Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Just wondering, do you keep your avacodo toast next to your HomePod on top of your vintage oak countertop treated with danish oil?
 
This isn’t news, any rubber feet on devices leave marks on oiled wood surfaces. Had this with amps and DVD players in the past although they left black spots the same size and shape as the feet of the devices.
 
Last edited:
Anyone can file a lawsuit.
But this one would be frivolous.

If someone is filing a lawsuit, it doesn’t make it ‘frivolous for this one’. For the record, a lawsuit has to be approved by a legal advisor/attorney in order to move forward IF their Was substantial grounds for legitimate reasons what the complainant is seeking damages for.

However, A Lawsuit would be frivolous if there was not enough substantial evidence or documentation to move forward in the legal process. There is a difference.
 
Do you respect wood, Mr Cook?

1*PJKzjrjt3fVvMbaFVeDOWw.png
 
You say this..... Basingstoke, my home town for many years, has the most roundabouts in the UK. Rumour was that they had the map laid out on a table when they were planning the town, and people kept putting their tea/coffee cups down on it. The construction companies thought the cup rings were supposed to be roundabouts.

I think Milton Keynes holds the roundabout record :)
 
Radiating what exactly? And whatever "it" is, by what scientific process would it cause a ring on the table?

This has nothing to do with the speaker or whatever type of radiation you think the speaker is emitting. It's due to silicon reacting with the oiled surface. MacBook feet have the same effect.


Ok remove the speaker ... so how is the ring showing up in the first place according to your scientific understanding then?
 
It's not "damaging wood furniture." It's reacting to oil or wax on the wood that isn't naturally there.
Which is damaging the surface of certain wooden surfaces, maybe very expensive wooden surfaces, you cant blame the furniture! My Zeppelin Wireless has been in place a year and has left no mark. Once again that should have been tested on a variety of wood and wooden surfaces, you cant test them all, that's impossible I know but still who wants rings on your wood from a speaker. I'm pretty sure this could have been avoided. Guess you are using the wrong kind of table , oh look apple makes one for the home pod :rolleyes:
 
We live in a complicated world, just place the HomePod on a small mat. Have two Homepods, both on wooden furniture and they are just fine. Stop making a mountain out of a mole hill.
 
The new Apple:

1. Late to the party.
2. Overpriced vs the competition.
3. No longer the innovative leading force.

But we gots us a round building.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Breezygirl
I don’t think anyone who buys this product is having third world problems.

Thus my point.

In other words, you’re not wondering if you’re going to eat in the next few days, ie, life is pretty good comparatively, ie, in the grand scheme of life, a ring on your furniture is not really a problem.
 
Anything Apple does makes headlines. For websites like this one that make money showing ads, the more outrageous headlines they can show and get people to talk in these forums, the more ads they show and more money they make. So they love it when Apple makes headlines.

Amazon and Google have both also had issues with their devices leaving marks on oiled wood. Amazon even includes a coaster with the Alexa because it caused such issues. But they didn't make headlines because no one cares when they do something. Now if Apple does the same thing, now it's reason to pay attention.
Had Apple provided a disclaimer when the HomePod first went on sale this wouldn’t be an issue. Like the battery throttling it’s a communications problem. Apple execs should know by now how much focus and attention the company gets. Provide a disclaimer, heck include in the documentation in the box. The fact that they didn’t do it makes me wonder if they didn’t come across it in QA and judy hastily wrote something up after they were called out on it.
 
Did your mum teach you how to take care of oil or wax finished furniture? Is this something you buy? Most people who buy high quality furniture make the effort to learn how to maintain it, and take steps to protect it. This issue does not occur with that table you just bought at IKEA.
Still missing it. Would you put a book or magazine on that table? Most likely, right? Remote control from your tv? Probably yes. iPhone? Yes. Macbook pro? Yes. Homepod? Probably too but hey, this one leaves marks.
Its about expectations vs reality. You just don't expect certain items to leave marks so you don't think about it. And that is the underlining issue here. If they put a label that it stains certain materials then you are made aware (just like mum&glass situation) and you will be careful.

Its the practical thinking here. Anyway, I think you know what I mean so don't be difficult :)
 
Had Apple provided a disclaimer when the HomePod first went on sale this wouldn’t be an issue. Like the battery throttling it’s a communications problem. Apple execs should know by now how much focus and attention the company gets. Provide a disclaimer, heck include in the documentation in the box. The fact that they didn’t do it makes me wonder if they didn’t come across it in QA and judy hastily wrote something up after they were called out on it.

So you think they tested setting it on every single surface known to man to make sure it wasn't going to be an issue? Come on. Oiled wood isn't the most common, especially in the living room and bedroom where most HomePod devices will be set. You can't honestly expect any company to test ever single variable in every situation. Hell, people with oiled wood know that when you set anything on it, it will leave a mark. Those that don't know that are a small minority and it's going to happen no matter what's set on it. In this case a stupid few are complaining about something that has nothing to do with Apple at all. "When I set anything on it, this happens. How dare Apple!"
 
  • Like
Reactions: artfossil
Any natural, organic based finish (such as wax or a mineral/vegetable oil) is prone to some sort of marking. They're not nearly as durable as a poly. As others have said, you set anything on oiled wood and it'll leave a mark.
 
We live in a complicated world, just place the HomePod on a small mat. Have two Homepods, both on wooden furniture and they are just fine. Stop making a mountain out of a mole hill.
DWA8vL7X0AA2AAu.jpg


Joking aside, it's been mentioned that the HomePod needs to be in contact with the surface to get the best sound quality, so cloth mats or coasters might not be the answer.

"Most others devices that I test have small feet that raise them off the counter ever so slightly to cause an air flow," commented Mr Miles.

"But the HomePod appears to need contact with the surface that it's on to resonate and create the powerful bass.

"I put it on a coaster to see if that would combat [leaving a mark] but that destroyed the bass qualities, so that's not a fix to the problem"

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-43064772
 
I don't think this is a big deal, but Apple should have known this before shipping the product and they should've included a disclaimer about it in the documentation. Surely they didn't think people would never sit a speaker on a wood surface that had oil or wax polish on it?

Come on. That's a use test failure that an amateur would make, but this is Apple.
[doublepost=1518703947][/doublepost]
DWA8vL7X0AA2AAu.jpg


Joking aside, it's been mentioned that the HomePod needs to be in contact with the surface to get the best sound quality, so cloth mats or coasters might not be the answer.



http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-43064772

It just means it doesn't get good sound if you're holding it suspended.

It'll be just fine if you put a hard surface under it and that hard surface is on another hard surface.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.