I'm ok with a few rough edges with a brand new app, but this app is awful.
- Freezes constantly while searching for podcasts in the "store"
- Podcast artwork showing up is random
- Crashes, stops playback randomly
- sorting from oldest to newest within podcasts shows every podcast ever, sometimes hundreds of episodes to scroll through, even if you haven't downloaded them, and are considered "played"
- No streaming
- 30 sec jumps only availble if you open the app (other apps use the next/previous buttons so you can skip back or forward without opening the app)
- Played episodes keep getting marked back to unplayed
- Episodes don't seem to delete even if you delete them
- automatically downloading new episodes doesn't seem to work
- unplayed podcast list doesn't let you sort oldest to newest. It's always newest to oldest.
- And my favorite: after the "subscribe button" is loaded in, it sometimes disappears, making it impossible to subscribe.
- App is sloooooooooooooooooooooooooooow
Pretty much unusable. I'm kind of surprised Apple would allow this thing to be released in the state it is in.
After experiencing many of the issues and feature shortcomings quoted above, as of today my Podcasts app crashes every time I try to use it. It starts to load and then crashes after a few seconds before displaying the list of podcasts. Force-quitting the app or restarting the phone don't help.
And since podcast states don't sync between the Music app and the Podcasts app, I now have a good 20 or 30 podcast episodes that I've already listened to over the past week that are still marked as new and unread in the Music app. So I'm going to have to try to figure out which ones I did actually listen to and which ones I haven't yet.
AND when I click from the Music app to try to search for new podcast episodes, it tries to load the Podcasts app (I can tell because it shows the Podcast black and grey background in lieu of the Music Store background). This then of course proceeds to crash. I had to go into the iTunes Store, search for the podcast, and manually download it from there (that, at least, works).
I have no desire to re-download the app to see if that would solve the issues. I'm willing to switch back to using the Music app and leave bad enough alone until this app is ready to hit primetime.
For those saying this is the first version of a new app and we should cut Apple some slack, one could perhaps generously call this a beta release. Let's hope Apple did this to work out the kinks before iOS 6 comes out, although they should have at the very least given a list of "known issues" or something in the description. If Apple doesn't consider Podcasts a beta release, at least internally without admitting it publicly, then I am seriously afraid of what sorts of issues the public release of iOS 6 is going to come with initially.
(PS Added to the list above of issues, for me at least, is while the Podcasts app was still working, my iPhone getting confused when I double-clicked the home button to resume the music or podcast I was listening to. For example, it would display on the lock screen the last music track I listened to, but then when I hit play it would play the last podcast I listened to instead.)