I'm genuinely curious about this as well. Putting all the conspiracy theories aside and assuming this isn't really an evil Samsung plot and that there are a small percentage of iPhone 6+ phones that have this defect, I gotta wonder where these supposed reinforcing structures are? Embedded into the aluminum? Could this be a manufacturing defect where a batch got built without them or with the wrong grade of aluminum? I simply find it hard to believe Apple would have designed a phone housing this malleable.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple: Bending in iPhone 6 Plus From Normal Use 'Extremely Rare', Only 9 Customers Have Complained
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I'm genuinely curious about this as well. Putting all the conspiracy theories aside and assuming this isn't really an evil Samsung plot and that there are a small percentage of iPhone 6+ phones that have this defect, I gotta wonder where these supposed reinforcing structures are? Embedded into the aluminum? Could this be a manufacturing defect where a batch got built without them or with the wrong grade of aluminum? I simply find it hard to believe Apple would have designed a phone housing this malleable.
Are you referring to present Apple owners or new owners?
*No one else owns an iPhone6/6+.
Some first-time Iphone owners, probably prior An&$*%&#( users
Over the night, 2 people posted in the iPhone forums they had a bent phone and MR made it a story the following morning. A fourth follow up story that adds no new information (except omg, 7 more people are now affected) and only perpetuates this stupid story. Just because they started a press frenzy over a non-issue, doesn't mean they can't continue to ride it with article after article. A little comprehension goes a long way.
Just wanted to chime in that my iphone 6 has been subject to the "screen clicking/popping" issue. Basically, you can feel the top left corner of the screen click when you put a small amount of force on it - just like the macbook touchpads.
Initially, I thought it was because I had a defective unit with a partially detached screen. Sure enough, the top corner of my phone was slightly bent which caused the screen to "raise" on the corner. So, the bent corner was actually causing the screen to click - quite an annoying side effect.
For anyone who has been keeping their new phone in their pocket but doesn't immediately notice a visible bend, I'd suggest playing around with the screen to see if it clicks. In my opinion, the clicking effect is far more annoying than having a 3 degree bend...
Initially, I thought it was because I had a defective unit with a partially detached screen. Sure enough, the top corner of my phone was slightly bent which caused the screen to "raise" on the corner. So, the bent corner was actually causing the screen to click - quite an annoying side effect.
For anyone who has been keeping their new phone in their pocket but doesn't immediately notice a visible bend, I'd suggest playing around with the screen to see if it clicks. In my opinion, the clicking effect is far more annoying than having a 3 degree bend...
Macrumors got tons of hits off creating this "press wave" and controversy. Literally took 4 incidents of bent phone claims and made a story that the entire media hopped onto. That ad revenue must be good right now.
Like I said, something is amiss because either several MacRumor users are trolls (successful at that) or Apple isn't completely telling the truth. We do have a lack of pics...but this story has gotten way out of hand.
----------
I was thinking this.
Yeah I see. Like the Malaysia Air catastrophes, it's all news media gold.
Oh and congratulations, you're the random reply winner from my list of over 25 quotes and Tapatalk notifications!
Attachments
If a MEMBER had started this story, macbloomers would have locked the thread, due to <insert made up excuse>... likely "trolling". Funny, it seems to be left to spiral out of control, as it makes MR look "popular"
What a crappy "news" site... utter trash.
I hope you can bend it! if you could not I would be very concerned that apple over engineered a stationary device! The costs of over engineering would be past onto the consumer.
A laptop would also have to withstand damage from backpack and brief cases. I would be pissed If someone told me I must carry my laptop as a backpack would damage it. Should a laptop be designed to travel in a bowling ball bag? I don't think so.
I'm kinda on both sides with this one. I put my Nexus 5 in my pocket with a massive Battery Case. It makes an otter box look anorexic. If I had no case I would be extra careful siting down with it. If I had an iPhone 6 Plus I would never even try it. Not that others are wrong or should not have to make sacrifices, I just could not do it. Call it OCD if you want. WITH THAT BEING SAID. I do also believe apple should have made the 6 Plus stronger and more resistant to bending. I think aluminium unibody design is not acceptable. At the very least they should have put in more internal bracing.
