Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Many complex things than can be done on a PC cannot be done on an iPad.

And few people do them, outside of tech forums.

But you could say the same of laptops: “many” complex things cannot be done on a slow, tiny Linux netbook. Is it not a PC, then?
 
These kind of topics really show who is on the leading edge with their thinking and who still wants to hang to the old terms and way of categorizing things.

^^This^^ Someone understanding the larger picture.
 
And few people do them, outside of tech forums.

But you could say the same of laptops: “many” complex things cannot be done on a slow, tiny Linux netbook. Is it not a PC, then?

It's not a workstation, but most PC stuff can be done, albeit slowly.

On the iPad there are many essential things that you just can't.
 
Maybe a Windows 8 tablet will be a PC once you attach a keyboard to it, but an iPad is not.
 
Many complex things than can be done on a PC cannot be done on an iPad.

Yes. So?

Many complex things can be done on a PC made in 2011 which couldn't be done on a PC made in 1990. Does that mean the PC made in 1990 is not a PC? This is clearly an argument with no logical conclusion.

We define something by what we do with it. It's basic logic.

All homes are things we live in.
I live in my flat.
My flat is a home.

So...

All PCs are machines used for personal computing tasks.
The iPad is a machine used for personal computing tasks.
Therefore the iPad is a PC.

The argument is only about what a personal computing task is and, frankly, that's just clutching at straws. An iPad is used for the vast majority of the same things any other form of PC is used for.
 
When was a terminal or thin client considered a PC?

When employees could use them to play minesweeper or solitaire when the office network was down, same as they can do with iPads now.

In fact, with a 3G iPad, they can do their farming on Facebook even if the office net has crashed.
 
As much as I liked my iPad, I certainly do not class it as a computer. The tablet market should be classed as something separate in my mind.

if you brought an iPad back to the 1980s Mac users, would they have considered it a computer? i think Yes, since it does more than they did. if so, then why would it not be a computer today? does not compute.
 
Yes. So?

Many complex things can be done on a PC made in 2011 which couldn't be done on a PC made in 1990. Does that mean the PC made in 1990 is not a PC? This is clearly an argument with no logical conclusion.

We define something by what we do with it. It's basic logic.

All homes are things we live in.
I live in my flat.
My flat is a home.

So...

All PCs are machines used for personal computing tasks.
The iPad is a machine used for personal computing tasks.
Therefore the iPad is a PC.

The argument is only about what a personal computing task is and, frankly, that's just clutching at straws. An iPad is used for the vast majority of the same things any other form of PC is used for.

So a 2011 game console is a PC because it can run heavier games than an eighties PC?
 
so the ipod touch is a computer too?

can you hook up an external monitor, keyboard and perform common computing tasks such as word processing, spreadsheets, image editing, email, scheduling, web browsing, and running any number of applications? yes, yes, and yes.
 
A digital watch is a (generally nonprogrammable) computer, like many other little things.
 
I know I will be flame for this but I think its time for some other tech company to come up with new OS and hardware configuration like Apple did years ago. Apple loosing grip with all inventions; there is so many glitches, problems which I have never seen before. The same with hardware; my iMac's seen Apple store guru many times as the same for MBA and iPhone. The quality is still there but its degrading year by year.
Honestly I will be very happy to see some competition at this level. I just feel the need to swap over but there is nothing out there at this moment.
Just my $0.02
 
can you hook up an external monitor, keyboard and perform common computing tasks such as word processing, spreadsheets, image editing, email, scheduling, web browsing, and running any number of applications? yes, yes, and yes.

Can you develop on it or do some other complex tasks? Can you run a VM? No.
 
Since when can you use an iPad as a development workstation?

What code a Developer can port and run on an iPad and what Apple allows in its App store are two completely different things.

(I enrolled as an iOS Developer, so there's lots of stuff on my iPad that's not on yours. :)
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; CPU iPhone OS 5_0_1 like Mac OS X) AppleWebKit/534.46 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.1 Mobile/9A405 Safari/7534.48.3)

Yes, you can develop on it.
 
What code a Developer can port and run on an iPad and what Apple allows in its App store are two completely different things.

(I enrolled as an iOS Developer, so there's lots of stuff on my iPad that's not on yours. :)

Can you develop Java and .NET? You can do that on PCs.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.