Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Did the guy in the Tweet really add an entry to his Contacts list for Craig Federighi complete with corporate head shot as the profile picture?
 
This should also happen on the iPhone, it's super dangerous especially when driving.
  1. Driving while navigating with Google maps
  2. Ask Siri a question
  3. She answers
  4. The freaking Siri screen just stays there, taking up the entire screen, forever, obscuring the navigation
  5. You have to manually return to Maps while driving, taking your eyes off the road
If Siri has answered your question, it should just go away automatically dammit.

Oh and you know what's worse? Shortcuts. Ask Siri to execute a shortcut, and the screen switches to the Shortcuts app and just sits there even after executing it. Like, why do I have to see it? There is no need to see or interact with any of it, why does the entire app have to come up on the screen and then just stay there? Do the thing I asked and then leave me alone.

If I recall correctly, they mentioned during the keynote that Siri wouldn’t take over the whole screen in CarPlay.
 
This should also happen on the iPhone, it's super dangerous especially when driving.
  1. Driving while navigating with Google maps
  2. Ask Siri a question
  3. She answers
  4. The freaking Siri screen just stays there, taking up the entire screen, forever, obscuring the navigation
  5. You have to manually return to Maps while driving, taking your eyes off the road
If Siri has answered your question, it should just go away automatically dammit.

Oh and you know what's worse? Shortcuts. Ask Siri to execute a shortcut, and the screen switches to the Shortcuts app and just sits there even after executing it. Like, why do I have to see it? There is no need to see or interact with any of it, why does the entire app have to come up on the screen and then just stay there? Do the thing I asked and then leave me alone.

To add to this, when I plug my phone into the car, why does a screen have to come up on the phone that just shows Car Play. Half the time I am trying to set up music to play or a GPS destination right after I plug the phone in and that CarPlay screen just forces me to dismiss it immediately every time. I can see when CarPlay has started by looking at the screen in the car, I don't need the phone to tell me too.
 
To add to this, when I plug my phone into the car, why does a screen have to come up on the phone that just shows Car Play. Half the time I am trying to set up music to play or a GPS destination right after I plug the phone in and that CarPlay screen just forces me to dismiss it immediately every time. I can see when CarPlay has started by looking at the screen in the car, I don't need the phone to tell me too.
This and music auto playing when connecting, it’s annoying and we should have the option to disable auto play when connect to CarPlay
 
"As Federighi's response suggests, adding this less intrusive Siri behavior would require some significant changes to the OS"

Major change? it's only a frekin visual change, not a complete Siri overhaul

Yeah, I mean it could fold down like the notifications do currently at the very least.
 
Ironically Siri was much less obtrusive on iPad 8 years ago.

wwdc-apple-ios-6-siri-ipad_0320021401262961.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: ErikGrim
They probably want to rethink some other things, not just moving it to a smaller window.
For instance, it would allow for a concept where Siri could pop in as an assistent (without getting summoned by you) to tell you something.
Likely they will do the same on the iPhone and move the screen-filling-call-pick-up screens to a smaller window as well.
*Cough* Office clips *Cough*.
Major change? it's only a frekin visual change, not a complete Siri overhaul
Nobody knows how Apple implements Siri. But I highly doubt it is just a simple visual change.
Ironically Siri was much less obtrusive on iPad 8 years ago.

View attachment 842086
Oh yeah... I‘d argue that was because Steve Jobs still took the lead of design. /s
 
iPhone too, please. Sometimes I want to ask Siri something based on what I’m looking at, but can’t remember all the details and then can’t read them anymore once I’ve summoned her.
If you change her to a male voice you gain access this feature
 
Though I don't doubt that Apple will improve the Siri experience on iPad, making a story out of a standard "We'll consider this in the future" reply (which in most case simply is a polite way of companies to answer to customer wishes like these) seems questionable to me even as a "rumor" ...

