And this is exactly what I do. I use Spotify for discovery, and then if I love the album, I hit up Amazon to purchase a physical copy. Call me old-fashioned, but my collection has to be physical before digital. You simply don't get the same experience with an album you love if you just own it digitally. Plus, it looks great on a CD rack.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Working with U2 on New Music Format to Boost Digital Music Sales
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
And this is exactly what I do. I use Spotify for discovery, and then if I love the album, I hit up Amazon to purchase a physical copy. Call me old-fashioned, but my collection has to be physical before digital. You simply don't get the same experience with an album you love if you just own it digitally. Plus, it looks great on a CD rack.
Obviously there is something that can be done. Write a dozen good songs, without listening to rubbish producers who tell you to copy the last hit song you had again and again. Admittedly, it's hard. But people have done it before.
yepp, that's true. i just don't get how Bono/U2 could help with this issue. i guess it's an engineering/researching/biology kind of story. for sure they could compare how it sounds, but i hardly believe that an average (or extraordinary) musician could come up with a groundbreaking technical theory to revolutionise the music industry's de-facto digital standards. i mean, without the expertise i just don't see the value they could add... or it's just some marketing BS, right?
Someone has to let Apple know about the opensource FLAC-format...
Someone willing to create a Quicktime Plug-in implementing it, so that people can use it? (And forget about Apple adding it themselves and putting iTunes or QuickTime under GPL control). What are the bets that there is someone involved in the code who doesn't want it to run on iOS devices?
Spotify anyone?
Maybe they should purchase spotify or one of the other streaming services?
...Think Different...
Maybe they should purchase spotify or one of the other streaming services?
...Think Different...
He didn't give U2 $100m. I'm sure he is so worried about your opinion on his competence. Maybe you could read up and learn a bit more about the deal.
Next up: A new improved format every year with discontinuation of old formats more than two years old.
I don't think they're talking about a file format. They're referring to a new way of releasing albums, whatever that means. It could be including live performances, or artwork or gear with an album purchase. But it's probably something I haven't thought of.
I can't imagine a new audio file format is their ambition. I wouldn't be at all surprised if they rolled out a new file format so they can boast "10x better than mp3!" as part of their marketing, but this has got to be about distribution. A new marketplace with really great discovery tools? A pay-per-listen until you've spent enough to own the album model?
Between Pandora, iTunes, YouTube, and the occasional other digital purchase, I get all the music I want. I can't imagine what would make me spend more on music. They've got a tall task ahead of them...
Between Pandora, iTunes, YouTube, and the occasional other digital purchase, I get all the music I want. I can't imagine what would make me spend more on music. They've got a tall task ahead of them...
I have never been intrigued - at all - by any music streaming service. If I like an album (or a song), I have to own it.
Guess I'm in the minority.
Guess I'm in the minority.
Better music would make me buy more.
There are a LOT of bands out there that never get the kind of exposure needed to boost music sales.
Example :
Arcade Fire.
They made their own distribution system. Produced their own music. Most importantly they are talented. That got them exposure. Concept albums.
Then they were the first indy band to win a grammy for best album.
This is the type of thing the music industry needs to have in the mainstream.
If Timmy wants to spend 20 Billion dollars to make the industry better and if he is successful I say go for it. In the long run it is worth it.
A la carte...
Or we could just buy a song's drum track for a quarter, the bass-line for another, keyboards, guitars, vocals... until one fine day & before we even know it, we've got the whole damn song paid off ...
No, but seriously, I like your idea...
Or we could just buy a song's drum track for a quarter, the bass-line for another, keyboards, guitars, vocals... until one fine day & before we even know it, we've got the whole damn song paid off ...
No, but seriously, I like your idea...
Last edited:
U2 played "Wake Up" before every concert in 2005/2006 and certainly got a lot of U2 fans exposed to AF. That is how I discovered AF.
Who else got "given" a crap album by bunch of old farts they didn't ask for in the first place?
You Too?
You Too?
Wrong, the BEP have been around just as long as U2. Before they hit it big on the charts, they started off in the making undergriund hip hop records
Nor can the vast majority of "audiophiles" if they try and pick out the difference in an ABX test.
Same reason as the people who laughed at new coke weren't running the coca cola company (as well as every other corporate screwup). Just because someone is running a company doesn't mean they are going to magically make every decision better than anyone else on the planet.
Apple released ping, MobileMe, the cube, and an iPod with no buttons. Do you not agree that the vast majority of the general public that panned those knew better than Apple?
Or maybe this is an internet discussion board and there are other options besides "i know better than Apple" and full on sycophant.
The real Mona Lisa is actually a huge waste of time. I would much rather see a print than the real thing from 30 feet away.
That's the kind of thing that sticks in your mind while attending a concert.
People milling about and you hear some band playing over the P.A. system and people start wondering who the band is.
That is one very good way to get the music out.
I was exposed to AF one night watching Dave Letterman. He has a habit of having bands on his show that nobody knows.
Stephen Colbert did it a couple days ago with a 3 piece band of 13 year old kids. They were great.