First off thank you for a measured and reasonable response, things got messy in here for a while.
That's assuming several factors, not least of which is if the charges were valid as that data shows arrests, not convictions. Leading further to serial targeting of individuals to make things stick. We all know there are corrupt cops and there are many instances where individuals who cannot afford proper representation on bogus crimes lead to lesser ones they still didn't do out of fear (and mistrust) that the system will still convict them unjustly, as many have had before.
I acknowledge the numbers represent arrests vs convictions and therefore they could skew a bit so in the interest of a "what if", lets cut the arrest numbers in half and assume those would be the convictions, I don't think the numbers would be anywhere near cut in half but again this is a what if scenario:
Black Americans @12% of the population but 23% of deaths at the hands of law enforcement is 2x the population percentage:
Murder and nonnegligent manslaughter reduced from 53.1% to 26.5%, still over 2x the population percentage
Rape reduced from 28.7% to 14.3%, comes in line with population percentage
Robbery reduced from 54.3% to 27.1%, still over 2x the population percentage
etc down the list.
The point here is even at 50% of the arrest rate these increased negative interactions with law enforcement could just as easily account for the disproportionate number of deaths as supposed systematic racism as they are both about double the population percentage. I am not claiming racism doesn't exist, it exists on all sides of all races and shades of color but race is not always the cause of death at the hands of law enforcement. Statistics don't lie, statistics are not racist.
I highly doubt that the four officers would have been charged had there been no protest. Breonna Taylor's 8 killers have still not been charged and it has been almost three months since she was murdered in her home by police.
I was not familiar with the details of Breonna Taylor's death so I read the following:
The 26-year-old was shot and killed by Louisville police in March following what her family calls a "botched" raid at her home.
www.nbcnews.com
What I get from reading this one summary is that this case is no where near as clear as the George Floyd case where we have serveral pieces of video evidence. Based on what I read this case needs and deserves a thorough investigation and unfortunately that takes time.
3 Officers serving a warrant
Did they knock and announce even though they had a no-knock warrant? The family says no but were they there?
If they knocked and announced then as tragic as this is, since both had no records, once fired upon law enforcement would indeed fire back. Impossible to hold the officers to a murder charge under these circumstances as they were acting in accordance with law.
If they did NOT knock and announce, as the warrant permitted, then IMHO this is a massive failure of law enforment procedure. First off no one should have their home forcably entered and not have the right to defend themselves, hence a no-knock warrant is highly problematic and should be illegal IMHO. Breonna Taylor should not be dead and Kenneth Walker should not be under arrest. That being said, can you hold the officers to a murder charge if they were following a lawful no-knock warrant, I think this will be difficult if not impossible, the laws regarding no-knock warrants needs to be changed.
I don't think race had anything to do with this, sounds like law enforcement procedure. I read only the above article, if I am missing updated information I apologize.
You miss the point completely — systemic change doesn't start on the bottom rung but though change at the top and clear messages sent down. PD's all over the nation are littered with well-intentioned rookie cops who quickly find out that they cannot affect department-wide change and that making their bones usually means showing you won't rat out your fellow cop. The ones that got elected to create change have been long demanding it — and have gotten pepper-sprayed for their stance.
I have to disagree here, change can and must come from within and from the base! Mandated change may work eventually but is usually met with fierce resistance. My post was meant to challenge people who feel underrepresented to assume positions of "power" in their communities, such as law enforcement or public office. When enough well intentioned rookie cops come into the system they can enact change.
I believe that racism gets the blame for far more than it deserves when it comes to law enforcement because from some of the numbers I have seen segments of the population can be underrepresented in law enforcement, not based on their national percentage of the population, but based on thier local population.
Ex: City X might have a 50% African American Population but if their representation in law enforcement is only at the 12% national level then that particular community could feel a racial bias that isn't there simply because the majority of law enforcement is white / other. Would they feel the same if 50% or greater of the local law enforcement was African American?