Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Apps That Didn't Add 'Trader' Contact Info in the EU Removed From App Store

zach-coleman said:
Why would I gamble with the language of "you may not be considered a trader" just to put out a free app when it comes to fines or other legal action? I'm a software engineer, you could argue that a free project is still inside of my profession.
Click to expand...

Fines from who?

This is total FUD

It's readily provable on your part if you are putting out a free app and making no money off of it (not showing any intent to commercialize it)

The Trader self assessment bullet points are refreshingly clear and easy to interpret
 
This is total ********. I submitted the trader status a year ago and it was pending the entire time with no feedback until they pulled the plug. Then, to make matters worse, every time I try to upload documentation I get an error that literally says "Something went wrong. Try again."

I will say that Apple support is trying their best to be helpful in sorting this out to the point of giving me a temporary upload page for the documents.

Ultimately, the EU is a big steaming pile of bureaucracy that should never have happened.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jhfenton
chrono1081 said:
Yup. People at the EU didn't think this one through.
Click to expand...
Yes they did. They don't want anonymous people selling stuff online. Being unreachable anonymous means you can do "anything" (fraud, kiddy-porn, spyware,...)with no liability. But if your verified real name and contact info is on the product, you might tend be be more careful about what you release.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gco212, AppliedMicro, icanhazmac and 1 other person
I sold my previous car a few months ago. I go an eSIM burner for exactly zero euros.

I could probably find a similar arrangement for the address.

RogueWarrior65 said:
This is total ********. I submitted the trader status a year ago and it was pending the entire time with no feedback until they pulled the plug. Then, to make matters worse, every time I try to upload documentation I get an error that literally says "Something went wrong. Try again."

I will say that Apple support is trying their best to be helpful in sorting this out to the point of giving me a temporary upload page for the documents.

Ultimately, the EU is a big steaming pile of bureaucracy that should never have happened.
Click to expand...
Vote ao the next Euro election for an appropriately Euro skeptic party.
 
Last edited:
Macropanda said:
I think the worry is that a PO Box can cost hundreds per year.
I got one in the UK for free and all they bill for is scanning post that I get, which should almost never happen.

Then get a SIM card which in the uk you can easily get for under £5 a month and use that.

It’s annoying but not anywhere near as costly as it first seems.
Click to expand...
So if you are annoyed with a developer just send them lots of mail.....
 
Macropanda said:
I think the worry is that a PO Box can cost hundreds per year.
I got one in the UK for free and all they bill for is scanning post that I get, which should almost never happen.

Then get a SIM card which in the uk you can easily get for under £5 a month and use that.

It’s annoying but not anywhere near as costly as it first seems.
Click to expand...
You can’t force it on people. Lot of these bureaucracy is not needed. Let the store owners handle the issue, in this case Apple or third party app stores. Apple already verifies developer information.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jhfenton
RogueWarrior65 said:
This is total ********. I submitted the trader status a year ago and it was pending the entire time with no feedback until they pulled the plug. Then, to make matters worse, every time I try to upload documentation I get an error that literally says "Something went wrong. Try again."

I will say that Apple support is trying their best to be helpful in sorting this out to the point of giving me a temporary upload page for the documents.

Ultimately, the EU is a big steaming pile of bureaucracy that should never have happened.
Click to expand...
You wouldn’t have these issues if you could distribute your app through your own website.

But yeah… why would a monopoly distributor/store care about small developers like you?
 
  • Like
Reactions: freedomlinux, jakey rolling and turbineseaplane
I wonder if the sellers on eBay/Amazon have to provide phone numbers and address to rest of the world.
 
TechnoMonk said:
You can’t force it on people. Lot of these bureaucracy is not needed. Let the store owners handle the issue, in this case Apple or third party app stores. Apple already verifies developer information.
Click to expand...

The root issue is liability. If you sell software in the EU, you are subject to consumer protection laws that impose some liabilities to you and that's the reason you need to be traceable.

Apple is generally not liable for third-party software delivered through the App Store. To "handle the issue" in stead of the developer, Apple would have to forfeit their liability exemption and basically "become the trader".

While possible, it's definitely something Apple would be very wary to do.
 
Those who support the DMA and the EU:

"Small developers shouldn't have to pay the outrageous $99 developer fee that Apple charges!!!!"

Also those who support the DMA and the EU:

"A separate telephone number and PO Box are just a cost of doing business! If you don't like it, you shouldn't be in business!!!!"

:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: DefNotAnLLM, iOS Geek, TechnoMonk and 1 other person
Timo_Existencia said:
Those who support the DMA and the EU:

"Small developers shouldn't have to pay the outrageous $99 developer fee that Apple charges!!!!"

Also those who support the DMA and the EU:

"A separate telephone number and PO Box are just a cost of doing business! If you don't like it, you shouldn't be in business!!!!"

:)
Click to expand...
I have seen this movie before many times. Once you invite govt in private business, it’s never ending control.
bsolar said:
The root issue is liability. If you sell software in the EU, you are subject to consumer protection laws that impose some liabilities to you and that's the reason you need to be traceable.

Apple is generally not liable for third-party software delivered through the App Store. To "handle the issue" in stead of the developer, Apple would have to forfeit their liability exemption and basically "become the trader".

While possible, it's definitely something Apple would be very wary to do.
Click to expand...
Apple has refunded in the past. And generally helpful against rogue apps.
 
bsolar said:
Liability is not limited to refund. While Apple might be generally helpful against rogue Apps, they still explicitly deny as much liability as they can in their Developer Program License Agreement.

Apple would be on the hook for far more than some refunds if they were liable as a trader.
Click to expand...
Sounds like it’s liability doing business in EU. I can see lot of indies opting out of EU. At some point, it’s just not worth it.
 
I think some people are underestimating this barrier.

Most apps make no money. But that doesn't stop people from putting out apps, often in their spare time, and hoping to find an audience. One of the attractions of the App Store was that the up-front cost was low. If you owned a Mac and iPhone already (millions do) you could use free tools to develop something. If you got an audience, you could scale up, quit your day job, start a business.

This was a great model for Apple too - lots of store content, and if an app hit it big Apple got 30%.

Yes, it's a labor of love for many developers (it was for me), but that doesn't mean we want to subsidize our hobby to the tune of hundreds of dollars every year. My personal goal was to make back Apple's developer license fee every year, and I only managed that the first year.

I get that the EU had reasons for this requirement, but let's not pretend this is an easy lift for all indie developers. They aren't bellyaching because they are "lazy".
 
  • Like
Reactions: DefNotAnLLM and TechnoMonk
TechnoMonk said:
It doesn’t need to be full of bugs. People ask dumb things. You would be shocked at some of the messages customer support guys get.
Click to expand...
A lot of iPhone users are not technically minded. It’s just good practice to provide some form of customer support, even if their questions seem dumb to you and me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: turbineseaplane
TechnoMonk said:
Sounds like it’s liability doing business in EU. I can see lot of indies opting out of EU. At some point, it’s just not worth it.
Click to expand...

Maybe, but what is liability for the business is protection for the consumer. Ultimately there is need for some sort of balance as you definitely don't want businesses to be unaccountable for the products they sell to consumers.

Said that, IMHO if a developer is doing actual business they should be operating under a LLC anyway, regardless of whether they are in the EU or not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 0049190 and turbineseaplane
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back