This is the most absurd thing I ever heard. (a) Apple will accept a purchase receipt from any seller, regardless of whether they are an Apple dealer or not, because they must do so under anti-trust legislation(and we have a written confirmation from Apple to that effect on file); (b) the first thing you do when you have a problem with Apple is to contact your seller, so that they can sort this out. Toshcomputers gives a 100% satisfaction guarantee, and if your Applecare does not register, you get a full refund.
Now, if you buy an AppleCare warranty and you do not register it while your original AppleCare is still in effect (as clearly described in the eBay listing that ToshComputers provides), then there is nothing they can do.
If Apple then refuses to register your Applecare they are completely correct (and no receipt from anyone will change that), as by the terms of AppleCare you can only register AppleCare when your original warranty is still valid.
This shouldn't be too hard...
This is nonsense. No one ever buys from eBay. You might buy from a seller who posts on eBay, but eBay is never the seller. The seller is the company or individual you buy from, through eBay, and companies like ToshComputers always provide a receipt/invoice which you use as a proof of purchase.
You are trying to register a product that you are not allowed to register because Apple's terms and conditions are that AppleCare can only be added when your original Applecare warranty is still in effect... This would have been clearly stated on the listing for the product, and if Apple were to register your AppleCare it would be a courtesy and not by your right. It has nothing to do with your Applecare product.
This is like buying a movie ticket and then not being in time to watch the show. If you come a week later and want to see the movie, they'll turn you away. It has nothing to do with the quality of the movie ticket you bought originally.
And is there any information that would allow you to conclude that this buyer has fallen for a 'scam'? All I have heard is that he slept through the deadline of his AppleCare registration, and didn't contact the seller to get help. If there is anything else you know, I would be delighted to hear it...
Folks, I have NEVER even heard of Toshcomputers, nor ever bought anything from them... but... I have to say this...
THIS MAN IS 95% CORRECT!!!!!!!!
(SEE EDIT FOR REASON OF 95%)
I have purchased applecare off ebay, worked 100% of the time no issues. The entire issue here, and I'm sorry to say it... you are going against apples ToS now that you waited UNTIL AFTER your original 1 year warranty expired. You even said it right in the original post. That my friend, and again, I'm sorry, is your ONLY mistake in this entire endeavor.
Had you added the warranty while you were still covered, apple accepts them no matter what. I have NEVER had an issue doing this. But it is APPLES, not Toshcomputers, rules that you are now violating by adding AFTER your 1 year original manufacturer's warranty.
Again, I have NO connection with toshcomputers at all, never even heard of the guy before until this post.
Just hate to see a guy getting bashed by an uninformed buyer. Again, I mean no disrespect... but the information is out there for the having, you just have to look.
EDIT:
So after some looking around, it seems in October Apple changed their policy about applecare. You have to provide "proof of purchase" OR the serial number from the outside of the box. It seems most of the ebay sales are now providing you with the serial number from the outside of the box along with shipping you the box for proof of purchase. I haven't bought since October so was originally unaware of this. So I would say that toshcomputers would need to at least give you the serial number off the box... but, the same issue still stands. You waited until outside your original warranty, which is Apple's rule and they stand hard by it normally. If he provided you with proof of purchase and or serial number, then he did all he can. It used to be all you needed was the code emailed to you, which apparently no longer is the case as of October.
EDIT #2
As of early October apple has changed their policies regarding applecare, No longer can you register applecare with simply a code that everyone is selling on eBay. You must have either a proof of purchase from an authorized apple re-seller (who apple does not allow to sell on eBay) or the serial number on the outside of the sealed box as proof of purchase.
The paragraph above is what I'm seeing on all the ebay sellers pages that I have bought applecare from. All of them carry 100% feedback, and it has worked for me 100% in the past... before October that is. They of course did not have this on their pages when i purchased but they have updated to carry this paragraph now.... which shows that in my eyes, you can trust them. But it seems to be pretty widely accepted that the policy was changed in October.