Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Anybody know a way to have have this without paying the 100/y fee to be a developer???

Its actually one of the features I've been most excited, to have my photos on iPhone and mac synced together.

You can join the free public beta program.
 
Looks interesting. Has a lot of potential doing forward . Hopefully Apple gives us the capability
 
My first impressions are positive. I like the clean interface and its responsiveness.
My only issues are:
  • There are no ratings anymore. They have been converted to tags. You can mark a picture as a favorite though.
  • There is no way to tell which pictures have been uploaded to the cloud and which are still pending.
 
I tried 10.10.3 on two MBpros. After hearing about browser speed improvements in all the updates I am finally seeing it. Chrome and Safari have both been doggy and jerky. So far they seem faster on this beta.

MBP 2.5 Ghz, 16gb, ssd.
 
It doesn’t seem like you know Aperture. Aperture has been and still is superior in terms of workflow to every other Raw editior out there. Plugins and extensions will not replace that. For retouching and filters, I already go to Photoshop, that’s not gonna be any different. But Photos has lost Aperture’s core advantage. That’s the troubling part.

I've been using Aperture since it cost $499. It's been almost 10 years.

If you can't see how an operating system level library with extensions opens up doors to unlimited types of workflows, then you lack creativity.

A metadata extension for example could add pro level file management to Photos that isn't available or necessary in the base app. An auto importer could help professionals who work with thousands of photos.

How about this for a workflow? You're out in the field, you take photos, unload them via WiFi to your iPhone and you do some sorting and start editing on your way back to the studio. Once there, you get on your Mac and continue editing. You get to a photo that needs a little more TLC so you pick up your iPad, send the photo to Pixelmator via its extension and find all the tools including layers that you need to make your photo look amazing. You run down to your local coffee shop and do some final polishes while you wait for your client to arrive. Together you make a few more adjustments and you AirDrop the photos to her iPhone. She taps her iPhone against yours to pay you via ApplePay, you shake hands and you're wrapped up.

Try to do that in Aperture.
 
So Wi-Fi and audio still don't work correctly but hey at least we get a new application to organize/store/upload/share our photos. Wow, it's like 2002 all over again!
 
I've been using Aperture since it cost $499. It's been almost 10 years.

If you can't see how an operating system level library with extensions opens up doors to unlimited types of workflows, then you lack creativity.

A metadata extension for example could add pro level file management to Photos that isn't available or necessary in the base app. An auto importer could help professionals who work with thousands of photos.

How about this for a workflow? You're out in the field, you take photos, unload them via WiFi to your iPhone and you do some sorting and start editing on your way back to the studio. Once there, you get on your Mac and continue editing. You get to a photo that needs a little more TLC so you pick up your iPad, send the photo to Pixelmator via its extension and find all the tools including layers that you need to make your photo look amazing. You run down to your local coffee shop and do some final polishes while you wait for your client to arrive. Together you make a few more adjustments and you AirDrop the photos to her iPhone. She taps her iPhone against yours to pay you via ApplePay, you shake hands and you're wrapped up.

Try to do that in Aperture.

As a potential client, if I knew you edited on an iPhone and an iPad i'd be walking out the door. That would tell me everything I needed to know about the quality and care you give a client.
 
I'm enjoying the new Photos app but am supremely disappointed that edits from iOS aren't syncing. I use a mixture of photo editing extensions and iOS stock editing tools to edit every photo.

Photos.app has pulled them across unedited and uncropped. Same with iCloud Photos on the web.

If I wanted that I wouldn't have taken the time to edit and crop every photo.

Surely this is a bug? :( How can I report this?
 
I'm in the public beta program under my own account and our family account.. Shows up on my iMac, and have downloaded.. Not shown up on my Mac mini. Cant work it out ?

Any ideas ?
 
Since updating I've been unable to connect my wireless earphones (Jaybirds Bluebirds X) to my Macbook, when I attempt to play sound to them they disconnect. I will be restoring to Time Machine backup.

This suggests that maybe some Bluetooth-related changes have been made in this update..
 
I can't see this version being any use to me.

Whilst I am just an amateur photographer, the apparent lack of an effects brush simply won't do.

If brush support is added, and features like lens/perspective* correction is added, that's when I'll start looking at it.

* Even my super-expensive wide-angle can do with a bit of correction from time to time
 
I've been using Aperture since it cost $499. It's been almost 10 years.

If you can't see how an operating system level library with extensions opens up doors to unlimited types of workflows, then you lack creativity.

A metadata extension for example could add pro level file management to Photos that isn't available or necessary in the base app. An auto importer could help professionals who work with thousands of photos.

