You don't have to give it but AT&T can ask for a $500 deposit or your credit card number too.
So...it's really a game of chicken isn't it. Do you need them or do they need you?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
AT&T Offers Walkthrough Videos for iPhone 3G Buying
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
You don't have to give it but AT&T can ask for a $500 deposit or your credit card number too.
So...it's really a game of chicken isn't it. Do you need them or do they need you?
This sucks. I got my wife a cheapo Razr at the same time as I got the iPhone last year. I can upgrade for $199+18 (what the heck is up with $18, anyway?), but I will be looking at full-boat $399 for her.
Or I can make her suffer for another 11 months. That won't fly.
I guess AT&T hasn't heard of the concept of pro-rated fees. I wouldn't mind a $100 penalty as much.
Why don't you get another line for your wife and then cancel the her existing line. If you already have used 1 yr of service then pro-rated early termination is $175-xxx. You'll still come out ahead...except she'll need to change her phone number.
Thanks, I will look into this. Maybe they'll buckle.
No chance to give her the old one, I already got rid of it (and for good money, so I really can't complain TOO much).
A Different iPhone Question
Haven't seen this covered yet (read many posts.... not all), currently living in Conn. and will be moving to Alamogordo, New Mexico and wondering the outcome of buying the iphone now and then going to NM where they don't have at&t service? The verizon guy says at&t will cancel the customer after a short time and I confirmed this at the at&t store in Las Cruces (50 mins. drive).... "after about 6 calls in alamogordo at&t sends a letter requesting the customer to cancel service because it is costing at&t to use another company's network towers". Would at&t demand the phone back or the full cost of the iphone?
Currently with at&t (5 yrs), best service for my home - travel often, no complaints. Using a "smart" phone Cing 3125 with $19.95 data plan - slow, not very useable for excel files.
I may live in Las Cruces (where at&t service is available), but will commute/work in Alamogordo. Really looking for the iphone's application ability.... the phone is secondary, just don't want to carry multiple devices with the power cords/accessories when "one device could do it all" (in the right location).
Any thoughts on this are appreciated - would be ok with paying at&t to stay with them, but doesn't look possible. Of course I already plan on acting completely surprised by lack of service and having to give up the iphone/at&t package.... just want to hold on to the phone without any more $$$!
Haven't seen this covered yet (read many posts.... not all), currently living in Conn. and will be moving to Alamogordo, New Mexico and wondering the outcome of buying the iphone now and then going to NM where they don't have at&t service? The verizon guy says at&t will cancel the customer after a short time and I confirmed this at the at&t store in Las Cruces (50 mins. drive).... "after about 6 calls in alamogordo at&t sends a letter requesting the customer to cancel service because it is costing at&t to use another company's network towers". Would at&t demand the phone back or the full cost of the iphone?
Currently with at&t (5 yrs), best service for my home - travel often, no complaints. Using a "smart" phone Cing 3125 with $19.95 data plan - slow, not very useable for excel files.
I may live in Las Cruces (where at&t service is available), but will commute/work in Alamogordo. Really looking for the iphone's application ability.... the phone is secondary, just don't want to carry multiple devices with the power cords/accessories when "one device could do it all" (in the right location).
Any thoughts on this are appreciated - would be ok with paying at&t to stay with them, but doesn't look possible. Of course I already plan on acting completely surprised by lack of service and having to give up the iphone/at&t package.... just want to hold on to the phone without any more $$$!
Ha! No doubt...
I saw that and just rolled my eyes.
Not that iReady has anything to do with the following, but the sooner Apple acts as service provider for their iPhone platform, the better.
Yeah, can anyone confirm what to expect for us current iPhone owners who are going to buy from Apple Store? Will they just confirm you are a current customer, sell you the phone, and you can activate at home? I plan on selling my current iPhone AFTER I get the 3G, just in case something crazy stupid happens.
One other question: when you get the new 3G phone and get rid of the other one, do you leave the SIM in the iPhone or transfer it to the new one? Because if I remember right, the 3G phone comes with a SIM ejector tool. I'm confused.
One other question: when you get the new 3G phone and get rid of the other one, do you leave the SIM in the iPhone or transfer it to the new one? Because if I remember right, the 3G phone comes with a SIM ejector tool. I'm confused.
No kidding. This is turning out to be a big clusterduck.
The more I think about it the more I think waiting a week or so after launch will be the way to go to buy the 3G. Remember what happened when the original was launched and people couldn't activate for hours and hours? I've been at an AT&T store where activation took over two hours. I literally went to go eat and came back at a later time while they sorted their crap out. I'd rather spend time at home waiting on iTunes activation than stand around a crowded AT&T store.
