Re: Re: Re: Re: Let it go....
Originally posted by SiliconAddict
You yourself made my point. As I had stated previously if you use something enough you automatically assume its the easiest method of doing something.
Let me ask one final question on the topic. Lets assume we found someone with ZERO PC or Mac experience. Which system do you think they would pick up the right/alternate mouse click first?
Well, in point of fact, I've helped set several people up with new computers when they've never used a computer before. I've helped them with both Macs and PCs. In general, I've recieved more calls for help from the PC newbies than from the Mac newbies. Why? Because the interface on Mac OS doesn't
need the contextual menus. Everything you can do from the contextual menus you can also do from an actual menu. So, the Mac newbies are able to see what they want to do much faster. It's far easier for them. Now, if the graduate from being a newbie and start to explore some of the more advanced features, great! Then they can learn how to use contextual menus.
As a contrast, the PC people are forever looking for the proper widget to click to get at what they want. 'Do I look in the tool bar, the menu bar, or the stupid right click thingie?!?' It's a much more difficult system to learn, based on my experience with newbies.
... an alternate/right mouse click or a 2 button mouse where after 10-15 clicks an average, relatively intelligent, individual should pick up on it...
Again, I know several individuals that would take great insult with that comment, including my grandfather-in-law, who used to work for the Navy designing battleships, amoung other things. I certainly would
not refer to him as anything other than quite intelligent.
You like the single mouse. Thats great you can live with that. But coming from a PC environment I cant live without a 2 button mouse.
I never said that I like a one button mouse. All I ever said was that I can't stand multiple buttons on a track pad on a laptop. In point of fact, on my workstation I have a multi-button track ball. Actually, not only do I not like one button mice for my own use, I don't like mice at all. If I'm going to be doing any kind of serious work at a computer, I want a track ball. Does that mean that I think Apple should produce multi-button track balls for all of their computers? No. Not in the slightest. Why not? Because a mouse is easier for beginners to learn and use and because it's just as easy for me to go and get the track ball that suits me. After all, if I'm spending $3k on a computer, am I really going to complain about spending another $40 for the
right interface tool? Not likely.
Ive NEVER had problems with the mice buttons on my laptops. Its 1/2 an inch difference in spacing from the right mouse to the left. *shrugs* Its always been fine for me.
It's not the distance between them that's the problem for me. It's the placement. I typically rest my thumb across the button on the trackpad and navigate with my index finger. To reach the right button on Windows laptops, I have to shift my whole hand over to get my thumb to it (very impractical), or, on others, my thumb tends to rest at the joint between the two buttons, and clicking becomes a highly unpredictable affair. Now, maybe if there was a button along each side of the track pad, so the right edge button could be the right click, and I could hit it with my ring finger, that might just work well. But, as I said, I'm not against multiple buttons on PowerBooks (or even, for that matter, multi-button mice available for Power Macs - I just think that the consumer line is well aimed with simplicity being a key feature), I'm just against any configuration that I've seen so far.
Fortunately I think I have a workaround for when I get my PowerBook. Double tap the touchpad for left click, mouse for right. From what I understand you can program these for the touchpad and mouse button so there is somewhat of a workaround. Im still going to have to carry a BT mouse with me because of this.
When you get your PowerBook, I'd recommend installing the
SideTrack alternative trackpad driver. It makes programming button clicks this way easy, and it gives you edge scroll wheels.
I hope you enjoy your PowerBook when you get it. I think we're actually closer to agreeing than at first it might have seemed.
Peace.