This is still true. The poster is correct. You signed a contract, and you SHOULD get what you paid for. You paid for a 2 year commitment and after the 2 years, you are entitled to a new subsidy.
Personally, I think this is AT&T trying to be nice and give in, but in no means did they need to. Basically you are no better than a spoiled little kid who cried and cried until he finally got ice cream.
You may have gotten what you wanted, but you should be ashamed.
mmmmm Apple flavored Ice Cream god it tastes so much better when you get it cheaper, boo hoo for the people who are saving $$$$$$$$$$$