Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPad and MacBook serve two different purposes. The iPad Pro is arguably a niche product but can be very useful for certain pros (architects, engineers, creators, etc.) in situations where a laptop would be impractical. Here are 10 situations where an iPad Pro is better suited than a MacBook:

  1. Handwritten notes, sketches, mind maps. With the Apple Pencil, the iPad Pro becomes a digital notebook: natural handwriting, highlighting, PDF markup, quick diagrams. A MacBook simply can't replicate this without external hardware.
  2. Long-form reading (PDF, scores, comics, articles). The iPad Pro is a reading device: portrait mode, comfortable ergonomics, no keyboard, one‑hand handling. A MacBook may be less pleasant for extended reading sessions.
  3. Professional document annotation. Signing, circling, crossing out, and marking up PDFs or images is dramatically faster with the Pencil. On a MacBook, doing the same with a trackpad is slower and less precise.
  4. Use while standing or moving. In a museum, on the subway, in a standing meeting, in the kitchen: the iPad Pro works like a notebook. The MacBook pretty much requires a surface to be usable.
  5. Drawing, sketching, quick creative work. Apps like Procreate, Fresco, or Concepts turn the iPad Pro into a direct‑input creative tool. On a MacBook, you need a separate drawing tablet.
  6. Casual multimedia consumption. Even pros need a break! Watching videos in bed, on the couch, or on a plane is simply more comfortable on an iPad Pro. The MacBook is heavier, warmer, and forces a fixed posture.
  7. Instant-on tasks. The iPad Pro wakes like a phone: jot a note, scan a document, check an e-mail, take a photo. The MacBook requires opening the lid and adopting a working position.
  8. Document scanning. The iPad Pro doubles as a high‑quality portable scanner (Notes, Files, Adobe Scan). The MacBook can't scan without external devices.
  9. Touch-centric workflows. Maps, floor plans, Kanban boards, creative interfaces: touch is more intuitive and efficient. The MacBook is limited to indirect input.
  10. Ultra-mobile second display. With Sidecar or Universal Control, the iPad Pro becomes a lightweight, tactile, portable second screen. A MacBook can't serve this role.
I was comparing the iPad Pro with the MacBook, not the iPad or the iPad Air. For casual multimedia consumption, long-form reading and light use (while standing or moving) the iPad and iPad Air do have advantages. That's why the iPad or iPad Air makes perfect sense as productos different than a MacBook.

iPad Pro is something else. It is presented as an alternative to the laptop, and therefore with a keyboard. Some advantages you point out make sense if you don't use the iPad with a keyboard, or if you need a touch screen. A touch screen can be useful at times and useless at other times, and requires an adapted interface that also has its shortcomings. The iPad Pro is the one that will be displaced by the MacBook Neo and successors. The iPad Pro never made much sense. I bought one and it has been totally frustrating. A laptop is much more useful, comfortable and versatile.
 
Apple needs a rethink of their iPad strategy. There should be just two iPads.

iPad - The affordable content consumption device and sketchbook, similar to Job's original vision. Focused on single apps but allows multitasking like it worked previously on the iPad with Split View and slide over. A series chips. LCD display (laminated). £329 for the 8 inch 'mini' and £429 for the 11 inch. Folio style keyboard/trackpad can be added for £99.

iPad Pro - The iPad that can be a computer. Works just like the regular iPad but attach a keyboard/trackpad and the interface turns into macOS. M series chips. OLED display. £799 for the 11 inch at £999 for the 13 inch. Magic Keyboard can be added for £199.


That creates two very distinct product lines and a much more compelling offer that what Apple currently have imo

The iPad Pro product line, which has been a commercial failure despite Apple's efforts, is doomed when a much cheaper laptop is available than an iPad Pro + keyboard.
 
[I suppose that quote was sarcastic... but in case not, let me add a few things:]

Oh! My list is looooong!

