Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
It should be capitalized shouldn't it?

In my opinion it should, it just makes more sense to me.
1. What with capitols being used to abbreviate things (A=Avatar)
2. For the historical references to the chip in that picture.

Edit: I'm am of course not trying to say my opinion counts for everything, just thinking out loud.
 
180 days and 250 posts, eh? Hmm... I've been a member for 6 years (July 16, 2002), and only have 151 posts. Guess I'll be able to use the marketplace in another 4 years. It's not that I'm not active, it's that most topics aren't worth posting to.
 
In my opinion it should, it just makes more sense to me.
1. What with capitols being used to abbreviate things (A=Avatar)
2. For the historical references to the chip in that picture.

Edit: I'm am of course not trying to say my opinion counts for everything, just thinking out loud.
This issue was addressed in this thread:
A conscious decision to match the lowercase style of macrumors regular.
 
180 days and 250 posts, eh? Hmm... I've been a member for 6 years (July 16, 2002), and only have 151 posts. Guess I'll be able to use the marketplace in another 4 years. It's not that I'm not active, it's that most topics aren't worth posting to.
LOL, yeah no kidding. I think the only reason I have over 200 posts in 6 months is because of the Apple hardware I have. I usually visit 5 different forums in one day.

Well, you can always start hitting the "I just got my iMac" threads and congratulate them. That will up your post count a bit. :)
 
I don't know if it's been mentioned before, but isn't it worth putting a sticky in each subforum that FS/FT/IC threads might crop up with a big "None of those threads" notice?
 
I'm glad I just completed my transaction in the Marketplace, because it'll probably be another year before I can use it again. :(
 
Duff-Man says...I think that the new changes are most welcome, but I also think that it is going to cause a spike in "junk" threads in the other forums when newbies can't see a marketplace - after all - one only needs to have a peek in the wasteland to see all the threads that are moved their because of non-eligibility.

(aside - perhaps it is a bit of a pain but when moving an ineligible thread to the wasteland instead of just locking it I think the contents should be deleted - perhaps with a simple "ineligible marketplace ad" tag in its place, lest any members see it and respond anyway - otherwise it is not totally enforcing the rules.)

I don't post here much anymore - partly because of time constraints but mainly because it's just become too aggravating. I'd always thought most Mac users were a bit above the intelligence of the mainstream peecee crowd but when I see the daily threads about "can I install my *blah blah blah* OS" discs anywhere or "which is the best browser" or "defrag" or countless others I just have to start to wonder...sheesh people, save yourself the time - *read* the rules you agreed to when you signed up, and search before you ask - you not only save yourself time but others as well...don't be so freakin' lazy....oh yeah!
 
...I also think that it is going to cause a spike in "junk" threads in the other forums when newbies can't see a marketplace - after all - one only needs to have a peek in the wasteland to see all the threads that are moved their because of non-eligibility.


That's something we've discussed and hope to manage in any fine-tuning as things bed in.


I don't post here much anymore - partly because of time constraints but mainly because it's just become too aggravating.

Understandable, but it's a shame. Oh yeah.
 
I don't post here much anymore - partly because of time constraints but mainly because it's just become too aggravating. I'd always thought most Mac users were a bit above the intelligence of the mainstream peecee crowd...

Exactly one of the reasons I don't post too often. Some thread titles I just look at and say to myself, "Are you serious?"
 
Duff-Man says...I think that the new changes are most welcome, but I also think that it is going to cause a spike in "junk" threads in the other forums when newbies can't see a marketplace

I wonder if not advertising the Market Place would be a reasonable solution to junk posts from Newbies?

Perhaps if there is no mention of it in the site benefits / introduction, and they can't see it, then there would be no rush to unlock it by posting junk.

I've been on other forums where there were unknown benefits to people who had obtained a certain level. Once you reached said level, the computer (or a moderator) would send out an invite to join the other higher-level members in the newly available portion of the site.
 
