Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
As if that "press conference" wasn't stupid enough. Good to know our hard earned money is going toward the salary of the greatest PR minds in the business. Well played, Apple.
 
Man oh man

Everyone just chill out. Seriously.

If you dig deep enough, you will find a flaw in anything. Surprise: The iPhone 4 isn't perfect. It is only incredible. And the Droid X is pretty great too! THERE ARE A LOT OF GOOD PHONES.

Take your free case, return the phone if it's really that bad, and get on with your lives. I love reading MacRumors and checking out opinions on the forums, but let's talk about something else now.
 
Apple is doing nothing but proving the facts.

They made a comment and a point about other smart phones ...

These companies publicly denied Apple's claims.

So, Apple decided to solidify their actions with a video backing up their claims.

And there's something wrong with that?

Too many armchair quarterbacks around here lately ... what would you do if you where in Apple's situation right now, roll over and take it?
 
apple is so god damn pathetic these days. squeeze it real hard, steve! try to make those bars drop. meanwhile, a touch of baby's breath on your assPhone 4 instantly kills the call and data.

no wonder apple fanboys are so delusional. look at their role models!
 
Remember when Apple posted a video of the iPad? It was on CNN.com (or something else, I'm not sure) but I am sure that it was displaying FLASH CONTENT.

I guess it's a mystery, but Apple probably didn't spoof the signal bar drops. That would probably be illegal and definately against Apple's morals and previous actions.

But do you own a Droid X and see the 3G symbol? Or are you assuming there should be one there? Not accusing, just asking.

If you wanna talk "spoofing", notice how the Youtube video of the Droid X only has 305 views. Hmmmmmm........

I own a Droid X and it does display the 3G symbol. It's very odd that in the video, it happens to be missing. There had to be some kind of editing or tampering for that 3G to disappear.

Also, the Youtube views for popular videos stay at that low number, but will change later. This happens with all popular videos. This is nothing different.
 
Apple is looking more like the guy on the forums that won't stop arguing with you. He will just keep spamming and spamming until you get so tired of what he/she is saying you just get turned off. This is how Apple is behaving now.

My respect for Apple has gone down the drain since the Antenna press conference. Trying to blame other companies for their own mishaps is creating a lot of enemies and attempting to put other mobile phone companies into the mix when they shouldnt be involved.

Apple should be completely ashamed of themselves. How stuck up can they be? I am a beloved iPad owner but all this nonsense will diminish Apple's brand. No wonder why theres so many apple haters out there... Because of behavior like this.
 
Remember when Apple posted a video of the iPad? It was on CNN.com (or something else, I'm not sure) but I am sure that it was displaying FLASH CONTENT.

I guess it's a mystery, but Apple probably didn't spoof the signal bar drops. That would probably be illegal and definately against Apple's morals and previous actions.

But do you own a Droid X and see the 3G symbol? Or are you assuming there should be one there? Not accusing, just asking.

If you wanna talk "spoofing", notice how the Youtube video of the Droid X only has 305 views. Hmmmmmm........

Yes i own a Droid X. Only time 3G or 1X is not displayed is when connected to WiFi.
 
Not that I disagree with you, but quoting sales number isn't always the best sign of a good product. Walmart sells a lot of crap, but I wouldn't call it quality, same for McDonalds

You have a point, however in this case, quoting the sales number works in this scenario. Apple sold 2 million iPhones the first week. Within that week the bad press got out about the reception problems, within a month another 1 million sold, plus the existing owners (right on this forum) refused to return their iPhone 4's because they loved it still regardless of the problem. You're talking about quality? The iPhone 4 is the best on the market in terms of smartphones. Droid X customer's wish they could have their phones look as good as the iPhone 4's Retina Display. In this case, sales amount is very indicative of the quality of the iPhone 4.
 
apple is so god damn pathetic these days. squeeze it real hard, steve! try to make those bars drop. meanwhile, a touch of baby's breath on your assPhone 4 instantly kills the call and data.

no wonder apple fanboys are so delusional. look at their role models!

Speaking of childish...
 
I couldn't care less if an iPhone in NYC drops a call if u squeeze it because where I live and travel frequently my ip4 works perfectly no matter how I hold it
 
Agreed and quite frankly my issue is not with the issue but the way companies respond to them. I thinks Apple's response was unacceptable. However, if that is how they want to do business, I will take my business elsewhere.

