macrumors12345 said:
Whatever. You just want Apple to sell you a Powerbook at a $200 loss. I'm going to use the Student Union discount to buy the new iBook for an effective price of $800. I'd like to see you find an $800 PC laptop that has even 70% of these features, all of which I appreciate:
(1) sub 5 lbs
(2) scrolling trackpad
(3) built in Bluetooth
(4) sudden motion sensor
(5) DX9 capable video card (*not* a shared memory solution!)
(6) slot loading drive
The only thing that is clearly sub-par about the iBook is the processor (more precisely, the front side bus), which Apple can do very little about. Motorola decides what they do and do not want to offer in the G4, and the only thing Apple can do if they don't like is something really extreme like switching to Intel. Oh, wait, that's what they're doing...
I'm going to soup mine up with a 1 GB DIMM (3rd party, of course) and put in a 60 GB 5400 rpm drive (CompUSA will do the install for only 30 bucks!). That will be a very nice laptop for the next year until the Macintel 'books come out. And when they do come out, I guarantee you I will still be able to resell my iBook for only one to two hundred dollars less than I bought it for (whereas if I wasted my money on a PC notebook, it could easily depreciate by 40-50% in the same timeframe).
I'd have to disagree with you...
The Dell 700m is approx $800 (Dell posts a 750 off 1499 coupon every two weeks, my friend bought one like that) and it has:
+12.1 1280x800 widescreen that destroys the low res AND low quality 12" lcd on the pb and ib
I compared them side by side at the store, and the apple LCD is weak. If you view it at more than 45 deg angle, it looks like crap, all other pc laptops at compusa had screens with WAAAY better viewing angles, and the ibook compared to the 20" imac next to it showed how crappy that screen was. A screen, including its brightness, viewing angle and resolution is part of the user experience as much as maybe the OS is, and all apples are way outdated in this regard. Hell even the 17" 1440x900 pbook i used at the school computer labs wasnt enough, i felt cramped, because at the time i had a dell with 15.4" 1680x1050 (not anymore, as I'm looking to buy a new laptop, and I so desparately want apple, but i don't pay for crappy processors or LCD screens, which are common across Apple's laptop line)
So let's recap, for $800 you can get a 700m with:
+ 12.1 Widescreen, way better than the 12" ibook or powerbook
+ Pentium M 1.8 GHZ which again destroys any G4, ever...
+ A DVD burner you can't even get in a 12" ibook
+ Better battery life
+ 512 mb of way faster memory, and system bus...
+ 4.1 lbs
+ SD card reader, which is actually very useful with a digital camera
- Integrated graphics (curiously fast enough to play games like nfs underground)
- No Bluetooth
- Cheaper design, but still nice, and way better than dells of a year ago, i'd be perfectly happy with it
- Windows (this is the deal breaker for me and why i'm not buying it right now)
The shock sensor and scrolling trackpad are just gimmicks imo, not that important to warrant mention.
So the moral of the story is: the screen is the dealbreaker for any apple laptop, and windows is the deal breaker for me for any non-apple laptop, I guess I won't be buying a computer until next year, then intel should take care of the "crappy CPU" problem, and I hope apple switches to the same LCD suppliers other PC vendors are using.