The point was your pitching staff is not as good this year as last year.
When you lose a Pedro Martinez, your pitching staff isn't improving. Just like the 2004 Yankees after losing Pettite and Clemens.
However, in 2004 through roughly 400 combined innings, the tandem of Clement and Wells had an ERA of 3.71. Pedro/Lowe combined for 4.66. Have we lost an Ace in Pedro? Absolutely. Is the staff worse? Time will tell, but the numbers say no. We've replaced the production, to be sure, but is "the presence" of Pedro worth any wins?
Not against the Yankees, obviously. Aren't you his Daddy? Would Pedro have fared any better than Wells on Sunday night in the cold at the Toilet?
If I were you, I wouldn't dismiss Timmy Wakefield like so much chaff. In his eleven starts against the Yankees since 2002:
70 IP
46 Hits
31 Walks
46 Ks
22 ER
2.83 ERA
1.10 WHIP
.179 BAA
At Yankee Stadium, his ERA is 2.58 in the same span (playoffs included). This doesn't even count his relief appearances, but I'm sure you remember Game 5.
The Sox relievers are markedly better as well, as proven over the last two postseasons. Timlin, Embree, and Foulke were absolute NAILS, while Gordon was puking in the bullpen and Rivera was busy blowing two games in the same day. International Serial Killer Mike Myers is a better LH specialist than whatever Stottlemeyer cobbles together.
Manny Ramierz has a 1.104 OPS against Tanyan Sturtze, the only man dumb enough to try to pick a fight with Gabe Kapler (World's Strongest Jew) during the brawl. I pray that Joe Torre trust Sturtze enough to use him in high-leverage situations the rest of this season.
Kevin Brown isn't healthy NOW, so was that your fifth starter throwing relief the last two games?
Do you really want Kevin Brown as your fifth starter? How exactly is he better than Arroyo? As far as PAB's go, I would think that ARod fits the description best, what with all the slapping going on.
And then there's Wade Miller. If he comes back healthy (granted that's a huge "if"), he's better than anyone on either staff other than RJ and Schilling.
Rivera needs to find that groove again
What groove is that? The one where he isn't mortal against the Sox? Since 2001, 11 of his 27 blown saves have come against the Sox, including the last 4 in a row.
As for 768 year old in the outfield, its better than that caveman you have runnin around out there. And Bernie's pretty darn good in the post season. Matsui can center too.
This is just plain wrong. Damon has no arm, but neither does Bernie. At least Damon still has his legs an reflexes. Every defensive metric known to man has Williams as one of the worst defensive centerfielders in the game. If I get around to buying the Neyer-James book, I'll throw the numbers up. Bubba Crosby is an upgrade at this point.
Look, I don't mean to go off on every little detail, and I apologize for the long post (it's better that actually working). Sorry.