Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
My 3gs is looking good. the back is scratched quite a bit near and on the Apple logo and the chrome is scuffed but you can't see it till you get like a inch away.
 
Ok my iPhone 4 on Verizon is really starting to go downhill. Home button stopped working about 6 months ago (1 out of 20 clicks on a normal basis), battery life is dwindling (3 hrs of usage, 9 hrs of standby), and several apps randomly crash. Maybe I'm just complaining and wanting an excuse for the new iPhone but I'm more ready than ever to get my hands on it in hopefully a month or so!

my father had an ipad with your home button issue,but less sporadic, so like one in every three. he walked into the apple store, revealed his appleid purchase history to make sure it was his, they then examined and acknowledged the issue by replacing it on the spot. Just an fyi, if your device is jailbroken, restore it to default firmware before trying to turn it in the apple store.
 
My 4 was mint when I shipped to my mom 2 weeks ago after I upgraded to a 4s. I don't baby my phones or wrap them in plastic armor. I just treat them like the $500+ device they are unlike some people who treat them like old Gameboys.
 
My iPhone is in pretty good shape. There are some scratches on the back (days from when I didn't put a case on) but there are absolutely NO scratches on the screen. There are also some minor dings on the side (bezel) when my phone popped out of my pocket while I was getting off an SUV :(:(:( but I learned my lesson... always keep a case on
 
My iPhone 4 home button is so wrecked. I have to hit it several times to get it to do things like multitask. Sometimes 4-5 times. Can't wait to upgrade
 
Minor scratches to my iPhone 4 but generally pretty good condition. It's spent most of it's life inside an Otterbox though :)
My biggest complaint is that it seems to be getting slower and slower, no matter how many apps I remove.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.