I went back and forth with both when they were released ultimately settling on the Max and haven't regretted it. Yes, there are some times I wish I had a smaller device like when im holding my son and trying to type with one hand but for the most part I'm loving the Max. The weight still bothers me at times though when I'm watching a long video and holding it for a while. I just hate that Apple didnt drop the Alpine green earlier I would have definitely got that lol