Hum... read the article, maybe?
You don't have to have them tell you. There's such thing as circumstantial evidence. Apple is hiring people to work on wireless power. There are still references to AirPower in new products. If it were cancelled, they've had plenty of time to remove those references or not add them at all to new products and they wouldn't be hiring people to work on it.
Apple hasn’t made an official announcement of any kind. There are some references in software for other products that MAY mean something or may just be leftover references that haven’t yet been removed. There hasn’t been any official announcements about the AirPower pad.
I understand that what they are trying to do is technically difficult. No one else has released a pad where you can place a phone/watch/iPad anywhere and in any order and it will charge. I believe all of the multi component charging pads require you to place a specific item on a specific part of the pad for it to work. If it was easy one of those other suppliers would already have a place anywhere pad for sale.
But this secrecy BS needs to stop.
If it’s been canceled say so.
If you don’t know if the technical issues can be solved but Apple is still working on it then say so.
Not saying anything isn’t better than giving an honest status. This is similar to their battery fiasco. Had they said up front what the IOS update would do and the consequences of turning on the slowdown feature vs not turning it on they they would have been better served.
Instead they decided not to say what they did or why.
This isn’t some secret product that Apple has never admitted exists but a formally announced product that was promised within a specific time frame. They don’t need to go into details but they should say whether or not the product development is dead or not.
Are they legally required to say anything? No. Is it bad PR? Yes, especially on top of other problems Apple has had with keyboards and homepods and software features.
The secrecy may be legal but that doesn’t mean it’s smart.