Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


The High Court of Paris on Friday denied Apple's request for an injunction that would have blocked activist group Attac from protesting at the company's retail stores across France, as it has been doing for the past several months.

apple-store-attac-800x532.jpg
Attac activists protesting at an Apple Store in France via Libération​
 
Not relevant, fact is you have freedom of speech in Europe, glad the judge denied Apple's request.
It’s mind boggling to me that “freedom of speech” could be construed to allow a bunch of jackasses to disrupt business in a privately owned establishment. In the US, these morons would be facing trespassing and vandalism charges, and rightfully so.

Edit: after rereading, it’s unclear to me whether they were in the stores or on the public sidewalk, which makes ALL the difference. If they were outside, then they’re fine. If inside, arrest ‘em. The vandalism is a crime either way.
 
Wouldn't they just need to prove that their not "peaceful protests". Just need to get pictures or video of the vandalism
It's also pretty easy to get protesters to act violently when you physically remove them from a space.
It’s mind boggling to me that “freedom of speech” could be construed to allow a bunch of jackasses to disrupt business in a privately owned establishment. In the US, these morons would be facing trespassing and vandalism charges, and rightfully so.
The problem Apple faces is that they also allow and encourage other forms of non-violent protest in their own stores (at least in the U.S. they have). So Apple wants to pick and choose their causes but that opens them up others to get into the door.
 
The problem Apple faces is that they also allow and encourage other forms of non-violent protest in their own stores (at least in the U.S. they have). So Apple wants to pick and choose their causes but that opens them up others to get into the door.
No, actually, it doesn’t, at least under US law. In the US, a business (and any private entity) absolutely can engage in viewpoint discrimination. Perhaps France has some kind of “equal time” for private entities - I don’t know.
 
Mentioned this last time there was an article on it. You don't step on the French's right to protest. Mostly because it just won't work. You can take them to court and the judge will take one look at you, one look at the protesters, tear off his wig, tie you up, and start waving a placard too.

It's a beautiful thing.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.