Agreed; precisely why many people consider it a gimmick.
If you usually use the laptop on a stand with an external keyboard, maybe it can be useful.
How? You are never that close to the top bar. That's a definite premeditated move to touch that strip.I think this will have 3D touch or something like that. Otherwise there will be accidental keypresses.
Unfortunately it's not innovation. The idea existed years ago. The only difference is that only the function keys are being converted to touch.
![]()
Acer experimented with such concept, the Acer Iconia, converting the whole keyboard with a touch screen display. Only difference is that there is no tactile feedback.
Not sure if this concept is patented.
If I thought I could live with only USB-C I might be interested. But I have too many USB 3.0 back up drives and thumb drives, I'm not going to replace them or deal with looking for an adapter every time I want to use them. Perhaps USB-C is too far ahead of it's time. I'll wait a few years for the rest of the world to catch up. I just can't see spending that much money on a laptop that won't do what I need it to do right out of the box. And no MagSafe is a deal-breaker for me.The world's first paperweight with an OLED touch bar! Innovation, isn't it? Something only Apple can do.
Actually I like it. Though we'll have to see how it will be implemented by Apple.
No hardware ESC key, no thanks. Plus the new low travel keyboard is not really meant for constant typing becauel thes pain after few hours of use.![]()
This. I think with the more space (even though this will be thinner than previous rMBP) it will be possible for Apple to give more travel for the butterfly keyboard.Lmao, I'm imagining someone crying in pain as they try to finish an email.
Myself and a few other coworkers type code all on the rMBs and we still have all of our fingers in tact. The MBPs may even have more travel.
I hope (and am almost assuming at this point) that Apple was smart about this and designed this to run separately, beneath the OS if you will, like a regular keyboard, so it won't ever freeze because of a program freezing or something.There is a flaw in the touch bar. What would it display when OS X hasn't been loaded yet? Or worse, what would it display if it were running Linux or Windows?
A power button will always be physical. That is the #1 rule in electronics.
See my above post, I think Apple has thought about this.I had one of these on a Lenovo and hated it. The thing never worked right. I was constantly trying to override the app or the system simply to shut down a program. I'll wait until they figure out this is a Bad Idea before getting another MBP.
Michael
Apple didn't invent the touchscreen but sure changed phones forever.Or like this:
![]()
But it is still a nice idea for Apple to use this technology.
This would never happen. The menu bar is very important for UX and I would be shocked if it went awayI guess, now there's no need for the menubar on the screen. In 10 years, Apple will reinvent the menubar and move it back to the screen. Wow!
I agree, they went too far with USB-C only device. For the next couple of years it would make more sense to have old ports onboard alongside the USB-C.If I thought I could live with only USB-C I might be interested. But I have too many USB 3.0 back up drives and thumb drives, I'm not going to replace them or deal with looking for an adapter every time I want to use them. Perhaps USB-C is too far ahead of it's time. I'll wait a few years for the rest of the world to catch up. I just can't see spending that much money on a laptop that won't do what I need it to do right out of the box. And no MagSafe is a deal-breaker for me.
Minority report: i find the creation of a touch bar pointless.
too bad apples implementation will probably not be that good.... at least not at first....I wouldn't mind something like that at all.
I'd guess there would be default function keys defined in firmware. I agree about the power button.There is a flaw in the touch bar. What would it display when OS X hasn't been loaded yet? Or worse, what would it display if it were running Linux or Windows?
A power button will always be physical. That is the #1 rule in electronics.
So all they need to do is have it work right and your objection goes away?I had one of these on a Lenovo and hated it. The thing never worked right. I was constantly trying to override the app or the system simply to shut down a program. I'll wait until they figure out this is a Bad Idea before getting another MBP.
You have to close your eyes.Where is the power button!
Looks awesome!
Following rumors suggesting the next-generation MacBook Pro will feature an OLED touch panel that replaces the function keys, designer Martin Hajek has created some renderings imagining what such a MacBook Pro might look like.
![]()
Hajek's design incorporates some recent information indicating the touch panel on the MacBook Pro could be contextual, with icons and imagery that changes based on the app that's in use. Hajek imagines music controls when Spotify is open, which morph into a download monitor when using Transmission.
![]()
Also included in the images is an example of Siri on the Mac, with the colorful Siri waveform depicted on the touch panel. Siri for Mac is rumored to be one of the main features coming in OS X 10.12, set to debut on Monday. Not pictured is a Touch ID button, a feature also expected to be included on or alongside the panel.
![]()
In addition to an OLED touch panel, Apple's next-generation MacBook Pro, which will come in 13 and 15-inch sizes, is expected to be thinner, incorporating metal injection mold-made hinges, thin speakers at the sides of the machine, and USB-C ports with Thunderbolt 3 support.
As has been seen in a leaked chassis image, the OLED panel will be located at the top of the keyboard, where the function keys would normally be positioned. KGI Securities analyst Ming-Chi Kuo has said the upcoming MacBook Pro will feature "the most significant upgrade ever undertaken by Apple."
We don't yet know when the new MacBook Pro will launch, but Kuo has said he expects it to debut in the fourth quarter of 2016.
Make sure to check out Hajek's website for the full selection of concept images.
Article Link: Concept Imagines What a Dynamic OLED Touch Panel Could Look Like on a MacBook Pro
With the camera, that ESC key can be an gesture.I want my legacy ESC key back![]()
Unfortunately it's not innovation. The idea existed years ago. The only difference is that only the function keys are being converted to touch.
![]()
Acer experimented with such concept, the Acer Iconia, converting the whole keyboard with a touch screen display. Only difference is that there is no tactile feedback.
Not sure if this concept is patented.