Actually, you were correct. I looked a little more closely at the DirecTV portion of my AT&T bill and the $10 discount I'm receiving is for Advanced Receiver Service and it expires after 2 years. I decided to call AT&T to find out if something was amiss with the credit and it took no fewer than 5 different phone transfers for me to get to an agent who finally said, "Oh, you can't get both the $10 per month discount for combining your DirecTV and wireless accounts and the FAN discount on your wireless account. You have to pick one or the other."
No since in me trying again then.
Here are the reasons I am not doing this
1. If you have to merge accounts (AT&T w/ DirecTV or UVerse), I am out, not losing my 25% discount, not unless it's worth it.
2. Tethering is not allowed in this plan, which kind of sucks, why not, they already are throttling abusers, just a stupid rule for people that don't abuse it.
3. I have 6 phones, 5*40 = 200 + 100 for the plan (60 for plan and 40 for 1 phone) - 40 for 4th phone. that $260. I think my bill is lower, only because I use NEXT and my plan is $15 per phone, not $40. My current plan, I am already at $220...before my discount, my discount brings it down to (187.50). I don't see the cost benefit here unless we get the NEXT discount per phone which would bring down the price to $15 per line, which could bring down the bill to 5*15 = 75 + 75 for plan (60 for plan and 15 for 1 phone) - 15 for 4th phone, that's what 150, then I might consider, but I would like tethering.
I might have to call AT&T back and see what my options are...