Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Mine is exactly the same. It looks like they came up a bit short on the depth of the case which is causing the sides and top to pull back a bit and for the buttons to not match up quite right. The feel of the case is great though as you mentioned. I also appreciate that they aren't making everyone ship back their defective cases. Truly top tier customer service.

Agreed I think the problem will be solved. Just waiting on their revised versions that they’ll have next week. Yes they told me I don’t have to ship my current one back out either.
 
I got the California Poppy to go with my PB max. It looks great.

Here are a couple comparison pics. You can see they are almost the same in thickness!

Very nice! The silicone case is definitely bulkier. I might do the same and have one nice leather option and the Sheath.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tulipo
Just wanted to give an update on my experience of 1.5 week of use on the Lucid Clear on my 12 Pro Max. I used Sheaths on both my 11 Pro and 11 Pro Max before this and loved it and this is the find time I tried a clear case.

Initially, I found the case VERY slippery, and after some use, it still seems a bit too slippery for me, although I have not dropped it yet cause of that. I got the very first batch of it since I ordered a while ago before the 12 Pro Max came out. Initial fit was kinda finicky, I found that bottom lip just didn't clip in and formed a bit of a V shape as if the phone was a little too big for the case. So far I find myself having to re-clip the case or snug it back into the phone as it has wiggle room and can start to come out easily as I use and put it on my back pocket etc. I put a Belkin screen protector on it and find that with the added thickness of the screenprotector, the lip around the case is not providing as much protection. Since I am waiting on them to send me a revised batch I will wait and see how the fitment of that goes before I decide to switch back to the Sheath or get the iCarez glass protector. They said there is a RIGHT way to put the case on, to put the bottom in first then clip on the rest. Attached are pictures so you can see the cutouts and fitment. Not the best as I took them on my XS Max.
That’s EXACTLY the fit issues on the case that scratched the hell out of my daughter’s pacific blue 12 Pro steel side. It was one scratch. It was deep but didn’t expose any silver because Apple did put a very thick coating on these phones.

I was sent a replacement that had the same exact issue. But there was one sent to me at the same time as my daughter got hers and it fit fine so I gave it to her. But even the non defective Lucid Clear just didn’t feel like the ones we had on her Xr, my old Xr and my 11 Pro or even my SE2.

I got us Casekoo clear TPU/hard plastic back cases instead and those work out better for us because we have decided we want to change our cases more this year. Usually we just stick the Lucid Clear on and forget about it.

I wanted to get a 12 Pro Max Sheath in blue for my husband for Christmas but it looks like it might be a bit of a wait for the new inventory. Caudabe did give me discounts and free screen protectors as a sort of apology for what happened to my daughter’s phone.

I don’t blame them. Flat clear highly polished steel sides, what could possibly go wrong?

They did ask me to send in the defective case so they could analyze the problem. So I sent it to them.
 
That’s EXACTLY the fit issues on the case that scratched the hell out of my daughter’s pacific blue 12 Pro steel side. It was one scratch. It was deep but didn’t expose any silver because Apple did put a very thick coating on these phones.

I was sent a replacement that had the same exact issue. But there was one sent to me at the same time as my daughter got hers and it fit fine so I gave it to her. But even the non defective Lucid Clear just didn’t feel like the ones we had on her Xr, my old Xr and my 11 Pro or even my SE2.

I got us Casekoo clear TPU/hard plastic back cases instead and those work out better for us because we have decided we want to change our cases more this year. Usually we just stick the Lucid Clear on and forget about it.

I wanted to get a 12 Pro Max Sheath in blue for my husband for Christmas but it looks like it might be a bit of a wait for the new inventory. Caudabe did give me discounts and free screen protectors as a sort of apology for what happened to my daughter’s phone.

I don’t blame them. Flat clear highly polished steel sides, what could possibly go wrong?

They did ask me to send in the defective case so they could analyze the problem. So I sent it to them.

Hmm, they said they won't be sending out a revised version until 1-2 weeks when I contacted them last week... hopefully the version they sent me isn't the one they sent you. I'm looking at comments regarding the Sheath as well and seems like there's also fitment issues. Maybe it's best to wait 1-2 months so they can iron out all the small issues.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5105973
I got the California Poppy to go with my PB max. It looks great.

Here are a couple comparison pics. You can see they are almost the same in thickness!

Ok I exchanged the Apple Silicone for the Apple Leather case and you’re right it’s definitely slimmer and much nicer than the silicone. Thanks for steering me lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tulipo
Really like my black sheath must of got lucky straight up, such a perfect fit and feel, slimmer and less of a lip than than my apple black leather which i like, just waiting for my magsafe charger to arrive to test, but will probably sell the leather case.

Think i am done case wise this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tulipo
Really like my black sheath must of got lucky straight up, such a perfect fit and feel, slimmer and less of a lip than than my apple black leather which i like, just waiting for my magsafe charger to arrive to test, but will probably sell the leather case.

Think i am done case wise this year.
They told me today that the black revised models are already available so maybe you did get a revised model. Some of the colors are still a week out.
 
