Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
What about apple privacy engagement if Google assistant or Alexa is installed on iPhone ?
Have a feeling to deter people from swapping to another assistant Apple will place a boogeyman warning when attempting to switch
 
This would be a game changer for me.. Siri and apple intelligence don't work on Portuguese from Portugal.. which makes CarPlay and other features almost useless. I am thinking switching to a pixel since Gemini works With Portuguese from Portugal. If apple does allow this, I will probably stay in the ecosystem.
Yes, I'm wondering if this might increase sales of iPhones, etc., or at least help maintain their numbers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: System603
I’ve never understood the criticism of Siri. Sure, it doesn’t have the breadth of knowledge of Google but it never once fails to set a reminder or a timer. Directions in Apple Maps are concise and the on-device help feature genuinely useful.
I’m genuinely unsure above whether this post is humorous or not. Surely nobody would seriously argue Siri doesn’t suck because it sets timers and it gives directions…
 
Have a feeling to deter people from swapping to another assistant Apple will place a boogeyman warning when attempting to switch
I don't think that would do anything other than to mildly annoy people as they switch assistants.
 
This has never been a must-have feature for me. I don’t care who makes it. It feels like a gimmick that’s cool for five minutes, and then I never use it again. Maybe in 5-7 years, I’ll try it again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bungaree.Chubbins
Or maybe if Apple was forced to actually compete on their platform their voice assistant wouldn’t be such a ****ing joke.
Under what obligation are Apple to allow Amazon Alexa or Google on their iPhone?
 
Have a feeling to deter people from swapping to another assistant Apple will place a boogeyman warning when attempting to switch

Eh. Google similarly already warns people the first time before allowing apps to be side-loaded in Android, but the important thing is they won't stop you. If you need a further comparison, they also sensibly warn of privacy issues if you set up third party speech recognition or text-to-speech apps. These features should all be available, pending parental control locks, of course.

This has never been a must-have feature for me. I don’t care who makes it. It feels like a gimmick that’s cool for five minutes, and then I never use it again. Maybe in 5-7 years, I’ll try it again.

I pulled my Amazon Echo dots back out of storage after a major knee injury last month. Being able to tell something to turn the lights off from across the room is so handy. I could also unlock my phone and go to the widget to do it, but that's slower. That's just voice control, and hopefully there will be a locally-hosted alternative eventually.

On the other hand, a while back, I really wanted to buy a couple of specific items of a line that looked like it was being closed out, and I wanted to do it locally, but the vendor only had general national chain information. It would have been really nice to type in, 'hey, (Siri or Google or Alexa), who carries this model flashlight locally?' Turned out Google's AI didn't know, either, and I suspect the other search engines with shopping tabs didn't either, but that would be exactly the sort of thing a virtual assistant would be good for. Go find this thing, give me a list, and maybe even let me buy it and go get it. From reading Gurman's article in Bloomberg, Steve Jobs thought similarly, enough to hound the original Siri devs to sell it to Apple in the first place.
 
Last edited:
Have a feeling to deter people from swapping to another assistant Apple will place a boogeyman warning when attempting to switch
Well, Apple needs to inform customers of the privacy risks. If you let Google have an open mic on your iPhone that you have next to you 24/7, there’s some severe privacy implications. Some people might accept those risks, but Apple has the duty to inform its customers.
 
I’ve never understood the criticism of Siri. Sure, it doesn’t have the breadth of knowledge of Google but it never once fails to set a reminder or a timer. Directions in Apple Maps are concise and the on-device help feature genuinely useful.
It fails to do those things all the time for me and many other people have reported the same issue

You’re an outlier. If there’s a chance of an error, that means there’s a chance you’ll never run into an error. That’s why listening to other people and empathizing with their experiences makes you more in touch with reality
 
Last edited:
Siri works fine enough for the very infrequent and limited tasks I use it for. Honestly I can’t imagine why people would switch to Google. You basically have an always listening mic on you which feeds the spyware company.
 
It’s not about whether Siri is good or not. It’s about the principle of being able to choose your own AI assistant (I would choose a private one that runs on my own home systems) and STILL be able to enjoy the full Apple ecosystem.

THIS IS GREAT and I wish they’d make this global and without needing the EU to force them.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.