Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Still not sure if I'm a fan
Same, one concern I have is that it becomes untenable, the NCAA makes billions off the backs of these players and their refusal to pay them, caused this. Now NIL offers these people money in their pockets, and I don't blame them, but it becomes like the wild west. Throw in the transfer portal and its like the NFL where everyone is on a single year contract.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
I didn't even know the Pac 12 championship game was on last night - probably past my bed time ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. So now USC is 11 - 2, while Ohio State is 11-1. This could mean that Ohio State sneaks into the playoffs. Plus it should be a cautionary tale TCU, they should be Kansas State today, but if there's a trap game on the schedule, this could be it. Kansas state is a good team.

1670066278664.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
I didn't even know the Pac 12 championship game was on last night - probably past my bed time ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. So now USC is 11 - 2, while Ohio State is 11-1. This could mean that Ohio State sneaks into the playoffs. Plus it should be a cautionary tale TCU, they should be Kansas State today, but if there's a trap game on the schedule, this could be it. Kansas state is a good team.

View attachment 2122819
Same.
 
If TCU loses, it will be the same bull - Georgia, Michigan. Ohio State, Alabama. The college playoffs are getting tiresome and boring.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
I tend to agree - maybe the playoff will get more interesting as it expands, but I find myself being more excited for interesting bowl matchups than the playoff.
 
Or ... You could be right!

TCU is losing to Kansas State with 3 minutes to go... #eyeroll

Full blame to coaching for not sneaking it on the goal line.

But watch. Georgia, Michigan, Ohio State and Alabama. The committee is too cowardly to pick anyone else other than the "safe" choices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
Ohio State is all but guaranteed to be in. My prediction is:
1 - Georgia
2 - Michigan
3 - Ohio State
4 - TCU

Alabama had too many close calls and unimpressive wins to leap over TCU and/or Ohio State, and USC plays in a mediocre conference. I see no other possible outcome of the CFP.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
Ohio State is all but guaranteed to be in. My prediction is:
1 - Georgia
2 - Michigan
3 - Ohio State
4 - TCU

Alabama had too many close calls and unimpressive wins to leap over TCU and/or Ohio State, and USC plays in a mediocre conference. I see no other possible outcome of the CFP.
o man!

UM has to beat OSU again!?!?
 
I'm hoping a 1 loss TCU gets in, over a 2 loss Alabama. Knowing the committee's preference for SEC, I wouldn't be terribly surprised that they'd choose Alabama over TCU
 
TCU lost by 3 points. Ohio State was drubbed good by Michigan. So maybe…
Georgia
Michigan
TCU
Ohio State

If that's the lineup, then a Michigan vs. Ohio State rematch is not guaranteed, in fact, unlikely. But if it happened, that would be the championship game. Now wouldn't that be one for the ages!
 
  • Wow
Reactions: pachyderm
Ohio State is all but guaranteed to be in. My prediction is:
1 - Georgia
2 - Michigan
3 - Ohio State
4 - TCU

Alabama had too many close calls and unimpressive wins to leap over TCU and/or Ohio State, and USC plays in a mediocre conference. I see no other possible outcome of the CFP.

But the committee is SEC-obsessed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
Welp, it's set now. Georgia v. OSU, Michigan v. TCU. I smell a Georgia route over Michigan in the Championship.
 
Welp, it's set now. Georgia v. OSU, Michigan v. TCU. I smell a Georgia route over Michigan in the Championship.

So we will get to see UGA beat the top 2 B10 teams again showing how the SEC is superior. :oops:
 
Same, one concern I have is that it becomes untenable, the NCAA makes billions off the backs of these players and their refusal to pay them, caused this. Now NIL offers these people money in their pockets, and I don't blame them, but it becomes like the wild west. Throw in the transfer portal and its like the NFL where everyone is on a single year contract.

The NCAA is fueled by March Madness (>80% of revenue), not football.

Compared to the nine-figure budgets for a top-tier athletic program, the NCAA's MM fund payout for a deep run into the tourney will only cover a fraction of that, and has to be split.

The big money is in football, with schools like Texas, Oklahoma, USC, and UCLA are defecting to the SEC and Big Ten respectively for larger football-contract driven payouts. The SEC figure was ~$54M last year, and those media deals are being renewed at higher rates.

The bowl system and CFP is entirely self-governing, and the revenues go straight to the conferences, which determine how to split it up to their members. NCAA plays little, if any role in the football postseason.

Ultimately, the schools are the ones who have benefited solely from the "student-athletes" and been resistant to change things, while hiding behind that term, until court cases and legislation forced their hand.

NIL, and the free transfer portal, is just a practical acknowledgement about what has driven the system all along.

Eventually, they could drop all pretenses, and football will end up with three mega-conferences.
 
As a side note, how awesome is it to not have Alabama and Clemson year after year?!!! I'm happy to see any of the top 4 teams I listed win the championship (though as a Buckeye fan, I wouldn't shed a tear if Michigan were to get blown out no matter who they play ;) )
I’m loving the fact that Alabama isn’t in the CFP. Would be thrilled to see The Ohio State win it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Herdfan
I’m loving the fact that Alabama isn’t in the CFP. Would be thrilled to see The Ohio State win it.
To be honest, I'd love to see a completely new slate of teams in the playoffs - so much so, I'd rather see someone other then Ohio state (and Georgia). Once we get the expanded playoffs hopefully things will change. I don't know if the change will be good or bad, but it will change.
 
To be honest, I'd love to see a completely new slate of teams in the playoffs - so much so, I'd rather see someone other then Ohio state (and Georgia). Once we get the expanded playoffs hopefully things will change. I don't know if the change will be good or bad, but it will change.

First, I think they went to far going to 12; 8 would would have been a good number. Take the 5 P5 champions, the top ranked G5 team and 2 at-larges.

I think even with 12, you are going to get basically the same 4 teams in the semis you would have now. Granted Alabama could beat any of the current teams in the Top 4 and UT probably could have before they lost their QB, but they didn't when it counted. So why do they need to get another chance?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.