Toggle sidebar Toggle sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Apple Music to Label AI-Generated Songs

bread6000 said:
Like I said, I am only defending people in music who uses AI technology as a tool, not ones to mass produced songs with text and make up fake artists.
Click to expand...
I don't care if someone uses AI as a tool to help them polish up and make the finishing touches to a song they already crafted to the best of their skills, I care if someone lets the AI take the wheel for the entire song.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eifelbube
bread6000 said:
Ok I am done. "Normal technology"? There is no such thing as "Normal technology". It's just technology that adavances aka advance technology.
Click to expand...
Right...
1787421285100.png

Explain this, then. Is this "Advanced" to you? No? Then what happened to the whole "Advanced technology" only thing? Oh, still arguing? Are the iPods that I have "Advanced" at all? Still no? EXACTLY.
 
turbineseaplane said:
All Apple is doing is LABELING the usage of AI.
Nothing is being removed. No toggles are being offered to exclude AI music (which is a toggle many of us want).

The only reason to be against labeling is a desire to trick people into listening to AI music.

The service should cater to the paying customers and it's in their interest to know what they are listening to, how it was made, who made it, when it was made, etc.

Don't like having your songs labeled as using AI?
Don't use AI 😉 😀

We are entering an era where many of us will place higher value on fully human created works.
There's an opportunity there actually!
Click to expand...
How about you guys stop acting like crybabies because someone uses AI as a tool. Also you still missed my point because you don't care.

Also you are not entering a era, only people like you think that.
 
Last edited:
bread6000 said:
That was advanced technology for it's time. What's so hard for you to understand?
Click to expand...
But now that almost all pieces of technology are all balanced, what is "Advanced" anymore? I don't see an obvious difference between laptops and phones. They all behave the same way.

P.S, The A1278's were all copy/pastes for its time, just as a heads up. 😉
 
OldNewMBP said:
I don't care if someone uses AI as a tool to help them polish up and make the finishing touches to a song they already crafted to the best of their skills, I care if someone lets the AI take the wheel for the entire song.
Click to expand...

OldNewMBP said:
But now that almost all pieces of technology are all balanced, what is "Advanced" anymore? I don't see an obvious difference between laptops and phones. They all behave the same way.
Click to expand...
So you just don't like AI technology, right? Just say that and stop wasting my time, because why do you care how someone OWN SONGS are put together? It's weird.
 
bread6000 said:
So you just don't like AI technology, right? Just say that and stop wasting my time, because why do you care how someone OWN SONGS are put together? It's weird.
Click to expand...
Incorrect. I don't mind using AI, but I also don't care about AI itself. As long as it HELPS me with a task, then it is useful, not REPLACING me entirely with a certain task. I am somewhat in the middle of "Loving AI" and "Hating AI". I am pretty neutral with AI.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eifelbube
OldNewMBP said:
Incorrect. I don't mind using AI, but I also don't care about AI itself. As long as it HELPS me with a task, then it is useful, not REPLACING me entirely with a certain task. I am somewhat in the middle of "Loving AI" and "Hating AI". I am pretty neutral with AI.
Click to expand...
If you written your own songs, Al is not replacing it. Replacing it to me is when it doesn't sound nothing like you written it (Music and Lyrics).

Also you should not had told me that you don't mind using AI because if you do just to help you with a task, they will view it as still trash. That attitude is why I started debating on here in the first place.
 
bread6000 said:
If you written your own songs, Al is not replacing it. Replacing it to me is when it doesn't sound nothing like you written it (Music and Lyrics).
Click to expand...
EXACTLY WHAT I AM TRYING TO SAY HERE, @bread6000! I am trying to say that you may use AI to fine-tune your song, not full on rewrite it and replace it! You STILL do NOT get what I am saying; I think that you are ignoring the purpose of what I am trying to say, and focusing on what I am saying means to you and yourself only!
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: eifelbube and turbineseaplane
bread6000 said:
Just like you can close the browser.

In fact, you could had not posted a comment on here if you didn't want someone like me to debate you.
Click to expand...
You aren't debating anything though. You are just making nonsense comments that really make no sense, not defining your terms when talking about how AI is "improving" the music someone already created, and then insulting people who think differently from you.

All this in the only thread you have seemingly ever opened on this site.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: eifelbube, OldNewMBP and turbineseaplane
bread6000 said:
Just like you can close the browser.

In fact, you could had not posted a comment on here if you didn't want someone like me to debate you.
Click to expand...

You said your time was being wasted. 👇 (in bold, emphasis mine)

bread6000 said:
So you just don't like AI technology, right? Just say that and stop wasting my time, because why do you care how someone OWN SONGS are put together? It's weird.
Click to expand...


Just trying to help you.
🫶
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: eifelbube and OldNewMBP
OldNewMBP said:
EXACTLY WHAT I AM TRYING TO SAY HERE, @bread6000! I am trying to say that you may use AI to fine-tune your song, not full on rewrite it and replace it! You STILL do NOT get what I am saying; I think that you are ignoring the purpose of what I am trying to say, and focusing on what I am saying means to you and yourself only!
Click to expand...
AI can not rewrite your song unless you act it to. Other than that it is going to sound like you written it
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back