Apple did not recommend users not to put the iPhone in their pockets. If the phone should not be put in pockets apple should have used the opportunity today to say that. Apple has their reasons why they did not, but I'm sure their are some people at apple saying maybe we should have put in a little more effort in the design.
Apple response: This is rare and only affects a small minoritiy of users.
....
Meanwhile Apple is strengthening the chassis of the upcoming 6S to advertise its increased durability.
They have a history of not acknowledging design flaws with a current product only to address them in the next update. See the iPhone 4 antenna issue that was remedied in the 4S for another prime example.
....
Meanwhile Apple is strengthening the chassis of the upcoming 6S to advertise its increased durability.
They have a history of not acknowledging design flaws with a current product only to address them in the next update. See the iPhone 4 antenna issue that was remedied in the 4S for another prime example.
Design Flaw
While I wouldn't ever put my phone in my back pocket, and I'm not concerned with my 6 bending in the leather cover as that adds rigidity (much stiffer than non-Apple leather cases/covers), this is still a design flaw.
Poorly thought out changes from iPhone 5 to 6:
1. Moved On/Off button from top to side, opposite volume buttons. Not only did this line up two week points, a no-no in structural rigidity, it makes it difficult to turn off/on without accidentally adjust volume and vice versa.
2. Volume buttons turned into ovoid bars instead of round buttons. These ovoid bars are twice as long as the old round buttons. They end up creating a very week side of the phone. Long ovoid voids in metal are very week. Round holes in metal, as long as they aren't too large, do very little to impact the strength.
3. Volume buttons now directly opposite SIM slot. So now you have 5 long ovoid voids in the structure (mute, volume x2, on/off, sim) all opposite each other. Very bad design.
4. Made phone too thin. Every millimeter counts in rigidity. An extra millimeter or two would have increased the strength of the phone a very large amount.
Why Apple did this?
They claim that the on/off was too hard to reach 1 handed if left on top. Not sure about the +, but on my 6 I can reach the top of my phone with my first finger rather than thumb to sleep it. No need to reach it to turn it on as you don't press that button to do that.
Volume buttons changed for purely aesthetic reasons. Was it worth it? Hardly.
Thinness is because Ive is obsessed with it even if no customers are asking for it. We asked for better batteries. In the 6, 1 mm would have allowed for 1 mm more of actual battery guts, and at least a 25% capacity increase. My 6 doesn't have enough battery. It's about what the 5 was, and considering it's bigger, it makes no sense.
How Apple can fix it in this iteration:
Resize the buttons in question to be much smaller with round holes. Round holes are much stronger. They can still line up with the case buttons, though the buttons now won't be backed by a full sized button underneath.
What they can do with the next version:
Move the on/off button, decrease the size of the volume buttons.
Make the phone 1mm thicker, and advertise how much better the battery is.
While I wouldn't ever put my phone in my back pocket, and I'm not concerned with my 6 bending in the leather cover as that adds rigidity (much stiffer than non-Apple leather cases/covers), this is still a design flaw.
Poorly thought out changes from iPhone 5 to 6:
1. Moved On/Off button from top to side, opposite volume buttons. Not only did this line up two week points, a no-no in structural rigidity, it makes it difficult to turn off/on without accidentally adjust volume and vice versa.
2. Volume buttons turned into ovoid bars instead of round buttons. These ovoid bars are twice as long as the old round buttons. They end up creating a very week side of the phone. Long ovoid voids in metal are very week. Round holes in metal, as long as they aren't too large, do very little to impact the strength.
3. Volume buttons now directly opposite SIM slot. So now you have 5 long ovoid voids in the structure (mute, volume x2, on/off, sim) all opposite each other. Very bad design.