Here's what is different. First, like Tim Cook, he obviously gets a ton of emails from customers and can't respond to most of them. They know that each of their responses is likely to be shared, so they are very selective in what they respond to from the general public and in what they say. Indeed they have to be careful not to run afoul of stock manipulation claims in these "public" responses. The fact that he chose to respond to this specific one means he chose he words carefully and intended to send a message. Couple that with it couldn't be added "at the last minute" is a validation that he supports it, and we'll likely see it in a subsequent update.
 



Say "Hey Siri" when using an iPad, and Apple's virtual assistant will take over the entire display, obscuring whatever you were doing on the device. Say the same thing to your Mac, however, and Siri responds in a more multitasking-friendly way by appearing in a small window in the corner of the screen, allowing you to drag and drop retrieved items from it.

Conceito-de-Siri-no-iPadOS.jpg

iPad concept of improved Siri behavior (image via iHelp BR)

This less disruptive, more functional implementation of Siri in macOS may well be coming to iPad, although it's unlikely to appear in the first version of iPadOS, which is due to be released this fall. The possibility was hinted at by Craig Federighi, Apple's VP of software engineering, in response to an email sent to him by Apple user Juliano Rossi.

Responding to Rossi's request that Siri on iPadOS behaves like on the Mac, without filling the entire screen, Federighi wrote:

As Federighi's response suggests, adding this less intrusive Siri behavior would require some significant changes to the OS, so it's not something that could be included at this late stage in software testing. But as Portuguese tech blog iHelp BR notes, it's at least good to know that Apple is aware of the legitimate request, which would bring iPadOS even closer to the macOS experience.

Apple often considers user feedback, but sometimes takes a while to act on it. For instance, the company eventually responded to multiple user requests that it change the volume level indicator in iOS. When pressing the volume buttons on iPhone or iPad running iOS 12 or earlier, the volume indicator displays in the center of the screen, obscuring content. As of iOS 13, coming this fall, the indicator is smaller and appears at the side of the display in a less intrusive manner.

Unveiled last week during Apple's WWDC keynote, iPadOS is designed to bring more desktop-class functionality to iPads with bigger screens. iPadOS will incorporate several features that recognize the tablet's function as a potential computer replacement, including a new Home screen, an updated Split View to enhance multitasking, and improved Apple Pencil support.

Article Link: Apple Considering Less Disruptive Siri Behavior in Future Version of iPadOS
[doublepost=1560176502][/doublepost]Sound good. Sooner would better than later.
 
This would be great. I completely disable Siri on my IOS devices because it is so lame and intrusive, but it would be nice to keep a couple of features left on.
 
They should do the same thing for incoming phone calls on iPhone.
I really wish they would’ve done this on the iPhone with ios13. Seriously though, a phone interrupting what your typing or looking at should not be a problem now a days. At least make it an option for the user to decide how they want to be alerted visually
 
At least one uses Siri through choice. Telephone calls on iPad are far more irritating. An interrupting call comes in that you’d prefer to ignore, and your iPad is bricked until the caller gets bored or it goes to voicemail. Quite ridiculous.

Edit: actually I guess in this instance you can press the home button to relegate the call to the background?
 
Last edited:
Though I don't doubt that Apple will improve the Siri experience on iPad, making a story out of a standard "We'll consider this in the future" reply (which in most case simply is a polite way of companies to answer to customer wishes like these) seems questionable to me even as a "rumor" ...
It’s not quite a rumor, true. But it’s a bit much to expect the forum spinoff: MacDefiniteMaybe.com :p
 
Honestly, they should eliminate full screen interactions across the board. Why does a phone call need to cover the whole screen while I'm using the iphone? Just have a small banner that also includes basic controls.
 
Just iPad! Stop giving features just to the freaking iPad...
iPad OS my guy, iPad OS
[doublepost=1560178201][/doublepost]
Honestly, they should eliminate full screen interactions across the board. Why does a phone call need to cover the whole screen while I'm using the iphone? Just have a small banner that also includes basic controls.
Or have a small interface at the bottom 40% of the screen
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.