I just don’t think Apple is stupid and purposely throttling phones to coerce upgrading is a stretch for me. I really think they tried to mitigate an even worse shutdown situation and miscalculated how much it would impact customer experience. I also think there is a small subset of bad batteries that are causing most of the problems.Look man, we're coming from two completely different places. So agree to disagree but here is my viewpoint.
I keep a powerbook G4 12" sitting on my desk next to my main work horses. I keep it there because its beautiful and sometimes I just find myself staring and playing with it; it is a testament to how amazing this company is. Sometimes I even take it to the coffee shop and people ask me what it is, and impressed when I tell them how old it is.
But even with this infatuation, I will not make excuses for them hiding something like throttling of batteries and not informing consumers that the battery was the culprit. The fact is, it was convenient for them to keep it secret and they did us no favors by doing so. I hope nothing comes of the lawsuits BUT I am glad they are there to put pressure on Apple to not pull this again. Until then I will have a wait and see attitude and hold off on updating future purchases. Yeah I'm just one group of purchases, but if enough of vote with our wallets they will pay attention.
Bottom line, there are too many unknowns for me to be so sure they hid anything or did anything wrong. I think they could have communicated better, but ultimately, the are trying to make it right.