4. Made phone too thin. Every millimeter counts in rigidity. An extra millimeter or two would have increased the strength of the phone a very large amount.
Why Apple did this?
They claim that the on/off was too hard to reach 1 handed if left on top. Not sure about the +, but on my 6 I can reach the top of my phone with my first finger rather than thumb to sleep it. No need to reach it to turn it on as you don't press that button to do that.
Volume buttons changed for purely aesthetic reasons. Was it worth it? Hardly.
Thinness is because Ive is obsessed with it even if no customers are asking for it. We asked for better batteries. In the 6, 1 mm would have allowed for 1 mm more of actual battery guts, and at least a 25% capacity increase. My 6 doesn't have enough battery. It's about what the 5 was, and considering it's bigger, it makes no sense.
How Apple can fix it in this iteration:
Resize the buttons in question to be much smaller with round holes. Round holes are much stronger. They can still line up with the case buttons, though the buttons now won't be backed by a full sized button underneath.
What they can do with the next version:
Move the on/off button, decrease the size of the volume buttons.
Make the phone 1mm thicker, and advertise how much better the battery is.
OMG my iPad Air 2 Plus just bent when i used it as a swing seat for my kid
I can not believe it my iPad Air 2 Plus with the 12.9 screen just bent all i did was use it as a replacement for my child's swing set chair and the thing bent. How can they build a product like this i should be able to use it as i like it. Maybe they should have though about this when they built it!
I can not believe it my iPad Air 2 Plus with the 12.9 screen just bent all i did was use it as a replacement for my child's swing set chair and the thing bent. How can they build a product like this i should be able to use it as i like it. Maybe they should have though about this when they built it!
Google shares keep dropping too. Weird isn't it?
I have done the same with my 6+ since last Friday and have no damage. This is where the user and common sense come into play.
Even the truth is becoming bent... for a brief period
Earlier models had ZERO bends
To go from 0(after many years) to 9 in only a few days screams problem. It is only a sample from a small population. Many more will come. I would perhaps begin to plan how to make the phone stronger... maybe thicker aluminum by 10 thou, steel ribs... or something! (or a steel screen? lol). The 9 may have been extreme, but how will the phone hold up under less stress over longer periods of time? It is unbelievable that this could not have been tested??!! Stress testing is normal for every product unless you don't care or are pushing it out too quick. My Galaxy Nexus doesn't bend at all. lol. I don't think I ever had a phone that bended... except the Motorola Star tac which was too small and mostly plastic.
To go from 0(after many years) to 9 in only a few days screams problem. It is only a sample from a small population. Many more will come. I would perhaps begin to plan how to make the phone stronger... maybe thicker aluminum by 10 thou, steel ribs... or something! (or a steel screen? lol). The 9 may have been extreme, but how will the phone hold up under less stress over longer periods of time? It is unbelievable that this could not have been tested??!! Stress testing is normal for every product unless you don't care or are pushing it out too quick. My Galaxy Nexus doesn't bend at all. lol. I don't think I ever had a phone that bended... except the Motorola Star tac which was too small and mostly plastic.
I am buying the iPhone 6+ bending Problem or not, not a big deal to me. The 6+ is so thin and big, I know it might bend easy. I already got the case for it and it will be on my belt, whenever Apple have the 6+ in stock. But I hope Apple fix the IOS 8 by the time the 6+ in stock.
Last edited:
With "problem" I meant specifically in the design of the original iPhone 4 antenna. Apple as far as I know never acknowledged a problem in the design of the antenna, merely a reduced reception caused by the user's grip not specific to the iPhone 4 and which affects all wireless phones. Apple even explicitly stated to be happy with the iPhone 4's antenna design.
It's edited. Maybe his first footage of the bending force didn't look good so he did some more?
Apple is held to a higher standard than a lot of other companies due to the fact that they typically set the bar for quality. The whole world watches them and their products. This is still no excuse for inferior engineering and durability testing in the 6+...