* Multiple "window" support sucks.
The way iPad OS handles multitasking between several apps and windows is very unintuitive.
I always end up tapping the wrong widget or wrong edge and suddenly I'm in spilt screen, can't get rid of the second screen and whatnot.
If all I want is to make one application's UI (window) smaller, so that I can put it aside, but have it still visible onscreen so I can reference its data in another application that I want to have fullscreen to work on, that's troublesome on iPads.
On a personal computer this is very easy, just resize the first application window small while keeping the important parts visible, then shove that window to edge of the monitor, switch to another app and resize that window to a size that keeps the previous smaller window visible.
On the iPad it just feels tons more clumsy and complex to do the same simple task.

* Multitasking of apps sucks.
While the iPad offers picture-in-picture for e.g. YouTube videos, I find that the iPadOS interferes too often and ends up interrupting or stopping that background video. Because either the front app could also play video and therefore just stops any other picture-in-picture video task. Or a website has autoplay on, which forces your picture-in-picture to stop.
On a personal computer video in another window just keeps playing, even if the front app plays some other video. They can play both at the same time. On the iPad this is nearly impossible to do. Try having 3 browser tabs with videos playing all at the same time! Often not possible.
Sometimes I deliberately want this. E.g. playing some music in the background, while waiting for a streaming video to start while chatting with a friend on Google Meet to discuss the streaming video together. Easy on my Mac. Never managed to do that on my iPad...
Then other apps that I deliberately have running in the background on my iPad for notifications get auto-shut down by the iPadOS after e.g. a month of running. If I don't constantly bring these to the foreground to keep them alive, they just die on my and so do all its notifications... Ugh.

* Notification handling sucks.
While it is nice to have notifications like on a phone, they always interrupt, and when dismissed are gone who knows where, more often than not I am unable to get back to them, or they automatically decide to snooze and show up again some minutes later, with no control whether you want to snooze them or not. Often they do not show up in Notification Center or don't provide the control that one would want.
Somehow notifications seem to work much better in macOS.
Notifications on iPad feel clumsy to the point that I often switch as many of them off as I can - just to avoid having to deal with them.

* Manipulating data in several applications seems much easier on a personal computer.
The iPad's clunky "Files" system makes it hard to locate files and keep them organized. Often you open it up and it just shows a big video full-screen or some other file that you need to close first - while all I wanted was to see and locate some files. The "Files" application should not also be a viewer application, that should be handled separately.
On a Mac I can just keep all apps I intend to use together open and visible at the same time, in windows next to each other, where I can then easily save temp files on the desktop or use copy/paste to transfer the temp data into another application, and then on to the next application etc.
On the iPad I need to store it in Files which may not even be instantly available, having to close a few viewers first, not all apps support it properly, or when copy/pasting sometimes content ends up without styles, ugh... that kind of multi-app workflow just never worked for me on the iPad. It is seemingly a massive amount faster and easier on a Mac.

* Preferences and Settings are all over the place.
The way some settings are in an application's own preferences, others in the iPad Settings under the application name, and yet still others in some completely different location.
For example I always get confused as to where do I switch my Apple Music login ID? Why is it not in the same place as with Music on macOS? A lot of other iApps have similar chaos in regards to where which of their settings are...

* Have you ever tried switching users on an iPad?
Sure, Apple even says that i-Devices are not designed for multiple users. Fair enough. But then they geo-fence features or support them only in certain apps or OS versions that this simply requires users to create several Apple IDs to be able to do all the things that you can do on a personal computer easily...
So there will be situations where you need to switch your Apple ID. I have 4 by now...
Yet on an iPad this is a Royal Pain In The Arse! First you need to deactivate "Find My", then you need to delete all data, then worry about which to keep and later merge, wait for the iPad to do its thing, then log in with the other user, wait until all your stuff and settings change and are downloaded, while all your FaceTime and Messages sessions were force-logged out.
And then the whole thing in reverse, to go back to your main Apple ID. Ugh. No thanks.

