Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I had it in my right earpiece, and then Apple screwed up the shipment to me and closed the issue. After escalating I got a new earpiece and didn’t have to return the old one.
 
There was a time when a person could buy a pair of high end headphones and use them "forever". It seems that everything Apple makes requires endless bug fixes, factory recalls or becomes obsolete in 5 years
Less than 5 years with these non-replaceable-battery headphones. Once that battery is dead, it's dead.
 
I bought mine exactly one year ago so they were still under warranty, but I just did a chat with Apple support and a new pair is on the way to me. Whole process was only perhaps 15 minutes.

(I should have dealt with them long ago when I first noticed NC was way worse, but only just got around to it last night as they were nearing one year old - and coincidentally they just started up this replacement program at exactly the same time. So you can all thank me.)
 
Apple should have allowed mailing it back rather than having people come to their store during a pandemic and wait in lines or risk getting Covid-19.
You can do mail-in service... they overnight the replacements, but they put a hold on your card until you send back the faulty ones. Once they’ve received the faulty ones, they will remove the hold after determining if the swap is covered or not. You don’t even have to get on the phone with anyone. You can do it all through support chat.
 
Less than 5 years with these non-replaceable-battery headphones. Once that battery is dead, it's dead.
I made that realization after my first gen lasted barely over 2 years. I almost didn’t get the Pros, but I figured with the AppleCare this time around, I could replace them right before 2 years and make that set last another 2 years. Now that I’ve gotten both replaced after a year because of this issue, I’m not sure if that plan will hold up as well. I guess I might still be able to get the case replaced if the battery is beaten, which I’m sure it will be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sideshowuniqueuser
I didn't include the tips, they just want the airpod itself.
Wait, they included the other sizes? I didn’t see any others in any of the three replacement boxes I received or else I would have assumed to keep them. I didn’t want the medium ones since I use the small ones so I sent them back.
 
And they didn’t subtract that from the rebate amount on the credit card hold?

I didn’t think they’d want the tips, but the drawings include them, so I wasn’t sure whether not including them would cause Apple to charge me a few bucks.
I just did the return thing and the person told me specifically not to include the tips. So there shouldn't be any charge.
 
I think I have ANC issue since a long time but how can I gauge that? I know that using some Bose in the past the sound was completely clean and no background whatsoever . With the AirPods I can hear background, soft but I can hear it. Is this correct?
 
I literally just called Apple about an hour ago about this issue and they told me they couldn't find any related issues related to the crackling noise. Lol
Hah. They replaced mine back in late August for this issue. What’s funny is they replaced the wrong one and then sent me the other so I got a new set. Hopefully these are fixed enough.
 
I literally just called Apple about an hour ago about this issue and they told me they couldn't find any related issues related to the crackling noise. Lol
I had each replaced under warranty because I two different issues, left had a clicking sound when there was motion or if I touched it when ANC is turned on. (Loose internal mike?) When I got the replacement, I noticed the whistle sound when I touched the other old one does not occur with the replacement. I had the other one replaced at the Apple Store and decided to get Applecare due to my problems To be safe. Now both was before Oct., so they will be replaced even without AppleCare if it occurs again.

If you have a problem, describe it and it would be replaced regardless of this service program if it is still under warranty. If you don’t have this problem yet, you will be covered when it occurs in the future. You can‘t get replaced just because of this program. Just remember if you hear a irritating sound with motion or touching it clicking or squeal, then you have problem.
 
I think I have ANC issue since a long time but how can I gauge that? I know that using some Bose in the past the sound was completely clean and no background whatsoever . With the AirPods I can hear background, soft but I can hear it. Is this correct?
That is normal, the ANC issue I had, I believe, is a loose or bad mic. One, I believe was loose, had a clicking sound from it moving inside. If I turn ANC or Ambient off, which no longer uses the mic, the noise went away. I also had a squealing sound when applying pressure near the mic which the other one was replaced, at a different time.
 
I only had the issue in my left but I had them replace both. Didn’t want one old one and one new one.
Originally, I only had one replaced, my son said there was one advantage of having one replaced. The battery life was slightly shorter on one. It would die slightly sooner than the newer one. This comes handy when on a call, he takes the dead one and charges it while still on the call with the other, then swap it, I rather have both new. But since they wouldn’t replace both for him, he sees a strange but useful advantage.
 
I had this. It was as if there was a loose wire in the device. If you moved it would cause static. Eventually it got bad enough that if I spoke then it caused static. If I was perfectly still and just listening it was OK.

After I replaced the left one I realized the right side also had a problem. Not quite so bad. If I walked while using these then the right side would produce a sort of "thump" or "thud" with each step. Contacted Apple and they also replaced this one free of charge. I bought them in the fall of 2019.

Interestingly enough, I went to the Apple store to get the second one replaced. The tech used a lightning cable to connect the charging case to his laptop and ran some sort of diagnostics that told him it needed replacement.
Both the left and right side had the thumping/rumbling noise for me. Happened whenever when I moved my head around, was very annoying. On my third set right now and it's starting to come back again. I hope Apple has somehow finally fixed this in a new hardware revision or something.
 
That is normal, the ANC issue I had, I believe, is a loose or bad mic. One, I believe was loose, had a clicking sound from it moving inside. If I turn ANC or Ambient off, which no longer uses the mic, the noise went away. I also had a squealing sound when applying pressure near the mic which the other one was replaced, at a different time.
Thanks for explaining it.
 
Must be a new hardware version? I will be making use of this for sure. It was something that seemed to get worse.
 
I’ve not been able to achieve Earfit for a while, even with the largest tips, and the noise cancellation is practically non-existent. I’m assuming I have this issue and yesterday managed to arrange a Genius Bar appointment today at Newcastle’s Eldon Square store (well timed with a new lockdown coming).
 
And they didn’t subtract that from the rebate amount on the credit card hold?

I didn’t think they’d want the tips, but the drawings include them, so I wasn’t sure whether not including them would cause Apple to charge me a few bucks.

When you return the AirPods, they don’t want the rubberized Tips. They’re going to dispose of them anyway, because of the sanitary precautions that they can’t reuse them. Believe me, Apple strictly wants the AirPods. It’s no different when you send the Apple Watch in for repair/replacement, they don’t want the watchband, they want just the watch itself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OddyOh
I literally just called Apple about an hour ago about this issue and they told me they couldn't find any related issues related to the crackling noise. Lol
But this is amazing! My right earpod have begun making distracting and fairly loud clicking sounds when in ANC/transparent mode when I walk around or eat fx. Super annoying. Can’t even use my left because I am hearing impaired.
 
are they charging you $197 for the diy placeholder charge on your card for just the two airpods via the diy service?
 
Thank God. I've had to get my left APP replaced 3 times because of this issue, and my most recent replacement is acting up now too. I bought AppleCare because I knew this was gonna be an issue beyond the 1 year warranty period. Sucks because I love these headphones otherwise.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OddyOh
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.