple work with Nvidia to put in the latest GPU? Whey did they make larger internal SSD storage? The answer is users feedback to Apple what they wanted to see in a computer.
 
Apple is apparently waiting for Intel 10th gen CPUs, which include integrated support for WiFi 6. Anyone who thinks they need it should not buy the 2019 16”.

If Apple does a 2020 summer/ fall refresh with Comet Lake the 16” will have it.
So it IS Apple who is making the decision to hold off and not Intel. The technology is available now.
 
Last edited:
I really wanted magsafe to return. I simply don't understand why apple wouldn't bring it back. My 2012 15inch is hanging in there but if it dies I may try to get a 2015 or another 2012.
I don't understand the continued obsession with magsafe in a day where you can charge from a ubiquitous USB port. Apple is 100% right to nix it.

They won't bring it back because:
1) It's a dedicated port.
2) It added cost and weight to the machine.
3) It caused way too many customer service cases (dirty ports, broken chargers).

Consumers shouldn't want it back because:
1) The chargers were proprietary, fragile, and expensive.
2) It was only on one side of the machine.
3) You can add it back for $20 with an adapter if you really want it.
 
So it IS Apple who is making the decision to hold off and not Intel. The technology is available now.
I never said it wasn’t lol. Of course the technology is available now, Apple has it on iPhone 11. But no, Intel doesn’t offer it on the 9th gen CPUs.

Like I said, if you think you need it, don’t buy the 2019 16” MBP. There are some nice PCs you can buy, that might be your best option.
 
I never said it wasn’t lol. Of course the technology is available now, Apple has it on iPhone 11. But no, Intel doesn’t offer it on the 9th gen CPUs.

Like I said, if you think you need it, don’t buy the 2019 16” MBP. There are some nice PCs you can buy, that might be your best option.

I have a WIFI 6 router and yes it would have been nice to have it but it did not have me hold back. Most users only connect to the Internet so having a super duper fast WIFI connection would be cool, it is not a show stopper. It has DFS channels which you still has a great speed with WIFI and you get a less crowded DFS WIFI channels. Will get it on my next Macbook Pro in 5 to 6 years or if I want it bad enough i will just get a external adapter 3 years down the road or more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PickUrPoison
Just unboxed the premium in store model. One store in the area got them...the others are showing nov 27. That's the 2.4/8gb gpu/32 ram/2tb model. while its migrating, here are some initial thoughts comparing to the 2018 its replacing.

Noticeably heaver...not a complaint, and not bad, but you can tell it's beefier. Ditto on the power supply. The thinner is always better jony era is over.

Still no 3 prong extension cord....cheapskates.

love 👍👍👍 the new keyboard. like an old friend coming home. The keyboard well is deeper and the keys smaller, so there will be an adjustment, especially going back and forth with my work machine (2019 13").

screen feels bigger and crisper

migration via target disk mode running at 90meg/s over thunderbolt 3 so they still haven't fixed that problem, but it's not something I do everyday so not that big a deal.

ill post back on performance and sound when the migration is done.
[automerge]1573845813[/automerge]
I don't understand the continued obsession with magsafe in a day where you can charge from a ubiquitous USB port. Apple is 100% right to nix it.

They won't bring it back because:
1) It's a dedicated port.
2) It added cost and weight to the machine.
3) It caused way too many customer service cases (dirty ports, broken chargers).

Consumers shouldn't want it back because:
1) The chargers were proprietary, fragile, and expensive.
2) It was only on one side of the machine.
3) You can add it back for $20 with an adapter if you really want it.

and shorts. I've pulled a number of staples out of MagSafe sockets sockets that showed clear signs of arcing. With all the fire issues, ill lay dollars to donuts that's the real reason it's gone.
[automerge]1573845934[/automerge]
I have a WIFI 6 router and yes it would have been nice to have it but it did not have me hold back. Most users only connect to the Internet so having a super duper fast WIFI connection would be cool, it is not a show stopper. It has DFS channels which you still has a great speed with WIFI and you get a less crowded DFS WIFI channels. Will get it on my next Macbook Pro in 5 to 6 years or if I want it bad enough i will just get a external adapter 3 years down the road or more.

exactly, unless you're moving large files around your home WiFi, or running in a very congested area, it won't make a difference, even with gig internet. And the congestion only really gets better once almost all the other networks and clients have it.
 
This does not apply to customizable versions. I selected the base model with 32gbs of ram and I have a delivery expectation of Nov. 25-27th.
 
I never said it wasn’t lol. Of course the technology is available now, Apple has it on iPhone 11. But no, Intel doesn’t offer it on the 9th gen CPUs.

