More and more are leaving apple in higher ranks. Seems like it’s not worth it anymore. Tim is a bean counter. And we are witnessing a very slow but assured decline in the apple that put experience and vision above all else for the last 20 years. There’s a reason Tim is shifting toward services. It’s a pure numbers game that doesn’t involve physical products. Don’t be surprised if apples car project is actually building a self driving Uber service rather than a consumer car.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Announces Upcoming Departure of Lead Product Designer Evans Hankey
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
yes, but it was significantly flawed, engineering-wise.
Given that the current design language and environmental care ethos involves using block aluminum, can’t see how anything like the old Cube would happen today.
Maybe. But Tim Apple surely isnt ready to leave Apple.
Yes, when MR. Cook resigns.
No it hasn’t.
No it’s not and stage manager will be fine.
1. She's been around for much longer than that and was probably picked for the right reasons
2. The shape of what we've seen since 2019 probably has more to do with the state of hardware technology and the evolution of Apple has a supply chain giant as opposed to being one of the most influencial company in industrial design.
For the rest, it's going to be difficult to comment given the lack of context behind the departure. She's staying for 6 additional months so it's probably her call. Apple loose yet another creative talent, which sucks. If the head of industrial design doesn't want to continue, it probably does not mean good for the future products.
If you are interested in how Steve's era works. You could probably derived a lot of information from their quarterly report alone. It was a lot more of that is what the designer wants ( including Steve himself ), and the COO goes and get this **** done.
Now it is a lot more about budgeting.
The timing is surely interesting. I sincerely hope it's not because she had to release an inferior product due to supply chain and marketing demands (the new basic iPad).
I'm obviously not part of the Apple design team, but trying to logically separate out what a product designer's responsibilities are vs. someone in engineering/operations, I'm having a hard time thinking that a designer has a say in accessory/apple pencil compatibility, or what specific charger (USB C/Lightning) is going to be used. To me, they are more focused on the shape, form factor, ergonomics of the design. What actually goes inside the device to make it all work, isn't on them. So while I agree that they are on the hook for some controversial choices, like the notch on the macbooks, the compatibility nightmares with the iPad are someone else's problem. At least thats my 2 cents.
That sucks. A little worried about what's going to happen to Apple's designs going forward. I personally think Apple's hardware quality and designs have been excellent since Evans took the helm. I am only speculating but if her departure had something to do with cost committees getting a further stranglehold on the design team's autonomy (especially since they are now reporting to operations), someone who will do exactly what the MBAs tell them to do might be appointed to replace her. This will cause more disasters like the new iPad and only Pro tier products being as good as they truly can and pushing more segmentation into product lines, ultimately hurting and confusing the average consumer.
For one, the new MacBooks. The notch. Even Apple thinks it's not attractive, the proof is that they hide it in every marketing pictures or videos they do by making the screen background black. If you think your design is attractive you don't intentionally hide it.
The bottom end of the MacBooks pro looks like my toilet bowl. Symmetrical bottom and top end (like they use to have) is much more pleasing to the eye. It's not a problem if you need to make it boxy, Razer Blades laptops are boxy and I know very few peoples that do not find them aesthetically pleasing. I get that a lot of peoples will disagree, probably most do not care but since we are on the subject of good looking products.
this is what happens when you shareholders before customer & user experience. Judging by the services push, Eddy Cue has Tim's ear the most now.
In the Jobs / Ive era, the industrial design had the most operational power within Apple. It was a design-led company. That power structure has been undone under Tim Cook's tenure.
I think it‘s pretty clear that decision was based more around Apple having issues fitting the landscape camera and Apple Pencil 2‘s magnetic charging module in the same place more than the design team. Also explaining why the new entry level iPad didn’t get gen 2 Apple Pencil support this year.
There were actually MANY of us here who said the buck stopped with Tim only to be shouted down by the usual suspects for whom Cook can do no wrong
I would have preferred the Studio to get the lattice pattern on the Mac Pro like some renders showed before release.
Apple's product pipeline is, from what I've heard, generally 3-5 years out. So things that are releasing in 2022, Jony Ive probably had a hand in designing.
I think the bigger problem at Apple is that there's no SVP of Design that oversees hardware and software design. A position that would basically assume Jobs's role as a tastemaker and person who had the authority to say "No" to bad designs and bad ideas.
Well said. It’s a shame Tim Apple has destroyed this over the years.
It’s all about the money now and maximising profits before sales start to fall.
I agree. The macOS UI needs to go back. The Big Sur UI doesn't look that pleasing.
Apple’s products for the past 3 years have been going to square boxes. They’re all hideous and feel absolutely terrible to hold.
That woman saw the table she’s sitting on and thought…hey! Let’s make the iPhone a square!! Let’s make everything a square!! That feels good in the hand!! It’s ergonomic!!
A human hand is rounded, not square. There’s a reason your door knob is rounded, your broom handle is rounded, your steering wheel is rounded, not square. It’s because intelligent designers understood that rounded feels good in a human hand; it’s ergonomically sound design. It’s intelligent design.
Apple had gone to intelligent design with the iPhone with rounded edges. Now they’ve gone back to unintelligent design in square edges.
It’s truly sad.
I’m beyond-surprised that the Apple Watch isn’t square yet, and the AirPods.
That woman saw the table she’s sitting on and thought…hey! Let’s make the iPhone a square!! Let’s make everything a square!! That feels good in the hand!! It’s ergonomic!!
A human hand is rounded, not square. There’s a reason your door knob is rounded, your broom handle is rounded, your steering wheel is rounded, not square. It’s because intelligent designers understood that rounded feels good in a human hand; it’s ergonomically sound design. It’s intelligent design.
Apple had gone to intelligent design with the iPhone with rounded edges. Now they’ve gone back to unintelligent design in square edges.
It’s truly sad.
I’m beyond-surprised that the Apple Watch isn’t square yet, and the AirPods.
Last edited by a moderator:
...And yet you are here stroking your ego with no previous work shown to back up your claim
herWhoever takes his place has to pronounce Aluminium like Jonny Ive!