Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
this is such a load of crap. I still want one though. I am pathetic

LOL I know what you mean. The iPhone 4 does everything else so well that this antennae thing is acceptable on the whole. I've been taking a look at my 3G and I usually don't hold it by that corner, so whatever. Waiting for the white one to come out anyway - perhaps they will have a firmware/software update by then?
 
It's either software problem (in which case all phones should be affected for they all use the same software) or it's "truly defective units". It can not be both and actually now that this document was leaked we know that it's neither - it's a design flaw.

No, consider the freezing iMacs in 2007 and again in 2009, it was a software fix yet some units had the issue and others didn't, exactly like the iPhone 4. Difficult to believe but true.
 
I got a replacement from Apple directly this morning. It was a week 24 vs my old week 22. BOTH did the same this. Two of my friends here in the UK also got iPhone4s, all exhibit the issue.

I really believe people who don't have the issue haven't travelled to areas that aren't city centres, areas that don't have highly strong signals.

88024xxxxxx = Week 24??? Again.....I live in an area with terrible AT&T signal for the most part. We do have 3G, but there are points where, on my commute home, I would lose signal and drop calls reliably........My iPhone 4 has yet to drop calls in these areas where my 3G would ALWAYS drop calls.
 
I haven't dropped a single call yet. I have conference rooms in my building that my 3G couldn't get a single bar of service, and my iPhone 4 shows full signal strength. I have about 10 co-workers who ALSO have the iPhone 4 and don't have a single issue with dropped bars. When I get home I can take a video of me doing the exact same test shown on the other videos around, and NOT losing a single bar of signal.

You probably had a defective phone, sorry....return it, and get another one. There may just be a bad lot out there.....maybe the conformal coating inside didn't cure right....or isn't thick enough....or perhaps there's a bad solder joint.....who knows. I can hold my phone in the death grip and it works. Sorry you can't accept that.

Give it up man. Even Apple already admitted the problem (indirectly by creating this leaked document). Do you own too much APPL or something?
 
I moved my fingers slightly away from the antenna and I don't have an issue anymore.

Free fix, you heard it here first.
 
Apple, the new Microsoft

Now here is a completely fair assessment. Like Microsoft, Apple has decided to copy others innovation and come out with an inferior product with which they are flooding the market and putting the little guys, like Htc, and nokia, out of business. On second thought, not much like Microsoft of yore in the least. More like the IBM of yore. Adobe... now there's a company flooding markets with inferior product!
 
Rock solid call quality

Signal shmignal. I see the number of bars decrease if I use the "death grip" but that's not how I hold the phone when I call anyway. And I do hold the phone with my left hand.

For me, the bottom line is call quality, not bar count. Sitting in exactly the same spot, I get far better sound quality and connection reliability with the iPhone 4 than I ever did with my ancient 2008 iPhone 3G. It's like a land line.
 
Thank God someone has the exact clue of what's going on.

EXACTLY!

All these idiots who are keeping their phone are really the most gullible people in the world. Return it and wait for this inevitable fix. They are probably doing this as we speak. The next batch will be silently 'upgraded'.

Early adopters, thank you for sacrificing your money so I can get a better product. Heh.
 
I've heard you can also buy scissors and golf clubs that are only for right handed people. Add them to your lawsuit, the bastards!!
 
When I do the hand thingy and run a speed test I go from 2619 kbps to 153..... So I'll say reception is affected.


No tests so far have shown that a hardware issue is to blame for reception problems on iPhone 4. In my own testing, I could not isolate any hand placement that prevented calls from working or lowered the reported data rates available, nor even could I force down the signal bars with a "death grip."
 
Or live in a place with great 3G coverage. I can go places where I can't get the bars to budge off 5 because the radio is so good it doesn't even need an antenna in good coverage areas.

But if you do need the external to make the thing work then it turns into a POS.

Actually my home was nearly always a dead-zone for my 3G and most inbound calls went to VM. Now these calls seem to be getting through, while my wife's 3G is still having problems. That makes me fairly sure that the sensitivity of the i4 is greater than the 3G and it simply works better than the 3G in my part of the world.
 
Since you're positive, why isn't the other antenna band affected? The one that handles WiFi, bluetooth, and GPS?

Maybe simply because the problem doesn't show at 2400Mhz (Wifi/Bluetooth) and 1575/1227Mhz (GPS). The signal attenuation with your finger on using Wifi/Bluetooth/GPS may not be too big while in the cellular bands 850Mhz/1900Mhz it does become a problem.

If for example the problem is only in the 850Mhz/900Mhz band Apple may come out with a switch to disable those bands in software, but this is hardly a solution.
 
Doesn't the top of the phone also have a gap between the antennas? What happens if you bridge this gap? An issue?

Buyer beware. If this was on verizon, i'd buy one still. If you don't like it, tough cookies.
 
You wrote "if you are left handed, burn in hell" in quotes, making me think that that was something a rep actually said to you, but nowhere in that article is there any such statement

Misleading title... please change.

Exactly. I'm a little tired of these dramatic folks taking things out of context, if there was any context to begin with, just to sensationalize a situation that never actually happened.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.