I feel the need to reiterate this point, because it appears that some people are looking over the major reason for this change. By requiring people to have a 250 post count, it will help to develop a better understanding about who the person is, and if they are trustworthy. Somebody would have to spend a fair deal of time editing their posts and being extremely careful as to what they say if they were to be an untrustworthy person, and attempt to pass off the point that they were not so. By having 250 posts, if somebody were planning on making a large financial transaction, then they would have a larger amount of posts to read over to understand as to who they are dealing with. I understand how people are complaining that they are being prevented from a right on the forum, but it is not a right, but rather a privilege. You might be a trustworthy person with only 30 posts, but somebody planning on making a $1500 transaction with you wants to have a little bit more proof than 30 posts from somebody. Even if you have been a long time member here, but are more of a lurker than a poster, than you probably haven't developed much for a name for yourself, and there won't be as much of a spool of posts for somebody to read over.

I understand what you're saying, but let's be honest...there's been a number of scams that have occurred here, and those people all had the 100+ posts needed to start a Marketplace thread.

Do you really think that adding to the post count will make a difference? Sure, it might dissuade lazy scammers, but won't stop a determined one from building up a post count to run one big, expensive scam (easily done when you're dealing with Apple equipment, which is pricey).

On the other hand you have someone like me; yes, I have a low post count, but I have tons of MR member references. I pay promptly, within minutes of closing a deal, and maintain good communications with traders. Shouldn't that count for more than someone who has plenty of time to just interject into various threads?

Yes, I know it's a privilege and not a right to use the MR forums. I'm just saying that I think the new rules will only limit the Marketplace and will result in less buyers and sellers, never a good thing for a Marketplace.
 
wow... this is awesome. cant tell you how many times ive declined a transaction because the person who replied was a 'newbie' with one other post.
 
Today is July 1. As previously announced, the following changes have been made:
  • The Marketplace forum has become the Marketplace Archive forum.
  • The Marketplace Archive forum is open for posting replies but closed to new threads.
  • Members already involved in Marketplace deals should complete their transactions between now and July 15. We strongly suggest that you exchange contact information now.
  • A new Marketplace forum is available in the Community section, but only to qualifying members. If you don't see the new forum, you are not yet qualified.
  • Qualified members with 250 or more posts and memberships of 180 days or longer can participate in the new Marketplace forum.
The transition period will end July 15, at which time:
  • The Marketplace Archive forum will be closed to posting and moved to the Archive section.
  • Members still involved in deals in the Marketplace Archive forum will have to rely on Private Messages and/or email, not posts, to complete their transactions.
  • The new Marketplace forum will remain available only to members with 250 or more posts and memberships of at least 180 days.
  • For everyone else, the new Marketplace forum will be unavailable until they reach 250 posts and 180 days of membership.
 
Im totally for the new rules, they have obviously been well considered. I look forward to doubling my post count in order to qualify. And because most replies in forums are of a great standard, I rarely need to contribute. There can only be so many people repeating and agreeing with comments to make an interesting read. So I guess Ill see you in the marketplace in three more years, or I bite the bullet and go wild with semi-useless comments... alas.
 
Since I don't have to worry about post count or membership length, I think a better idea would have been to implement a simple feedback system and limiting the number of concurrent items for sale to prevent mass fraud (ala MacBooksRock).
 
Since I don't have to worry about post count or membership length, I think a better idea would have been to implement a simple feedback system and limiting the number of concurrent items for sale to prevent mass fraud (ala MacBooksRock).
The only problem with that, is that it would cost a huge part on the mod's time to moderate it, it would be their primary focus on the site, when it is only supposed to be an extra.
 
This is great, It will be an extra step to help us all from getting scammed, like I and many others did with MacBooksRock (who's item I never got). Now my only issue is getting enough posts, I've been a member for almost two years and I look forward to regaining marketplace privileges, I've done so many good deals there.

Props to the staff for making this change.
 
What part needs moderation - the feedback? The rest can be handled by a capable programmer.

I too am up for a feedback system, maybe something like a thread where only people who you've dealt with can post. This could be done with a special PM or a similar message.
 
Forgive me if this has been considered before, but has the forum staff ever thought of appointing a moderator just for the MarketPlace forum? I think this would save a lot of time for all the other staff members....
 
Im happy about this :)


Means Ill be doing transactions with people from the community rather than a random person who passes by :)
 
I'm having trouble subscribing to the new Marketplace RSS feed. Webkit/Safai/NetNewsWire are all saying "unknown feed type". Any clues why?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.