How about this for a workflow? You're out in the field, you take photos, unload them via WiFi to your iPhone and you do some sorting and start editing on your way back to the studio. Once there, you get on your Mac and continue editing. You get to a photo that needs a little more TLC so you pick up your iPad, send the photo to Pixelmator via its extension and find all the tools including layers that you need to make your photo look amazing. You run down to your local coffee shop and do some final polishes while you wait for your client to arrive. Together you make a few more adjustments and you AirDrop the photos to her iPhone. She taps her iPhone against yours to pay you via ApplePay, you shake hands and you're wrapped up.

Try to do that in Aperture.

You will not be doing my wedding photos then!
 
I'm enjoying the new Photos app but am supremely disappointed that edits from iOS aren't syncing. I use a mixture of photo editing extensions and iOS stock editing tools to edit every photo.

Photos.app has pulled them across unedited and uncropped. Same with iCloud Photos on the web.

If I wanted that I wouldn't have taken the time to edit and crop every photo.

Surely this is a bug? :( How can I report this?

Help > Send Photos Feedback
 
Professional Photographers: Photos is a platform for OSX, not just an app. The app is only the front end UI that Apple provides. Extensions are what will make this infinitely powerful for professionals. Imagine Pixelmator being able to natively tap into your Photos library and execute non destructive edits that will then become available to your library through Photos.app on your Mac, iPad and iPhone.

Other extensions will add power to those who need it. Need more fine tune control for your EXIF data? More automated importing? There'll be an extension for that. A whole ecosystem is going to pop up and it'll be a serious threat to Adobe's Photoshop/Lightroom monopoly.

Photo libraries are now supported at the operating system level. This is huge.
Except, all that you say was already there with iPhoto and Aperture. And it didn't happen. The RAW converter was already part of the OS. All iPhoto and Aperture libraries were already available to other programs. What you describe was already possible on the existing framework and applications. It didn't happen. Why would it happen now?
 
As a potential client, if I knew you edited on an iPhone and an iPad i'd be walking out the door. That would tell me everything I needed to know about the quality and care you give a client.

"If I were a client and I knew you edited on a personal computer instead of in a dark room, I'd be walking out the door".

1995 called, they want you back.
 
Professional Photographers: Photos is a platform for OSX, not just an app. The app is only the front end UI that Apple provides. Extensions are what will make this infinitely powerful for professionals. Imagine Pixelmator being able to natively tap into your Photos library and execute non destructive edits that will then become available to your library through Photos.app on your Mac, iPad and iPhone.

Other extensions will add power to those who need it. Need more fine tune control for your EXIF data? More automated importing? There'll be an extension for that. A whole ecosystem is going to pop up and it'll be a serious threat to Adobe's Photoshop/Lightroom monopoly.

Photo libraries are now supported at the operating system level. This is huge.

Sorry to be skeptical, but I haven't seen a single pro-level extension, or even the announcement of one from the usual suspects. As it is, Photos appears to be severely gimped (no pun intended) to the point of being unusable.

I admire your, uh, enthusiasm but until I see anything concrete, I'm calling BS.
 
Sorry to be skeptical, but I haven't seen a single pro-level extension, or even the announcement of one from the usual suspects. As it is, Photos appears to be severely gimped (no pun intended) to the point of being unusable.

I admire your, uh, enthusiasm but until I see anything concrete, I'm calling BS.

Considering it's been less than 24 hours since the release of the beta to developers I'm not too surprised with that.
 
I'm in the public beta program under my own account and our family account.. Shows up on my iMac, and have downloaded.. Not shown up on my Mac mini. Cant work it out ?

Any ideas ?

It wont show up on my mac mini either... I wonder what the deal is?
 
Anyone know what the menu option for "File > Consolidate" does? I'm too scared to click it haha, worried I might screw up my photo sorting or something.
 
The Verge is saying it hides things in the file system. If you set it to store locally, it has to be storing them somewhere. Any clues? If you use an app to display where space is being taken up, there has to be something.

It doesn't "hide" them, but there is no easy way to find a photo outside of the app. There is a complex file structure on disk corresponding to your photos, and it's not obvious what photos are what. iPhoto is the same way.

----------

I'm enjoying the new Photos app but am supremely disappointed that edits from iOS aren't syncing. I use a mixture of photo editing extensions and iOS stock editing tools to edit every photo.

Photos.app has pulled them across unedited and uncropped. Same with iCloud Photos on the web.

If I wanted that I wouldn't have taken the time to edit and crop every photo.

Surely this is a bug? :( How can I report this?

According to the release notes, there are a couple ways this could happen:
- edited images on iOS may not show their changes in Photos until you open each changed photo in Edit mode within photos.
- Additionally, the release notes say that syncing does not work well between iOS 8.1.3 and Photos. They recommend using the 8.2 Beta on your phone if you intend to test Photos.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.