Like I said, if you think you need it, don’t buy the 2019 16” MBP. There are some nice PCs you can buy, that might be your best option.
It's Apple's implementation overall that makes it unavailable. Putting the blame on Intel seems to shift the blame. It's unreasonable to expect Intel to have the technology, which is rather new in final format, to be in the current CPUs. Apple sticking soldered on components and not offering a M2 slot for WIFI is on Apple not Intel.

If people buy these laptops to last for years, the lack of it will matter in a year or two as the standard is rolled out.

There are indeed a great number of PCs which offer stack up quite well against the Macbook Pro. I don't suffer the delusion that Macs are unreasonably priced when comparing equivalent specifications.

What is generally lacking in the PC world is a decent working ratio for screens. Most makers have embraced the bad for most work scenarios 16x9 aspect ratio. PCs do however handle MST MUCH better than Apple who ignores it. As far as I can tell there are two makers who offer machines that don't use it, Apple and Microsoft. Google seems to be embracing 16x9 in their new laptops.

Hopefully Microsoft will include TB in the next iteration of their lineup. I appreciate their use of AMD, but that choice limits the acceptance of TB until it's more widely implemented.

I have no antipathy towards Windows and Windows 10 has been solid for me. My experience with Apple has been frustrating. The bad taste in my mouth the Mac mini is giving me makes me leery of buying anything else out of Cupertino. Currently, there is ONE aspect of using my Mac that I prefer over Windows. It's a great oversight on the part of Microsoft but Apple did it well.
 
I really wanted magsafe to return. I simply don't understand why apple wouldn't bring it back. My 2012 15inch is hanging in there but if it dies I may try to get a 2015 or another 2012.
At some point MagSafe might return but don't count on it anytime soon. USB-C charging is here to stay.
 
I'm still rockin my mid-2009 13-inch MBP. It's 2.53GHz Core 2 Duo with 8GB ram, Nvidia GeForce 9400M graphics, 1Tb SSD, and beautiful chicklet keys. This machine is still amazing and has PORTS GALORE. Apple offered me $40 trade-in for it. Haha! no.

This 16" MBP is a good move in the right direction though. Bring back MagSafe, illuminated apple logo, and at least one USB3 port and you'll get my money.
 
I'm still rockin my mid-2009 13-inch MBP. It's 2.53GHz Core 2 Duo with 8GB ram, Nvidia GeForce 9400M graphics, 1Tb SSD, and beautiful chicklet keys. This machine is still amazing and has PORTS GALORE. Apple offered me $40 trade-in for it. Haha! no.

This 16" MBP is a good move in the right direction though. Bring back MagSafe, illuminated apple logo, and at least one USB3 port and you'll get my money.
It has 4 USB3 ports, they also do TB3!
 
  • Like
Reactions: nicho and MacNut
I'm still rockin my mid-2009 13-inch MBP. It's 2.53GHz Core 2 Duo with 8GB ram, Nvidia GeForce 9400M graphics, 1Tb SSD, and beautiful chicklet keys. This machine is still amazing and has PORTS GALORE. Apple offered me $40 trade-in for it. Haha! no.

This 16" MBP is a good move in the right direction though. Bring back MagSafe, illuminated apple logo, and at least one USB3 port and you'll get my money.
MagSafe won't be back unless they can make it work with USB-C. The Apple logo is cosmetic and serves no actual function. USB-C is backwards compatible with USB3.
 
You're all making me jealous. My 13" rMBP early 2015 works just fine....

BUT:
a 16" display
16GB Ram
500GB SSD
dedicated graphics

What's not to like...oh right, the price... :(

Just can't justify it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peperino
On the German Apple site they list it as the 16" MBP. Shouldn't they use metric and call it the 41cm MBP?
screen sizes are always reported in inches no matter the country, unless it’s France where it’s the law.

little known fact is that the UK still uses the imperial system, especially for driving.
 
Do they have them on display? I’d like to try out the keyboard before I pull the trigger.
Apple store in Cincinnati had them on display, I tried. And then pulled the trigger.
They actually had one sitting right next to the 13’ MacBook Pro so I could test the differences very easily. It’s night and day IMO. Much quieter and satisfying.
Took them long enough!
 
Worse thing was they broke. Having the cable permanently fixed to the charger and a no strain relief was a disaster. People wrapped the cable around the charger and ended up tearing the cable out of the charger. Then the quality of the charger itself was poor and subject to shorting out. The only thing good was that at $70 for a replacement, they generated a lot of high-margin revenue for Apple.
How many times I avoided that my MacBook should crash to the floor thanks to MagSafe!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Peperino
Received mine a few hours ago, migrating from a Macbook Pro 15 Mid 2014.

Keyboard feels great, a little less travel compared to my old keyboard. Screen is great, trackpad is massive.

But the speakers... the speakers are so great. Watched some trailers on YouTube, they sound amazing!
 
  • Like
Reactions: ersan191
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.