Does boiling the bumper affect the cosmetic appearance at all? For example, does it cause any discoloration of the silicone or disrupt the glossiness of the plastic?
Seriously thinking about doing this. My bumper was a little loose, so I put some thin strips of gaffer's tape (wonderful stuff; think of duct tape with a velvety back and leaves no residue) inside on the bumper's anatomical left (right side as you face the phone). This solved the fitment issue for me, but I like the idea of not having to rely on a shim to make it fit, and there's other minor distortions that a shrinked fit might take care of.
Does not affect the physical appearance at all, everything is just like new.
Warping will happen a little at the 30 pin port opening and the headphone jack however keep it square while cooling and all is back to normal. By warping I mean it will bend inwards every so slightly, others the sides warped a little however just like I said it can be straightened out while cooling and it will be square again. You can dip it in the boiling water for a few seconds to straighten out again if required.
Mine originally moved I would say 2mm up and down and the sides were loose and could be pressed in same with the top and bottom, you could feel it clicking against the metal band when any side was pressed, now it doesn't budge even when trying forcefully to make it move, it is like it is part of the phone now.
I was not happy with the fit at all before boiling however now I am very pleased.