Oh well. Should be fun!!
iReady AT&T Sales folks aren't
Well after waiting in line almost a half hour during lunch today I have discovered that AT&T Sales folks are completely ignorant of what is going on, and their bosses are seagull managers (swoop down, **** all over everything and leave the mess behind).
Nobody at the local AT&T store has any idea of what iReady is, or the recommendation to file a credit application before the 11th. According to them, the only way to do that would be to buy another phone then bring it in and cancel it then buy the iPhone.
Why do I tremble EVERY time AT&T gets involved with this?
Well after waiting in line almost a half hour during lunch today I have discovered that AT&T Sales folks are completely ignorant of what is going on, and their bosses are seagull managers (swoop down, **** all over everything and leave the mess behind).
Nobody at the local AT&T store has any idea of what iReady is, or the recommendation to file a credit application before the 11th. According to them, the only way to do that would be to buy another phone then bring it in and cancel it then buy the iPhone.
Why do I tremble EVERY time AT&T gets involved with this?
So am I screwed, if I sold my iPhone?
After reading the Existing customer description it seems as if they want you to bring it in???
please help/confirm this!
thanks
After reading the Existing customer description it seems as if they want you to bring it in???
please help/confirm this!
thanks
Regarding 'handing down' (or selling) the iPhone 1.0....
Will the old $20 data plan (including 200 SMS) still be available to the recipients of the old iPhone, for activating via iTunes?
Or will they be forced to pay $30, for non-3G service, and no SMS?
Will the old $20 data plan (including 200 SMS) still be available to the recipients of the old iPhone, for activating via iTunes?
Or will they be forced to pay $30, for non-3G service, and no SMS?
unlocked original iphones?
What Im curious to know is, what is the fate of the original iphones? Say I have an original, and buy a 3g, and want to give/sell it to someone else. Does that mean they HAVE to get service with AT&T? because as I understand it, the original iPhone was sold un-subsidized, meaning it is my phone at this point to do with as I please. Now, considering the FCC has a law on the books saying that I can call up my cell provider and have my phone unlocked from the carrier, couldnt I do that with my original iPhone, thereby freeing it up to be used on other GSM networks without having to resort to "jailbreaking" it? Isnt AT&T legally obligated to unlock my original iphone at my request if I made one?
I would LOVE to know the answer to that one.
What Im curious to know is, what is the fate of the original iphones? Say I have an original, and buy a 3g, and want to give/sell it to someone else. Does that mean they HAVE to get service with AT&T? because as I understand it, the original iPhone was sold un-subsidized, meaning it is my phone at this point to do with as I please. Now, considering the FCC has a law on the books saying that I can call up my cell provider and have my phone unlocked from the carrier, couldnt I do that with my original iPhone, thereby freeing it up to be used on other GSM networks without having to resort to "jailbreaking" it? Isnt AT&T legally obligated to unlock my original iphone at my request if I made one?
I would LOVE to know the answer to that one.
So, if my friend gives me his iPhone on the 11th and I go home and activate it and then walk up to AT&T and say I want the upgrade they'll go ahead and do it? Why wouldn't AT&T think of this trick? I can literally get everyone I know on AT&T that isn't eligible to do this by just transferring the phone over and over again.
For starters, AT&T will get $36 from your first activation, and $18 from your second, for $54. And they might put a 30-day minimum or some other restriction so you're not within their trial period. And they could restrict the serial numbers. But if they get $54 plus $199 from multiple iPhone 3G buyers, plus the 2-year commitment, that's not a bad scenario for them.
It's ATT that's "not respecting other people." They know what the law is and they should darn well comply with it.
I have the same question...if I sold my original iPhone, but still have the plan and the SIM, do I just bring in the SIM? It shouldn't matter that I no longer have the actual iPhone, right?
Thank all of the unlockers / resellers for this. Since a quarter of more of the original iPhones were never activated on AT&T, AT&T and Apple decided to crack down and force activation at the time or purchase.
they didn't explain that well. just like they didn't explain the extra $200 issue.
the voicemails are on the phone. so if you change phones and presumably clean the phone data before you give it to someone else, the files go bye bye.
generally you are correct. but this time the huge line could be dozens and dozens of people and you will likely be talking to some temp hire that has no clue but a script he was told to say and do. you will insist, he will insist, you will demand to talk to the manager. the manager will be busy and take 20 minutes to get to you etc.
you really want to make a change, sue. seriously. get a group together, find a lawyer and sue. over the SS number, over the excessive upgrade price issue, over all of it. Because ATT seems to have gotten too big for their britches and Apple is stuck with it because of their contract.