* Intransparent settings.
Speaking of Apple IDs on i-Devices. My "Music" app on iPad has no user signed in, all web downloads, Siri settings, radio etc. are switched off. Still, every time I open "Music" it attempts to connect to some Apple servers and complains that no user is signed in. Why? Where can one switch this off? No idea. This is not transparent. Ugh.

* Seemingly enforced subscriptions everywhere.
Everything in iPadOS more and more becomes a "subscription" service. What if I don't want that?
People often end up paying for stuff they barely use or not even use at all. It's getting bad on Windows and macOS too, but it's really bad on iPadOS. Apple is pushing hard to make even many features of iPadOS a subscription exclusive.


I think I stop here. But I could go on for ages...
You hopefully get the picture.

iPadOS is just really clumsy to use and in my opinion totally unituitive and incoherent - at least when you compare it to most personal computer OSes.
The iPads M class chip is amazingly powerful, and could put many desktops to shame, but with iPadOS all that power goes to waste, I feel...
There are a few individual apps that certainly profit from the M class chips, but the way iPadOS, apps and data are handled and interact is just not worthy of all that power, I find.

It depends on your use cases, of course. So your milage will vary.
And I understand some people love iPadOS.
Me, I just can't stand it. Going back and forth between Windows, macOS and iPadOS, every time I use iPadOS I just feel like I'm put into a straight jacket... Nothing works quickly. Nothing works as one would expect. Everything feels clumsy, unintuitive and all over the place.

p.s.
With the iPad's CPU getting more and more powerful, Apple tried to find ways to make the iPad able to use that immense power. Fair enough.
But at the end of the day iPadOS is still derived from a phone operating system that was at its core designed for 3 1/2 inch multi-touch screens that could handle a few smart apps. The design language of that operating system was never intended for powerful features like multitasking applications.

When Apple moved iPadOS out of iOS, they had a chance to completely redesign it, to allow it to handle more powerful features.
Yet either Apple did not have the manpower to redesign iOS for iPad properly, or they lacked ideas how to even do this, or it was a political decision to keep iPadOS close to iOS in design - either way, in my opinion that transition from iOS to iPadOS failed completely.
All we got was iOS with a few "Frankenstein'd" features bolted on that just feel unintuitive, rather than getting a new powerful multi-touch OS that can support and handle powerful handheld hardware.

Does the iPad still not support two or more videos playing or two or more audio streams playing?
 
The iPad Pro product line, which has been a commercial failure despite Apple's efforts, is doomed when a much cheaper laptop is available than an iPad Pro + keyboard.
For Apple this means less revenue and not much business sense, so they will most likely make changes to avoid cannibalisation like further gimping the Neo and increasing its price and giving the next iPP more exclusive features, possibly even giving it Mac OS etc. They want you to spend more money on the iPP and App Store, not buy the Neo with lower profit margins and No App Store sales.
 
The iPad Pro just doesn't offer great value for what you pay. Yes, the screen is wonderful, probably the best of any Apple product right now, but that's where it ends. They need something to really differentiate it especially at the price point. If it was MacOS capable when docked it would be an instant buy for me, even at a higher price point.

So why have the iPad Pro? If the OS is way too limiting just have base iPad and iPad Air. And discontinue the iPad Pro.

I assume pros are doing sound and video editing will just get Mac and none pros people doing social media, internet surfing, playing gaming, reading and writing or drawing aka consumption device where iPadOS shine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rosuna and Dreamail
Does the iPad still not support two or more videos playing or two or more audio streams playing?
Not on my iPad Pro M1. Not regularly.
It's hit or miss. At times I can get it to work, via picture-in-picture plus a separate web tab with a second video running. But then suddenly one of the two would stop for no apparent reason. Why? Who knows... iPadOS is just too iffy, I think. More of a "toyOS" than a real OS.
 
Not on my iPad Pro M1. Not regularly.
It's hit or miss. At times I can get it to work, via picture-in-picture plus a separate web tab with a second video running. But then suddenly one of the two would stop for no apparent reason. Why? Who knows... iPadOS is just too iffy, I think. More of a "toyOS" than a real OS.

That odd do Android tablets do this as well?

