I thought the same way until I bought a pair. I have the beats X but I use my AirPods all the time. I find the thumping noise very irritating while walking with noise isolated sets - every step is thump thump. Phone calls are better on AirPods because it is difficult to talk on isolated buds. I still use my beats x for listening in bed at night. I also own the solo 3 which I use around house.No noise isolation, no volume controls, fall out during exercise. Plenty of better options for less.
Volume control is surprisingly not and issue for me. Before I got I the AirPods I thought it would be a deal breaker but is not. I always have my phone in my pocket or nearby and it is easy to adjust volume.