I've also been a satisfied Caudabe customer for my last 3 or 4 iPhones. Even though I've also tried other manufacturers my preferred cases were always the Caudabes. Because of this I ordered 2 Sheaths for my 12ProMax, a gray and a black. The gray is fine but the black one suffers from the same fitment issues so many others have noted: both top and bottom panels bow out due to the cases being too small. The same problem exists on the sides but to a lesser degree. I've also been promised a replacement whenever a revised mold is finalized with no return requirement.
 
Well I got tempted by an offer by Casetify and ordered one of those. What a nightmare I had and 4 different order changes later because stock was running out, so I cancelled my order and will never bother with them again.

I’m back to this brand and will order a navy blue sheath I am thinking for my blue iPhone 12. Can you guys tell me please if this model has been one of the sources of fitment issues? These cases are still nicer looking than the Apple cases in my opinion but knowing my luck i’ll have to return it unless I get an up to date revision model lol.
 
Well I got tempted by an offer by Casetify and ordered one of those. What a nightmare I had and 4 different order changes later because stock was running out, so I cancelled my order and will never bother with them again.

I’m back to this brand and will order a navy blue sheath I am thinking for my blue iPhone 12. Can you guys tell me please if this model has been one of the sources of fitment issues? These cases are still nicer looking than the Apple cases in my opinion but knowing my luck i’ll have to return it unless I get an up to date revision model lol.
Can’t help you on the blue but my black is great, got it 3 weeks ago now so must of been a early one. I have the black apple leather too, sheath is better, bit smaller and lip not as high which I like, doesn’t show marks.
Isn‘t there a seller there? There is one here in Melbourne better than buying from US and waiting 3 weeks, easier return too if needed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The-Real-Deal82
Can’t help you on the blue but my black is great, got it 3 weeks ago now so must of been a early one. I have the black apple leather too, sheath is better, bit smaller and lip not as high which I like, doesn’t show marks.
Isn‘t there a seller there? There is one here in Melbourne better than buying from US and waiting 3 weeks, easier return too if needed.
They eventually turn up on Amazon but the sheath hasn’t arrived on there yet. I’d rather buy from Amazon as the returns are so easy. I haven’t found a UK supplier as yet. Thanks for the info btw
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robbosan
I took a punt and ordered direct from Caudabe in the US. Delivered for £19 with a discount code. I’m guessing i’ll just get refunded if it doesn’t fit and if they don’t i’ll use chargeback through PayPal anyway. Hopefully it’ll be like Robbosan’s and pucker
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robbosan
The magsafe charger works good with the sheath, doesn't grip as hard as the apple leather still enough to work so is easier to get off. Only used it once with the apple leather and can see the ring mark, nothing on the sheath.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The-Real-Deal82
Hi all, does the Sheath case for iPhone 12PM fit the iphone with a Spigen full cover screen protector without lifting up the edges? Is it Spigen screen protector friendly?


I ordered a black Sheath 2 days ago and concerned about the compatibility with a different brand screen protector vs Caudabe’s own screen protector.

My thin fit Spigen case is perfect fit wise with a Spigen screen protector. The sides ever so slightly hug all around the iPhone frame.

I hope Caudabe sends me the revised Sheath case. I heard there is some issues with fit with Sheath ones. I chose the black because I prefer black color and all other colors was out-of-stock at the time of purchase. Was the black color specifically the more problematic color compared to gray, navy, sea green, electric blue??

There is a 30% Black Friday sale on now on Caudabe website. I bought my Sheath using the BF coupon code.
Happy shopping people!
 
Well got my replacement sheath today and the grip is a night and day difference from my first one. The first one I had feels like it’s been used already as it’s worn down so much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PaladinGuy
Well got my replacement sheath today and the grip is a night and day difference from my first one. The first one I had feels like it’s been used already as it’s worn down so much.

Grip? Didn’t know some had faulty texture as you say. I thought it was only fitment issues. Interesting.
 
Grip? Didn’t know some had faulty texture as you say. I thought it was only fitment issues. Interesting.
Yeah, I bought a sea green and had no issues with fitment, but the grip seemed off. Glad I went with my gut and requested a replacement, since it’s a night and day difference between the replacement and the first one I got. The first one feels like it’s already been worn down. Felt like a bar of soap
 
  • Like
Reactions: JBlass421
Yeah, I bought a sea green and had no issues with fitment, but the grip seemed off. Glad I went with my gut and requested a replacement, since it’s a night and day difference between the replacement and the first one I got. The first one feels like it’s already been worn down. Felt like a bar of soap

Well glad problem is solved. The grip texture is the main unique feature about these cases so if that’s not right other than slimness and A+ fitment then it defeats the purpose lol
 
I bought a Sheath for my iPhone 12 mini in grey, received it yesterday and unfortunately it doesn't fit well, and still doesn't hug the sides in the middle. Contacted support, I guess ill see what they say Monday.
 
Late reply but yes, the Apple leather case is definitely slimmer than the Sheath.

I actually disagree I own both an Apple leather case and a sheath case and the sheath is slimmer not by much but definitely slimmer. When I wear the apple leather case on my phone I feel a slight bulk over the Sheath. But hey not trying to create a dispute over this. I love both my apple leather and sheath. They’re always my 2 go to cases and both are definitely slim cases.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.