More iPhone for the rest of us.

Hopefully you will not take the last iPhone right before is my turn in the two day 3000 people line... Thanks
 
I'll be the first to say that I agree that many phones have this same issue, and it was probably a smart move for Apple to show the first few videos at the press conference last Friday, but...

APPLE! The horse is already dead! Put down your baseball bats and leave it the hell alone already.

How long did they beat Apple to death before they responded and they were getting beat up about how long it took to respond. They should drive it home, I still hear people asking about the issue, even myself being asked about my iPhone 4 antenna.
Drive it home Apple!!!:apple::apple::apple:
 
These companies publicly denied Apple's claims.

No, they didn't - indeed they were very careful not to.

And two that had not been sucked in saw their weasel words blow up in their faces (if you will excuse the hideously contorted metaphor).
 
Apple should be ashamed of themselves. The gloves are off now. This holiday season, let the vicious marketing begin.

Mobile Phone Wars Begun It Has!
 
sorry to burst your bubble - the white iphone will be manufactured the same way. If they changed the design they would have to go through FCC approval again and that would be public record.

In other words - they would be admitting fault. And the over 3 Million (more by then) customers with Black iPhones would be heading to Apple with pitchforks and lawyers.

I've seen the latter replies to this, but what makes you so sure? You have an in depth knowledge? I'm not so bothered to be honest as my 3GS has never let me down, but don't you think it's a bit suspicious that further delays have been announced?
 
Apple is looking more like the guy on the forums that won't stop arguing with you. He will just keep spamming and spamming until you get so tired of what he/she is saying you just get turned off. This is how Apple is behaving now.
Nonsense. Apple would quite cheerfully walk away, but the other guys in forum just won't let it lie...
 
Someone check this! I don't have the iP4 or DX.

I own a Droid X and it does display the 3G symbol. It's very odd that in the video, it happens to be missing. There had to be some kind of editing or tampering for that 3G to disappear.

That's strange. I, too, now doubt the realisticness of the test very slightly. However, look at the Youtube video description. It says that it dropped bars. Apple can't lie about that. Maybe it was 'shopped for some other reason???

Take a look:
 

Attachments

  • Droid-X-to-End-up-in-the-Hands-of-the-Business-Community.jpg
    Droid-X-to-End-up-in-the-Hands-of-the-Business-Community.jpg
    121.1 KB · Views: 61
So we have half the posters here saying everyone gets it and Apple is wasting their time demonstrating it in videos.

Then we have the other half who deny that the issue exists in other smartphones, even after seeing the videos.

Very few of the people posting seem to care about observation and facts. This is a problem in the whole industry. Apple is pointing that out because so many people are saying it's just Apple. In fact, iPhone 4 has a great antenna in the sense that reception even when "holding it wrong" is better than most others:
http://www.anandtech.com/show/3794/the-iphone-4-review/2

That it's not just minor or obscure grip issues on other phones can be seen by all the cell phone manuals warning users about how NOT to hold their phones:
http://www.techbitts.com/2010/07/collection-of-dont-hold-it-wrong-cell.html

Very well said.

If not for the initial waves of 'finger pointing' and 'singling out,' revelations such as this would not be necessary.

I Don’t believe it, and I’ve never been in a Dr.’s office where the Dr. had time to go play with phones in his waiting room?

Surely, they ordered a pizza while discussing reception on cellphones.
 
That's strange. I, too, now doubt the realisticness of the test very slightly. However, look at the Youtube video description. It says that it dropped bars. Apple can't lie about that. Maybe it was 'shopped for some other reason???

Take a look:

I don't understand. What's the picture of the original Droid for? lol
 
I've seen the latter replies to this, but what makes you so sure? You have an in depth knowledge? I'm not so bothered to be honest as my 3GS has never let me down, but don't you think it's a bit suspicious that further delays have been announced?

Suspicious started when Apple just so happened to release their first Apple-branded "case" (aka, the Bumper) after 4 years of producing phones. And it JUST so happens that this new design was to completely cover the outer stainless steel band that just so happened to be the "minor" flaw in design that started this whole mess.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.