This is Rodgers 7th year as a starter? Lets see him do it for another 7 years, bump his career winning percentage up to around .750, and win some more championships/playoff games and then there will be a good debate.
Let us not forget the last playoff game Rodgers played in his team choked away a 19-7 lead with 5 minutes left (and possession).
I think Rodgers is the better player at this point in time when it comes to athleticism/physical skills as a quarterback. He's 31 and in his prime. But career-wise, he's got a long way to go before he can be in the same conversation as guys like Brady and Montana.