I guess iPadOS roots came from iOS. Where Steve Job thought people where be using it for reading iBooks, email, internet, games and to do lists, note taking and people into video editing or sound editing or MS office will be using laptop so called pro.
 
iPadOS is just really clumsy to use and in my opinion totally unituitive and incoherent - at least when you compare it to most personal computer OSes.
The iPads M class chip is amazingly powerful, and could put many desktops to shame, but with iPadOS all that power goes to waste, I feel...
There are a few individual apps that certainly profit from the M class chips, but the way iPadOS, apps and data are handled and interact is just not worthy of all that power, I find.

Linux and Windows was built for many user login using the device where iPadOS not. Only for one user.

I think with more RAM now and storage Apple could do it now where before with only 2 GB of RAM or less and only 32 GB of storage or 64 GB of storage where be really limiting.

So Apple could do this with iPad Pros now.

The businesses sector will take iPad more seriously if had different user profiles and system addim accounts and user accounts.
 
* Have you ever tried switching users on an iPad?
Sure, Apple even says that i-Devices are not designed for multiple users. Fair enough. But then they geo-fence features or support them only in certain apps or OS versions that this simply requires users to create several Apple IDs to be able to do all the things that you can do on a personal computer easily...
So there will be situations where you need to switch your Apple ID. I have 4 by now...
Yet on an iPad this is a Royal Pain In The Arse! First you need to deactivate "Find My", then you need to delete all data, then worry about which to keep and later merge, wait for the iPad to do its thing, then log in with the other user, wait until all your stuff and settings change and are downloaded, while all your FaceTime and Messages sessions were force-logged out.
And then the whole thing in reverse, to go back to your main Apple ID. Ugh. No thanks.

Apple wants you to delete your Apple ID and do factory reset when giving iPad to other using not going in each app and deleting files.
 
* Multiple "window" support sucks.
The way iPad OS handles multitasking between several apps and windows is very unintuitive.
I always end up tapping the wrong widget or wrong edge and suddenly I'm in spilt screen, can't get rid of the second screen and whatnot.
If all I want is to make one application's UI (window) smaller, so that I can put it aside, but have it still visible onscreen so I can reference its data in another application that I want to have fullscreen to work on, that's troublesome on iPads.
On a personal computer this is very easy, just resize the first application window small while keeping the important parts visible, then shove that window to edge of the monitor, switch to another app and resize that window to a size that keeps the previous smaller window visible.
On the iPad it just feels tons more clumsy and complex to do the same simple task.

I thought Apple got multitasking right in version 18 and nuked it with version 26 being more complex now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dirk Pieters
I wanted a pro for the longest time due to the 13" size, but could never justify the crazy price for the additional features I had no use for. When the Air 13" came out, I got that and I'm very happy with the purchase.

Apple has turn into really expensive now under Tim Cook where under Steve Jobs things where more affordable.
 
Bro I don’t agree with you :

- Base iPad is for brokies
- iPad mini is for kids
- iPad Air is for normal people
- iPad Pro is for rich

(ok this might not be exact but it gives an idea, more you pay, more you get)
The runway for iPad Pro is nearing its end. Consider that iPad Air is artificially limited to not have quad speakers and ProMotion is telling enough.

I understand that the entry level iPad and mini have two speakers but the Air seems to be artificially ham stringed to substantiate the Pro apart from FaceID and Thunderbolt USB-C. When the Pro is thinner than the Air one has to wonder.
 
iPadOS is inferior to MacOS in multiple ways.

You may what complain in this thread about why iPadOS sucks and why Mac OS is better or what features iPadOS needs to make it more pro.


