Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Studio Display Owners Complain of High-Pitched Buzzing Sound Likely Caused By Electrical Interference
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
In 35+ years of using Apple products, the Apple Studio Display is the best money I never spent.
So with you on this. I waited in anticipation and then when I finally went to look at it in-person I was very disappointed. I'm actually starting to seriously consider the XDR... It would be nice if they updated it though.
Yep, just you. My Studio Display is performing perfectly, no buzz and never had the speaker issue either. And as the article points out MacRumors has no idea how widespread the issue is. The problem is with social media and pile on nature of it. And don’t rule out the trolls who claim they have the issue when they don’t even own the product. Think that doesn’t happen? Think again. Just take a look at these forums packed with those who consistently trash the company and its products over and over and over again.
Now march on over to the Apple Discussion Forums and peruse the Displays section and the Mac Studio section where the Studio Display is discussed. See any talk about this issue? I don’t.
Linux users would love a 5K screen, as fractional scaling doesn't really exist there in a fully functional form
...bro I've never met a single Linux user who said "damn, I wish I had a 5K monitor to run Arch on right now" especially since the majority of Linux users hate Apple's guts (for good reason)
This is a terrible take: MANY people are purchasing it solely because a decent looking 5k monitor has value to them. Your feelings about what's good enough for people doesn't negate that reality.
Insulting others' preferences because of Apple's seemingly over-engineered project is an incredibly odd way to criticize.
That's probably because they all use low dpi screens as they know that everything else sucks.
I don't know how Linux managed to end up in this mess, where high dpi monitors are such a pain to deal with.
Or you could get a WiFi/bluetooth controlled plug as a workaround.
Precisely. I am a neurophysiologist and in my research we amplify millivolt signals by thousands of times. We get all sorts of noise, from illegally boosted CB radio to humidifiers. Often in diagnosing problems we have had to call out electricians to check out a given building's wiring. Two things have become obvious from my experiences of this: First, in both the US and UK a shockingly high proportion of outlets are not properly grounded via the third prong. It got so bad in one building in the US, our lab head had a 50-foot metal bar driven into the soil near the building to act as a proper ground. Second, at least in the UK, the idea the the AC current is a smooth sine wave is laughable. You should see the high frequency crap coming out of the outlets. So it is possible some of this issue is due to factors other than the monitor, and the variation among user's experiences depends on the quality of the wiring they have attached their system to.
It's probably "coil whine". Coils aka inductors are present on motherboards, power supplies, graphics cards in all computers.
Simply put the coil vibrates, when a current passes through it the wire inside vibrates, it's the same electromagnetic effect that makes audio speakers work.
The problem can have many causes including: cheap & nasty components, poor internal power filtering, dirty mains power, broken or cracked coil cores, dry solder joints, poor mechanical isolation of circuit boards and a zillion others. It can be very difficult to resolve without component replacement as swop out boards may have the same issue.
Simply put the coil vibrates, when a current passes through it the wire inside vibrates, it's the same electromagnetic effect that makes audio speakers work.
The problem can have many causes including: cheap & nasty components, poor internal power filtering, dirty mains power, broken or cracked coil cores, dry solder joints, poor mechanical isolation of circuit boards and a zillion others. It can be very difficult to resolve without component replacement as swop out boards may have the same issue.
I couldn’t agree more. And mostly from folks who don’t actually own the display!
I don’t know how widespread the electrical whine is, but I haven’t heard it. In fact, mine is the best monitor I have owned since my 27” Thunderbolt Display. So much so, that I’m genuinely thinking about adding a second one to my setup. Sure that makes for an expensive setup, but literally nothing else on the market can compete with the specific blend of features and Mac OS integration that this monitor offers.
Last edited:
I love mine and have not experienced any of these reported issues (knock on wood). (That said, I am still not super thrilled at the price I paid. )
I cannot dispute that these issues exist just because of my anecdotal experience. I will probably get flamed for this, but I can't help but think this is a result of a WFH engineered product. How many commuted to work to see/touch/test prototypes in the lab?
) I cannot dispute that these issues exist just because of my anecdotal experience. I will probably get flamed for this, but I can't help but think this is a result of a WFH engineered product. How many commuted to work to see/touch/test prototypes in the lab?
Not to be that guy, but mine has been trouble free and seriously just works. I really like it.
Bro what
High DPi monitors are supported on Linux very well with native binary packages. KDE Plasma has had HiDPI scaling settings in the GUI and has had them since 2020
My guy do you even use Linux?
You might not find benefit in it, but many do.
I wish Apple would make a not-affordable-but-at-least-cheaper base model display. No speakers or other unnecessary nonsense. Just make a quality display.
Thank the deity that Apple didn't go through with its original plan to make this the new Mx 27 inch iMac. I guess these kinds of things are to be expected when you replace iMac internals with an iPhone at the last minute, without proper QC.
All the more reason I keep saying this monitor is completely unreleasable and needs to be pulled from sale
Yeah just take the M1 iMac, remove the Mac part and the chin, and sell that for $700. That's it. That's all they had to do.
I’d bet it’s related to the power supply. I and others experienced something similar with the PowerMac G5 back in the day.
Disappointing to hear this product plagued with more issues as I had every intention of buying two this week.
Disappointing to hear this product plagued with more issues as I had every intention of buying two this week.
Capacitors can also do the same, albeit for different physical reasons.
For all the money Apple puts into cosmetics in their products, you'd think that they'd go the extra distance in the power supply designs to minimize these effects as well as providing reduced susceptibility to less than perfect AC mains power. But, noooo...
Also, for what it's worth, designs of Apple power supplies often are such that they add AC pollution to the AC mains themselves. That causes issues with other products plugged into the same circuits as the Apple products. Two sides of the same coin. They may pass the rather lax compliance agency requirements, but Apple product purchasers should expect more.
One of the best words that can be used to describe Apple is hubris.
Then, provide a suitable lens placed in front of the screen so that it appears to be 27 inches. Heck - why not 35 inches?
LG 5k still the best option. This thing has been a mess and costs several hundreds more.
My BenQ monitor does this sometimes. I can usually stop it by turning it off and back on again, but it is annoying. Though the BenQ only cost $400…
Disappointing that this buggy overpriced monitor is the replacement for the 27” iMac
Disappointing that this buggy overpriced monitor is the replacement for the 27” iMac
I just don’t understand how they release this display, which is a very mild update to the 5k Ultrafine from 2016, and have all of these problems.
If you really like 5k then buy the LG. It’s just the better product right now, cost by far and reliability.