my two pence worth
kitki83 said:
great just when I was about to settle for Mac Pro now this comes out.
I need macs experts give me their opinion,
For up and coming college grad who works in Graphic design.
Damm everyone I know tells me to stick with Mac Pro what sucks I already got my nice 17 wide screen lcd for my mac pro
Anyway
Post pics of those new imac being opened
I think the 24 inch iMac is the perfect 2D graphics workstation. Save the money on the separate monitor and the cost of the extra machine. If you are going to be doing 3D stuff or film work then go Pro for the disk space and the dual/quad ness.
If you're going to be running Quark and CS2 (3) then you really do not need the Pro, trust me. We've always had a pro tower model in our office and when the iMac G4 angelpoise came out we got it as a third machine for the office, partly the form factor, partly the 20 inch flat screen. Once the tower's ended their lease I found myself using the iMac G4 more and more and the only major problem with it in terms of performance has been the lack of ability to add more RAM. But it whizzes through most tasks. For putting together large images for display work in Photoshop it's fine (sure you probably don't won't a load of other applications open simultaneously).
We've almost certainly going to buy the 24 inch iMac, A4 magazine spreads side by side at true size, perfect. We're never going to have the spare cash for the 30 inch screens! And we'll max out the RAM (obviously not from Apple). You've got 500 HD, 800 Firewire (for the external drives that will be useful with the Time Machine stuff), the wireless stuff built in.
I can't state this enough, it is EXTRAORDINARILY good value. These ARE the mid/high end machines that people are clamoring to fill a supposed 'gap'. Make no mistake these are not "consumer" machines, they're for Pros. What consumers really need 24 inches?
Look at your budget carefully (if necessary sell the 17 inch display on ebay) for $2634 you get the fully specced 24 inch iMac (plus RAM to buy elsewhere) as opposed to $3837 for the versatility of the Mac Pro, an extra processor and a lesser video card, as well as 1 inch less of screen!
I thought the same when the iMac G5's were coming out. And I know plenty of graphics professionals that are using them (they've held off the intel ones 'cos of CS2) very happily. With the extra processing power which will compensate you for the CS2/Rosetta issues until next spring, you'll be fine.
Part of the reason the iMac's don't appear to be professional is in the marketing. Apple doesn't really want the graphics professionals to be buying the iMac as opposed to the Pro Towers (all marketed in serious grey and black dark heavy important) rather than the fluffier marketing of the iMacs. But don't be fooled. As I said above unless you really are doing a lot of 3D work, and high-end movie compositing, the iMac 24 will do you just fine.
Oh and you can upgrade the graphics card!
We've ordered ours.