With iPadOS 27, I would like to see…​

 
I was comparing the iPad Pro with the MacBook, not the iPad or the iPad Air. For casual multimedia consumption, long-form reading and light use (while standing or moving) the iPad and iPad Air do have advantages. That's why the iPad or iPad Air makes perfect sense as productos different than a MacBook.

iPad Pro is something else. It is presented as an alternative to the laptop, and therefore with a keyboard. Some advantages you point out make sense if you don't use the iPad with a keyboard, or if you need a touch screen. A touch screen can be useful at times and useless at other times, and requires an adapted interface that also has its shortcomings. The iPad Pro is the one that will be displaced by the MacBook Neo and successors. The iPad Pro never made much sense. I bought one and it has been totally frustrating. A laptop is much more useful, comfortable and versatile.
The iPad Pro has the best display out of all of Apple’s products. It’s not going anywhere. Also, the iPad Pro is a better jack of all trades than the Neo is
 
  • Like
Reactions: snipr125
I owned an M4 iPad Pro that I bought at Apple's MSRP, along with the Magic Keyboard. It is, by far, the worst value Apple product I have ever bought, and one of the worst value products Apple has ever released.

  • They offer almost no functionality improvement over the iPad Airs
  • The keyboard is way too expensive - the removal of the Smart Folio Keyboard was a serious mistake
  • The iPad Airs are always on sale from Amazon, making the price differential worse. iPad Pros are not on sale as much
  • Macbooks have gotten cheaper, often on sale, to the point where direct comparisons look increasingly unflattering
 
The iPad Pro product line, which has been a commercial failure despite Apple's efforts, is doomed when a much cheaper laptop is available than an iPad Pro + keyboard.

I'm not so sure. With a keyboard the pricing I'd identified there would get you an 11" iPad for less than a MacBook Air, and just a bit more if you went for the 13inch. And you get an OLED screen and pen input.

I think the answer to the Pro line is to put macOS on them basically and that is effectively a new category of device which gives iPad Pro some purpose, not for everyone but it is offering something different for those that want a super flexible set up.

Currently they are charging £999 for an 11" iPad Pro, Magic Keyboard for £299 😁, and you can't do anything different on it than your base iPad. I mean seriously who is buying this?
 
I'm not so sure. With a keyboard the pricing I'd identified there would get you an 11" iPad for less than a MacBook Air, and just a bit more if you went for the 13inch. And you get an OLED screen and pen input.

I think the answer to the Pro line is to put macOS on them basically and that is effectively a new category of device which gives iPad Pro some purpose, not for everyone but it is offering something different for those that want a super flexible set up.

Currently they are charging £999 for an 11" iPad Pro, Magic Keyboard for £299 😁, and you can't do anything different on it than your base iPad. I mean seriously who is buying this?
I bought it for the Tandem OLED and M5 chip
 
  • Like
Reactions: snipr125
Thanks to iPadOS26, properly slimmed down iPad line up should be the following:

A-series
Base iPad
iPad mini

M-series
11" iPad Air
13" iPad Pro
A future larger screen or foldable iPad

iPadOS26 doesn't really work on screens smaller than 11", and it barely works on the 11" Air/Pro with some serious fiddliness. Maybe that can straighten itself out in 27. For now, the 13" is the best screen size and form factor for the multi-windowed version of iPadOS. The others are meant for single full-screen app use or Slideover if it comes back. This is a good opportunity to streamline the SKUs.
 
I bought it for the Tandem OLED and M5 chip
Yes and not just that, its the quality of life features, face id, cellular support, the pencil etc. The display though is incredible, best screen in the industry right now nothing can compare to it.
 
I wonder if sales and demand of the iPad Pro would increase if they released another folio keyboard. I never understood why they removed it from the product line. The Smart Keyboard is nice in its own lane, but it adds weight, thickness, and bulk. How nice would it be to have protection and utility of the keyboard while keeping it thin and light like the keyboard Folio from M1?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Adelphos33
I wonder if sales and demand of the iPad Pro would increase if they released another folio keyboard. I never understood why they removed it from the product line. The Smart Keyboard is nice in its own lane, but it adds weight, thickness, and bulk. How nice would it be to have protection and utility of the keyboard while keeping it thin and light like the keyboard Folio from M1?

What is wrong with new keyboard for iPad?
 
  • Like
Reactions: DougFNJ
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.